EPISODE TRANSCRIPT
Jews and Power (Ruth R. Wisse)
Explicit
Automatically transcribed from the episode audio. Some words and names may be inaccurate.
Listen to the episodeDownload textDownload captions
So picture Warsaw. It's the autumn of 1939. Right. Right after the invasion. Exactly. It's this chaotic, terrifying period just before the walls of the Warsaw ghetto actually go up. There are German soldiers standing in a courtyard and they're just openly harassing a young Jewish child. Just bullying him. Yeah. Physically tormenting this little boy right in the street. And the boy's mother runs out of the building. She intercepts these soldiers, scoops up her kid who's bruised and terrified, puts his cap back on his head, and just pulls him back inside. Right. And as she does this, she tells him in Yiddish, come inside the courtyard and be a mensch, which means be a decent human being. It's such a powerful moment. And it's actually the exact moment that Ruth Arwissa places at the very beginning of her book, Jews in Power. OK. Let's unpack this because today we are doing a deep dive into that exact book, Jews and Power. Yes. And I think it's important to note right off the bat that we're going to impartially examine Wyss's arguments here, looking at the historical texts she references to really understand this unique political history.
Right. Our mission today is to fundamentally rethink the Jewish historical experience, not just as a history of religion or like a history of victimhood, but as a deeply complex deliberate political strategy of a stateless people. Exactly. Because Wissa doesn't use that courtyard story just as some tragic anecdote. She uses it to expose the architecture of this 2000 year old political and psychological strategy. Because whether you are interested in history or the actual mechanics of power or even the vulnerabilities of modern democracies, this deep dive is going to completely reframe how you look at the relationship between morality and physical security. It really will. And going back to that word the mother used, mensch, it carries this entire moral ecosystem with it. Right. It's not just be a man. No, no.
In Yiddish, it means far more than just a man. It represents this ultimate standard of empathy and restraint and just ethical integrity. So her immediate visceral instinct isn't to teach her son how to fight back. Right. Or even to scream at the soldiers. Her instinct is to reinforce a moral boundary. She's basically instructing her son not to let their barbarism, you know, infect his humanity. Which is incredible. But that story didn't actually stay in that courtyard. No, it didn't. Two years later, it surfaces in London, far away from the occupation. Two prominent Jewish figures who had managed to escape Poland are discussing it. One is the famous Yiddish poet Itzik Mongir, and the other is Shmuel Ziegelboim.
And you really have to understand who Ziegelboim was to get the weight of this conversation. Right. He wasn't just a casual observer. Exactly. He was a prominent leader in the Jewish Socialist Bund. Which was huge, right? Massive. It was this secular movement in Eastern Europe that fiercely believed Jewish life and political autonomy should be built wherever Jews currently lived in the diaspora. So rather than seeking a separate state somewhere else. Right. And Ziegelblum had been forced into the Warsaw Ghetto, managed to escape, and was now in London serving in the Polish government in exile. Now tragically, he eventually commits public suicide in May 1943, right? Just to protest the allied indifference to the Holocaust. Yes. So this is a man deeply, intimately tied to the political survival of his people. And when he shares this courtyard story with Manger, the poet observes that no other people on the entire darkening continent of Europe took the injunction to be human quite as seriously as the Jews. Which is a beautiful testament to their moral fortitude. It is. But...
Wisse's analysis, and this is where she forces the reader into a highly uncomfortable space. She looks at this incident and identifies a fatal flaw in the mother's directive. Right. Because Wisse argues that becoming a mensch, like cultivating that profound moral decency, it has a non -negotiable prerequisite. You have to stay alive. Exactly. You have to be alive to be moral. And she introduces this concept here that really frames the entirety of our deep dive today. She calls it moral solipsism.
Yeah, moral solipsism. No, solipsism in classical philosophy is this idea that the only thing you can be sure exists is your own mind. Right. But when Wiss applies this to morality, she's describing a civilization that became so deeply preoccupied with its own internal ethical performance, its own moral purity, that it systematically ignored external reality. It's like being so intensely focused on passing this internal spiritual test that you completely feel to notice the literal existential threat standing right in front of you with a weapon. Exactly. And the contrast here with classical Western political theory is just striking. Oh, for sure. I mean, if you read Plato's Republic or if you look at the preamble to the U .S. Constitution, providing for the common defense is not an afterthought. No, it's the bedrock. Right. The American framers literally wrote, provide for the common defense. before they even got to securing the blessings of liberty.
But European Jews, entirely because of their statelessness over centuries, they lacked any political or geographic or military structure to defend their own civilization. They had this incredibly sophisticated internal society. But absolutely no external armor. Right. I was thinking about an analogy for this. It's like a team of brilliant software engineers, right? I like where this is going. And they spent generations building the most ethically sound, culturally rich, just beautifully designed operating system in the world. It is an absolute masterpiece of code.
But they intentionally refuse to build a firewall. They don't install antivirus software. They operate on this deeply held, almost theological assumption that the sheer beauty and moral purpose of their code will just naturally protect it from malicious actors. Oh, wow. Yeah. And so when the hackers inevitably arrive, the system is completely destroyed. Not because the code was bad, but because it had literally no mechanism for physical defense. That analogy captures the essence of Wyss's critique perfectly. The Jewish people built this extraordinary moral and cultural software, but the hardware of a sovereign state, that military firewall, it was entirely absent. But, you know, the immediate reaction most people have when reading Wyss's critique of the mother in Warsaw or of European Jews in 1939 is to push back on the fairness of that judgment. Sure, because it sounds like victim blaming at first glance. Exactly. But is it fair to judge this mother or European Jews for not anticipating the unprecedented horrors of a Holocaust? I mean, the industrial scale of the Nazi extermination was so unprecedented that the jurist Raphael Lemkin literally had to invent the word genocide in 1944. Just to give the world a vocabulary for it. Right. So how can you judge a mother for failing to build a firewall against a zero day exploit that the human mind hadn't even conceived of yet? Well, and Weiss is meticulous in clarifying this exact point. She states unequivocally that by no fair historical standard can European Jews be blamed for failing to anticipate German intentions.
Right. You can't blame a victim for failing to predict a crime that defied all known parameters of human history. Exactly. The focus of Jews in power is not about blaming the victims of the past. Her argument is directed squarely at the generations that come after the catastrophe. Okay, I see. The obligation of modern politics is to meticulously analyze the structural political deficiency that allowed that vulnerability to exist in the first place. So if the software gets wiped out... You don't blame the original engineers for not foreseeing an unimaginable virus. But you absolutely demand that every engineer who comes after them understands exactly why it crashed. Yes. And you demand that they build a firewall next time. Right. Because to ignore the political realities that fostered that extreme vulnerability would just be a catastrophic failure of historical memory. Which leads directly to a massive historical question. Right. If they lack the traditional defense system, like a state, an army, a border in 1939, when do they actually lose it? And how did they govern themselves in the meantime? Because we are conditioned to view history as this series of empires rising and falling through military conquest, right? Exactly.
A group of people without land or an army isn't supposed to survive for two millennia. They're supposed to assimilate or scatter or just be destroyed. Right. But to understand the origin of this anomaly, Wyss takes us all the way back to the year 70 CE. the defining political trauma of the Jewish people? Yes. Judea was a province of the Roman Empire, and a massive Jewish revolt had been launched against Roman rule. So the Roman general Titus, who later becomes emperor, is sent to crush it. And he didn't just defeat the Jewish forces, right? I mean, the Roman army laid siege to Jerusalem, breached the walls, burned the second temple to the ground, and just systematically dismantled the entire city. The sheer totality of that destruction is staggering.
The Roman historian Josephus, who actually witnessed the siege, he wrote that the city was leveled so completely that anyone visiting the site wouldn't even believe it had ever been inhabited. It's just wild to think about. And that loss of sovereignty, it essentially divided Jewish history into two distinct epics. You have the before. characterized by terrestrial sovereignty, a functioning state, a monarchy, an army, you know, a centralized geographic hub. And then you have the after.
Right. Defined by exile, diaspora and dispersion across the globe. But the memory of that loss didn't just fade into a historical footnote. It was aggressively institutionalized into the daily fabric of the culture. Oh, absolutely. It was engineered into the psychology of the people so they wouldn't forget who they were. Like, every time a Jewish person recites the grace after meals, there's a specific plea to rebuild Jerusalem. And the traditional words used to comfort a mourner explicitly connect their personal grief to the collective grief of the destruction. They mention mourning among the other mourners of Zion and Jerusalem. And of course, the Passover Seder, which is arguably the most universal Jewish ritual, it culminates every single year with a defiant declaration, next year in Jerusalem. But while the memory of sovereignty was fiercely maintained, the physical reality of it was just gone. And for a very long time, the dominant historical narrative was that 70 CE basically marked the death of Jewish politics.
Right. Whistle brings up Heinrich Graz here. Yes. Graz was one of the most influential Jewish historians of the 19th century. And his thesis was that prior to the Roman conquest, Judaism functioned as a, quote, constitution for a state. It was a true body politic. But... After the exile. After the exile, Graz argued, it ceased to be a political entity altogether. He said it transitioned into a pure religion, a spiritual community completely divorced from the mechanics of statecraft. Which, you know, that view held sway for a long time because our modern definition of politics is just deeply unimaginative. We equate politics with land and taxation enforced by police and standing armies. What's fascinating here is how Wisse points out a massive paradigm shift that occurred in historical scholarship around the 1970s. Oh, right. Scholars started digging into the archives of the diaspora. Exactly.
And they realized that Gretz was fundamentally wrong. The traditional definition of politics was just too narrow to capture what the Jews had actually accomplished. Here's where it gets really interesting, because modern political science rarely studies Jewish history, despite them running what might be the longest lasting political experiment in human history. That is Wyss's central thesis. The Jewish people didn't stop being a political entity when Rome burned their capital. Their politics just adapted. They remained highly organized. Highly organized. They maintained strict legal systems, elected authorities, social welfare networks, systems of taxation. They had all the hallmarks of a functioning, complex society. The crucial difference being that their politics had to operate entirely within the margins of other nations' sovereignty.
Right. It's a continuous, self -governing civilization operating across multiple continents, surviving under the rule of Roman emperors, Islamic caliphates, European monarchs, Russian czars. All without ever possessing a centralized state apparatus of their own. It just blows my mind. And as Wyss notes, these diaspora communities actually anticipated features of liberal democracy centuries before the Enlightenment even happened. Wait, really? Like what? Well, they developed internal systems predicated on the rule of law. Individual rights, communal responsibilities, elected authority, and a commitment to universal education. For males. Wow. Concepts that were entirely alien to the feudal European or Middle Eastern societies that were surrounding them at the time. But if they didn't have a state, what do their political institutions actually look like on a day -to -day basis? I mean, how do you enforce laws and maintain a cohesive society while living under the absolute control of foreign despots? To answer this, Wyss illuminates the mechanics of this stateless power through two specific examples.
One is a historical anecdote, and the other is a classic piece of folklore. Okay. Let's hear the anecdote first. It reads like a scene from a spy thriller, right? It really does. It takes place in Warsaw. during World War I. A German military intelligence officer is stationed in the city and he starts receiving these reports of suspicious coordinated activity in a specific courtyard. Suspicious how? Well, every evening, dozens of Jewish coachmen, these are rough working class men who drive transport wagons all day, are seen slipping into a building one after another.
So through the lens of military intelligence, this looks like a textbook conspiracy. Exactly. He thinks it's a secret cabal of laborers planning sabotage against the occupying German forces. So the officer raids the building, fully expecting to dismantle a rebel cell. But what does he actually find? He bursts into the room and finds these exhausted blue collar men sitting at long wooden tables, intensely poring over ancient texts, aggressively debating complex points of religious and civil law with a scholar. That is amazing. The officer must have been completely disarmed.
He was. He later notes in his reports that you couldn't find that level of intense voluntary dedication to intellectual and legal study among the elite students at the University of Berlin, let alone among, you know, day laborers. Right. And what that German officer inadvertently discovered was the actual decentralized infrastructure of Jewish political life. Yes. Their government wasn't a parliament building, it was a mobile constitution. The shared, rigorous study of a binding legal code was the mechanism that held the civilization together, regardless of whose geographic borders they happened to live within.
That is so cool. Okay, so what about the folklore example? Ah, the joke about the rabbi, the duke, and the dog. Right. We guess folklore and humor are often the sharpest tools for diagnosing how a culture actually survives. How's the joke go? So a tyrannical local duke decides on a whim that he is going to wipe out the local Jewish community. The community's rabbi goes to the duke's estate to plead for mercy. Standard setup. Right. And the rabbi says, your grace, if you spare my people, I promise you that within one year I will teach your favorite hunting dog how to speak our language. And the duke just goes for it? The duke, whose arrogance is only matched by his amusement, agrees. But he warns, if that dog isn't talking in 12 months, every Jew in the town dies. Oh, man. So the rabbi returns to his congregation, and the people are absolutely terrified. They surround him, shouting, Rabbi, have you lost your mind? You can't teach a dog to talk. You've just guaranteed our execution.
You've only delayed it. Now what does the rabbi say? The rabbi calmly looks at them and says, a year is a long time. A lot can happen in a year. Before the year is over, one of the two will croak, either the dog or the juke. It's just a brilliant piece of gallows humor. It is. But Wisset treats it as a masterclass in diaspora political strategy. It completely maps out the psychology of dealing with overwhelming coercive power when you literally have none. Because you can't meet the Duke on a battlefield. No. So you use his own ego against him. You buy time.
You rely on the inherent biological instability of dictatorships. Right. The rabbi isn't praying for the seed to part. He's just playing the actuarial odds of human mortality. It's an exercise in extreme unsentimental pragmatism. It is the essence of political accommodation. But to make this work across centuries, this pragmatic survival instinct had to be formally codified into law, right? They had to figure out a way to legally square their own strict divine laws with the undeniable reality that they were subjects of whatever king or czar held the sword. Exactly.
And this brings us to a foundational legal concept in Jewish history. an Aramaic principle from the Talmud known as Dina DeMalkuta Dina, which translates to, the law of the land is the law. Which on the surface, if you just read that translation, it sounds like absolute capitulation. Right. It sounds like the rabbis are simply saying, we surrender, whatever the king wants is fine. But Weiss explores how deeply subversive and brilliant this legal maneuver actually was. By issuing a decree within the Jewish legal framework that the state's law is valid, The rabbinic leaders were actually preserving their own internal authority.
It's like a corporate acquisition. How do you mean? Imagine a small, fiercely independent tech startup with a unique culture, and they get hostilely taken over by a massive, rigid conglomerate. The conglomerate immediately orders the startup to adopt their corporate HR software and their specific holiday schedule. The startup has no leverage to fight this. Right. They have to comply. But... Instead of just surrendering and letting the team feel conquered, the startup CEO sends out an internal memo. The memo says, as a matter of our internal company policy, which I am setting for us, we are going to adopt these new protocols.
Ah, I see. The end result is identical. They are using the conglomerate software. But the source of authority remains internal. It preserves their internal culture and chain of command. That is precisely how Dina de Malhuta Dina functioned. The Jewish leadership decreed that they were deferring to the secular ruler, but they were doing so on their own terms, under the umbrella of their own legal system. So they didn't internalize the status of a conquered, broken people? No, they were making a strategic, religiously sanctioned decision to comply in order to ensure communal survival. But wait, what was the limit? I mean, a system that says the law of the land is the law is incredibly dangerous if the ruler suddenly demands something completely unjust. You can't just absorb every despotic decree into your own legal code. Right. And the system had strict, heavily debated caveats. Weiss notes that the rabbinic consensus was that the rule only applied to the legitimate universal functions of a government.
Like what? like maintaining civil order, minting currency, or levying standardized taxes. OK, so normal state stuff. Right. But if the government's demands were deemed fundamentally illegitimate, for instance, if a tax was levied only on the Jewish population in a punitive manner, or if a law demanded murder, idolatry, or sexual immorality, the law of the land was entirely invalid. Oh, wow. And in those cases, resistance, even to the point of death, was required. Even with those copy -hots in place, the stark reality of what Weiss terms political complementarity meant Jews were utterly dependent on the ruler's goodwill.
Utterly. You are surviving by making yourself useful to the sovereign. It's a completely delegated existence. And the historical record demonstrates the brutal fragility of that existence, right? It does. I mean, Jewish communities sought the best possible relationship with local authorities out of sheer necessity. In the Middle Ages, within the Islamic Empire, the Gaon, the head of the Jewish Academy in Babylon, he wielded immense religious and juridical authority over the Jewish world. But as the historian Shlomo Goite noted, the Gaon's actual practical power was a mirage.
It depended entirely on the Muslim government because they were the ones who controlled the police and the military forces necessary to actually enforce anything. We see the ultimate tragic failure of this strategy in Christian Spain, too. Right. The expulsion. Yeah. For centuries, you had the Golden Age of Spain, the convivencia, where Jewish communities just thrived. They were deeply woven into the fabric of the royal courts as financiers, physicians, translators, chief diplomats. They felt secure because they were indispensable to the state. Exactly. But that security was an illusion based entirely on utility.
The moment the political and religious winds shifted at the end of the 15th century. Their utility couldn't offset the religious fervor of the Inquisition. And King Ferdinand and Queen Isabella, who had once been pragmatic protectors, they ultimately signed the Edict of Expulsion in 1492. A civilization that had thrived there for centuries was just wholesale evicted overnight. Which raises this massive question. How could a people endure centuries of this precarious, humiliating dependence? I mean, how do you get expelled from Spain or massacred in the Polish -Lithuanian Commonwealth centuries later without completely despairing or just giving up and assimilating?
Pragmatism and legal loopholes aren't enough to sustain a people through that level of trauma. No way. They needed a theological bedrock. And Wisk points us toward exactly that, the Covenant of Sinai. According to the foundational narrative of the Jewish people, their ultimate treaty Their primary political alliance was not negotiated with a local duke or an emperor or a czar. It was negotiated with God. Yes. The treaty was made directly with God. So they are situating themselves politically within a hierarchy where the earthly ruler is just middle management.
Right. The supreme power is actually running the board. Precisely. Wissah draws on the work of the historian Yitzhak Baer, writing in 1936, which, you know, was a profoundly dark time for European Jewry. Oh, for sure. Baer argued that the day to day fate of the Jewish people in the diaspora was completely comprehended through their firm faith in the direct influence of God upon history. He insisted this wasn't some naive, you know, timid spinning out of old dreams. It was a rigorous, fully functional system of religious concepts. So Wiesa's arguing that in their own minds, historically, the Jews never viewed themselves as truly powerless. That is the crux of their psychological endurance. When we look back, we see a marginalized, stateless people at the mercy of heavily armed empires, but their internal framework processed reality entirely differently.
Because they believed their ultimate protector was omnipotent. Right. So if they suffered, it was never interpreted as proof that the local duke was more powerful than God. Instead, the suffering was internalized as part of a divine plan. Maybe it was a test of their fidelity to the covenant or a punishment for their own communal sins. So every compromise wasn't a defeat. It was a tactical retreat authorized by the highest power in the universe. Exactly. Wisse describes this phenomenon as the capacity for postponed political gratification. Postponed political gratification. I like that. You can endure the intense humiliations and physical dangers of the present because you possess absolute certainty in the ultimate divine justice of the future.
The scales will eventually be balanced. But doesn't relying on divine justice eventually run out of steam if the physical suffering becomes too immense? I mean, you can only tell yourself that the suffering is a divine test for so long. And you've hit on exactly where Wyss's analysis turns incredibly dark. The strategy of extreme political accommodation combined with this internal unshakable sense of spiritual superiority. It didn't just fail to protect them in the modern era. It provoked a backlash. It actively provoked a paranoid, deadly psychological backlash from the very nations hosting them. This is the boomerang effect. The precise tools the Jewish people evolved over 2000 years to survive were inverted and weaponized against them. Right. And to understand how this happened, we have to trace the evolution of antisemitism, because modern political hatred didn't just spring out of nowhere. It evolved from a theological rivalry. How so? Well, in the early centuries of Christian dominance in Europe, the vulnerability of the Jews was interpreted entirely through a theological lens. The Church Fathers, notably Augustine, developed what's known as the Witness Doctrine. What's that? This doctrine held that the Jews must not be completely eradicated because they needed to survive as wandering degraded witnesses to the truth of Christianity. Wow.
Their physical powerlessness, their exile, their suffering. It was all held up by the church as tangible theological proof that God had abandoned the old covenant and transferred his favor to the Christians. So the degradation of the Jew was necessary evidence of Christianity's triumph. Exactly. But the Jews didn't cooperate with this narrative. They were supposed to act like a defeated, dying relic, but instead they maintained a vibrant, highly literate, intensely communal civilization right in the middle of Christian Europe. And Weiss points out that this sheer resilience caused immense intellectual and moral insecurity among Christian theologians and rulers. Oh, massive insecurity. The church possessed all the political and military power, yet they felt insecure because the Jews simply refused to disappear. As Weiss notes, if the dominant power truly felt capable of defeating the Jews on intellectual or theological merits, it wouldn't have had to rig public debates or burn the Talmud or resort to state -sanctioned violence. The reliance on coercive force portrayed a deep underlying insecurity about their own narrative. Right. But the true horror Weiss details is what happens when Europe transitions out of the Middle Ages. We move into the era of the Enlightenment and Emancipation. Right. Jews are finally allowed out of the ghettos. They can enter secular society, attend universities, establish businesses. And as they do, the hatred doesn't disappear. It mutates. It goes from theological bigotry into a modern political weapon. OK, and if we connect this to the bigger picture, this is the critical mechanism of modern political anti -Semitism. Because people often lazily attribute it to just xenophobia. You know, a simple dislike of the unlike. But in the 19th and 20th centuries, it was systematically weaponized for specific political ends. You have to remember, the Jews had spent two millennia honing the skills necessary to survive, organize, and compete without relying on coercive military force. Right, they had to be smarter, more adaptable. So when they were finally allowed into liberal democracies, systems that supposedly operate on merit, law, trade, and education rather than brute force, they were uniquely positioned to excel. Which brings us to Wilhelm Marr. Yes. Marr was a German agitator who literally coined the term anti -Semitism in 1879. And he wasn't arguing theology at all.
Not at all. He wrote a wildly popular pamphlet called The Victory of Jewry Over Germindom. He looked at the Jews and saw people without an army, without a country, who were suddenly succeeding in banking, journalism, medicine, and the arts. But instead of recognizing that this success was the result of a 2 ,000 -year survival strategy focused on literacy and adaptability, Marner's contemporaries reversed cause and effect. Exactly. They looked at this success and argued that it was evidence of a vast, insidious conspiracy to achieve world domination. The authors of the infamous fabricated text, The Protocols of the Elders of Zion, operated on the exact same premise.
The psychological projection here is just astounding. I mean, the European powers, the Germans, the British, the Russians, were the ones actively trying to conquer the globe through military imperialism and colonialism. Yes. Yet they projected that exact desire for world domination onto the one group of people who had explicitly renounced physical conquest for 2000 years. It is profound projection. Wyss argues that anti -Semites interpreted Jewish deference to power as a covert bid for world power. Because the Jewish community was decentralized and democratic, anti -Semites viewed it as a shadowy international cabal. So they claimed Jews were weaponizing liberalism to weaken traditional monarchies. Right, softening the ground so they could take over from behind the scenes. And there was a dark joke from the text that you have to share because it perfectly captures the cognitive dissonance of this conspiracy.
Oh, the newspaper joke. Yes, so one Jew is walking through a park and sees his friend sitting on a bench calmly reading an anti -Semitic right -wing newspaper. He asks his friend, why on earth are you reading that garbage? And what does he say? The friend replies, when I read the Jewish press, all I read about is our disasters, pogroms, poverty, exile, and misery. But when I read the anti -Semitic press, I get the refreshing news that we control all the banks, we run all the governments, and we own the world. It's so good. It perfectly distills the absurdity of the conspiracy.
But, you know, why is it that the more Jews contributed to a society, the more vulnerable they seem to become to these specific political attacks? Because antisemitism functions as a highly adaptable protean political instrument. When a modern nation state experiences a crisis, say, a severe economic depression or a humiliating defeat in war, The ruling political class needs simple explanations to feed to an angry, frightened population. You can't easily explain the complexities of macroeconomic shifts to a starving populace. No, but a demagogue can point to a distinct, highly visible minority and say, the Rothschilds are stealing your wealth, or Jewish intellectuals are intentionally corroding our traditional culture. And the Jewish lack of a coercive military defense made them the absolute perfect risk -free scapegoat. You could attack them physically and politically, knowing with absolute certainty that there was no sovereign state army marching over the border to retaliate on their behalf. Exactly. The very strategy that kept them alive in the Middle Ages, quiet accommodation, remaining inconspicuous, became a deathtrap in the modern era of mass politics and ethno -nationalism.
Which leads directly to the horrific culmination of this scapegoating in the 20th century. And with that, The Jewish political strategy had to fundamentally change, leading to deep internal contradictions today. Yes. The Holocaust laid bare the absolute failure of the 2000 -year -old strategy of diaspora politics. The realization that accommodation was no longer viable led directly to the creation of the modern state of Israel. The Jewish people re -entered the realm of terrestrial sovereignty. But as Weiss points out in the final sections of her book, securing a geographic border and building an army doesn't magically erase the psychology that has been ingrained over two millennia. The transition from statelessness to sovereignty is fraught with immense internal contradiction. Right. Weiss discusses this tension among modern Jewish thinkers regarding power.
For example, she brings up David Bialy. Yes, Bialy is a historian who wrote extensively on Jewish power. And Wisse notes that he viewed the long diaspora period as an era of relative stability, referring to the internal governance of the rabbinic courts. So he almost seemed to prefer the clean moral lines of that stateless era over the anxieties of actual self -rule. That's Wisse's critique, yes. She also points to S. Ansky, the renowned writer and ethnographer.
Before World War I, Ansky led these massive ethnographic expeditions, collecting Jewish folklore. And he deeply romanticized this culture precisely because it demonstrated an aversion to physical heroism. He favored spiritual struggle, right? Exactly. He celebrated the fact that Jewish folk tales rejected the nightly battles or military glory that dominate other European folklore. But Wisse gives a really strong pushback here. She argues that Judaism never actually glorified powerlessness. I mean, she points directly to the Psalms, which are full of visceral appeals to a mighty, avenging God to destroy enemies.
Right. The tradition didn't worship weakness. It simply outsourced the execution of physical power to the Almighty. Wisse is essentially diagnosing a diaspora hangover. A diaspora hangover. Yeah. For 2000 years, Jewish morality was inextricably linked to not possessing coercive power. If you don't have an army, you don't have to make the morally agonizing decisions that come with deploying one. You can maintain a pristine, theoretical moral high ground. But with the state of Israel, that dynamic has shifted. And to understand the danger of clinging to that diaspora mindset, Wees brings in Jean -Francois Ravel's How Democracies Perish. Yes. Ravel warned that modern democratic societies are uniquely vulnerable because they are often beset by internal guilt. They turn inward, constantly questioning their own legitimacy and try to accommodate or appease existential threats rather than forcefully repelling them.
Because they're terrified of compromising their own moral purity. Exactly. And we supplies this directly to the Jewish condition. She argues that if modern Jews no longer rely on God to physically intervene, they must provide that missing dimension of physical power themselves, or it is quite literally a suicide pact. It reminds me of the quote on the back cover of the book from Cynthia Ozick. She asks if political independence has truly altered the venerable Jewish psychology of appeasement. It's a terrifying implication. Right. It's wise saying that the exact survival skills that kept the Jewish people alive for 2000 years, the instinct to accommodate, to buy time, are the exact same traits that threaten them today if they don't adapt. She is confirming exactly that. The politics of accommodation worked only when there was no other choice. Today, with the state of Israel, the dynamic has fundamentally shifted. Israel's ability to withstand assailants now affects the security of other democratic nations, making the Jewish political condition a bellwether for the survival of global democracy itself. Stepping back, this has been such a profound journey. We've seen how a people redefined politics to survive without a state, how their reliance on a higher power gave them the stamina to endure, and how their very success bred paranoid conspiracy theories. And how the transition back to sovereign power challenges a 2000 year old mindset. Right.
Which leaves us with a final thought for you, the listener to ponder. Wist suggests that democracies today suffer from the same guilt producing accusations and hesitation to use power that historically plagued stateless Jews. So as you look at the world today, ask yourself, in our quest to be the moral mensch in the courtyard, are modern democracies ignoring the wolves at the gate? Can a society be so committed to its own moral purity that it forgets it actually has to survive to practice it? Thank you so much for joining us on this deep dive. Keep asking the hard questions, keep seeking out multiple perspectives, and we'll see you next time.