marginaliaA PODCASTExplore all episodes

Art & Music

Mimesis as Make-Believe (Kendall L. Walton): How Fiction Moves Us

LISTEN TO THIS EPISODE

Source cover or paper first page: Mimesis as Make-Believe: On the Foundations of the Representational Arts

Kendall L. Walton examines representational art through the structure of games of make-believe.

Novels, paintings, films, and children’s toys can serve as props that prescribe what participants are to imagine.

The discussion follows fictional truths, principles of generation, and the role of audiences as participants.

Walton’s account of quasi-fear addresses how a fictional monster can produce an intense response in someone who knows it is not real.

Depiction, narration, and statements about fictional characters connect the experience of art with questions about language and existence.

Clarifications to the recording: Walton does not treat the Reality Principle and Mutual Belief Principle as a complete account; the checkered-tablecloth example illustrates conventions that those principles do not adequately explain (Chapter 4). Verbal representations need not have narrators (§9.5). Quasi-fear is a physiological-psychological condition, not merely a bodily reflex, and Walton’s analysis does not deny every genuine emotion prompted by fiction (§§5.2, 7.1). Searle’s account of pretended assertion expressly excludes an intent to deceive (§2.5). Fictional truths need not actually be imagined by anyone (§1.5). Claims about identical cognitive mechanisms, established evolutionary benefits, and social-media outrage go beyond what this book establishes; the final digital-media discussion is the hosts’ extrapolation.

Listen on the podcast website

Read about the original source: Mimesis as Make-Believe: On the Foundations of the Representational Arts

Part of Marginalia: books, papers, and ideas for learning and debate.