1 00:00:00,000 --> 00:00:03,759 So picture Warsaw. It's the autumn of 1939. Right. 2 00:00:03,839 --> 00:00:05,960 Right after the invasion. Exactly. It's this 3 00:00:05,960 --> 00:00:08,880 chaotic, terrifying period just before the walls 4 00:00:08,880 --> 00:00:11,980 of the Warsaw ghetto actually go up. There are 5 00:00:11,980 --> 00:00:15,199 German soldiers standing in a courtyard and they're 6 00:00:15,199 --> 00:00:17,920 just openly harassing a young Jewish child. Just 7 00:00:17,920 --> 00:00:20,859 bullying him. Yeah. Physically tormenting this 8 00:00:20,859 --> 00:00:22,980 little boy right in the street. And the boy's 9 00:00:22,980 --> 00:00:25,359 mother runs out of the building. She intercepts 10 00:00:25,359 --> 00:00:27,960 these soldiers, scoops up her kid who's bruised 11 00:00:27,960 --> 00:00:30,239 and terrified, puts his cap back on his head, 12 00:00:30,300 --> 00:00:32,799 and just pulls him back inside. Right. And as 13 00:00:32,799 --> 00:00:35,200 she does this, she tells him in Yiddish, come 14 00:00:35,200 --> 00:00:38,259 inside the courtyard and be a mensch, which means 15 00:00:38,259 --> 00:00:41,060 be a decent human being. It's such a powerful 16 00:00:41,060 --> 00:00:43,840 moment. And it's actually the exact moment that 17 00:00:43,840 --> 00:00:45,840 Ruth Arwissa places at the very beginning of 18 00:00:45,840 --> 00:00:48,799 her book, Jews in Power. OK. Let's unpack this 19 00:00:48,799 --> 00:00:51,640 because today we are doing a deep dive into that 20 00:00:51,640 --> 00:00:54,320 exact book, Jews and Power. Yes. And I think 21 00:00:54,320 --> 00:00:56,340 it's important to note right off the bat that 22 00:00:56,340 --> 00:00:59,020 we're going to impartially examine Wyss's arguments 23 00:00:59,020 --> 00:01:01,619 here, looking at the historical texts she references 24 00:01:01,619 --> 00:01:04,900 to really understand this unique political history. 25 00:01:05,200 --> 00:01:07,780 Right. Our mission today is to fundamentally 26 00:01:07,780 --> 00:01:11,120 rethink the Jewish historical experience, not 27 00:01:11,120 --> 00:01:14,000 just as a history of religion or like a history 28 00:01:14,000 --> 00:01:17,569 of victimhood, but as a deeply complex deliberate 29 00:01:17,569 --> 00:01:20,489 political strategy of a stateless people. Exactly. 30 00:01:20,810 --> 00:01:22,890 Because Wissa doesn't use that courtyard story 31 00:01:22,890 --> 00:01:25,629 just as some tragic anecdote. She uses it to 32 00:01:25,629 --> 00:01:28,870 expose the architecture of this 2000 year old 33 00:01:28,870 --> 00:01:31,329 political and psychological strategy. Because 34 00:01:31,329 --> 00:01:34,049 whether you are interested in history or the 35 00:01:34,049 --> 00:01:36,609 actual mechanics of power or even the vulnerabilities 36 00:01:36,609 --> 00:01:39,030 of modern democracies, this deep dive is going 37 00:01:39,030 --> 00:01:41,290 to completely reframe how you look at the relationship 38 00:01:41,290 --> 00:01:44,430 between morality and physical security. It really 39 00:01:44,430 --> 00:01:47,129 will. And going back to that word the mother 40 00:01:47,129 --> 00:01:51,469 used, mensch, it carries this entire moral ecosystem 41 00:01:51,469 --> 00:01:54,629 with it. Right. It's not just be a man. No, no. 42 00:01:54,829 --> 00:01:57,549 In Yiddish, it means far more than just a man. 43 00:01:57,969 --> 00:02:01,030 It represents this ultimate standard of empathy 44 00:02:01,030 --> 00:02:04,209 and restraint and just ethical integrity. So 45 00:02:04,209 --> 00:02:07,230 her immediate visceral instinct isn't to teach 46 00:02:07,230 --> 00:02:09,770 her son how to fight back. Right. Or even to 47 00:02:09,770 --> 00:02:12,909 scream at the soldiers. Her instinct is to reinforce 48 00:02:12,909 --> 00:02:15,419 a moral boundary. She's basically instructing 49 00:02:15,419 --> 00:02:17,840 her son not to let their barbarism, you know, 50 00:02:17,960 --> 00:02:20,060 infect his humanity. Which is incredible. But 51 00:02:20,060 --> 00:02:22,400 that story didn't actually stay in that courtyard. 52 00:02:22,639 --> 00:02:24,840 No, it didn't. Two years later, it surfaces in 53 00:02:24,840 --> 00:02:28,080 London, far away from the occupation. Two prominent 54 00:02:28,080 --> 00:02:30,060 Jewish figures who had managed to escape Poland 55 00:02:30,060 --> 00:02:32,599 are discussing it. One is the famous Yiddish 56 00:02:32,599 --> 00:02:35,800 poet Itzik Mongir, and the other is Shmuel Ziegelboim. 57 00:02:36,300 --> 00:02:38,419 And you really have to understand who Ziegelboim 58 00:02:38,419 --> 00:02:41,300 was to get the weight of this conversation. Right. 59 00:02:41,300 --> 00:02:43,710 He wasn't just a casual observer. Exactly. He 60 00:02:43,710 --> 00:02:46,110 was a prominent leader in the Jewish Socialist 61 00:02:46,110 --> 00:02:48,949 Bund. Which was huge, right? Massive. It was 62 00:02:48,949 --> 00:02:51,729 this secular movement in Eastern Europe that 63 00:02:51,729 --> 00:02:54,129 fiercely believed Jewish life and political autonomy 64 00:02:54,129 --> 00:02:56,550 should be built wherever Jews currently lived 65 00:02:56,550 --> 00:02:59,590 in the diaspora. So rather than seeking a separate 66 00:02:59,590 --> 00:03:02,889 state somewhere else. Right. And Ziegelblum had 67 00:03:02,889 --> 00:03:05,110 been forced into the Warsaw Ghetto, managed to 68 00:03:05,110 --> 00:03:07,409 escape, and was now in London serving in the 69 00:03:07,409 --> 00:03:09,969 Polish government in exile. Now tragically, he 70 00:03:09,969 --> 00:03:12,889 eventually commits public suicide in May 1943, 71 00:03:13,409 --> 00:03:15,430 right? Just to protest the allied indifference 72 00:03:15,430 --> 00:03:18,569 to the Holocaust. Yes. So this is a man deeply, 73 00:03:18,909 --> 00:03:21,310 intimately tied to the political survival of 74 00:03:21,310 --> 00:03:23,650 his people. And when he shares this courtyard 75 00:03:23,650 --> 00:03:26,169 story with Manger, the poet observes that no 76 00:03:26,169 --> 00:03:29,129 other people on the entire darkening continent 77 00:03:29,129 --> 00:03:32,189 of Europe took the injunction to be human quite 78 00:03:32,189 --> 00:03:34,590 as seriously as the Jews. Which is a beautiful 79 00:03:34,590 --> 00:03:37,449 testament to their moral fortitude. It is. But... 80 00:03:37,439 --> 00:03:40,020 Wisse's analysis, and this is where she forces 81 00:03:40,020 --> 00:03:42,520 the reader into a highly uncomfortable space. 82 00:03:43,060 --> 00:03:45,919 She looks at this incident and identifies a fatal 83 00:03:45,919 --> 00:03:49,379 flaw in the mother's directive. Right. Because 84 00:03:49,379 --> 00:03:52,419 Wisse argues that becoming a mensch, like cultivating 85 00:03:52,419 --> 00:03:56,080 that profound moral decency, it has a non -negotiable 86 00:03:56,080 --> 00:03:58,719 prerequisite. You have to stay alive. Exactly. 87 00:03:58,879 --> 00:04:02,860 You have to be alive to be moral. And she introduces 88 00:04:02,860 --> 00:04:05,439 this concept here that really frames the entirety 89 00:04:05,439 --> 00:04:08,639 of our deep dive today. She calls it moral solipsism. 90 00:04:08,819 --> 00:04:12,560 Yeah, moral solipsism. No, solipsism in classical 91 00:04:12,560 --> 00:04:15,039 philosophy is this idea that the only thing you 92 00:04:15,039 --> 00:04:17,579 can be sure exists is your own mind. Right. But 93 00:04:17,579 --> 00:04:20,519 when Wiss applies this to morality, she's describing 94 00:04:20,519 --> 00:04:23,759 a civilization that became so deeply preoccupied 95 00:04:23,759 --> 00:04:26,639 with its own internal ethical performance, its 96 00:04:26,639 --> 00:04:30,220 own moral purity, that it systematically ignored 97 00:04:30,220 --> 00:04:33,009 external reality. It's like being so intensely 98 00:04:33,009 --> 00:04:36,730 focused on passing this internal spiritual test 99 00:04:36,730 --> 00:04:39,889 that you completely feel to notice the literal 100 00:04:39,889 --> 00:04:41,870 existential threat standing right in front of 101 00:04:41,870 --> 00:04:44,649 you with a weapon. Exactly. And the contrast 102 00:04:44,649 --> 00:04:46,889 here with classical Western political theory 103 00:04:46,889 --> 00:04:49,829 is just striking. Oh, for sure. I mean, if you 104 00:04:49,829 --> 00:04:52,029 read Plato's Republic or if you look at the preamble 105 00:04:52,029 --> 00:04:54,949 to the U .S. Constitution, providing for the 106 00:04:54,949 --> 00:04:56,870 common defense is not an afterthought. No, it's 107 00:04:56,870 --> 00:04:59,209 the bedrock. Right. The American framers literally 108 00:04:59,209 --> 00:05:01,600 wrote, provide for the common defense. before 109 00:05:01,600 --> 00:05:03,939 they even got to securing the blessings of liberty. 110 00:05:04,399 --> 00:05:07,160 But European Jews, entirely because of their 111 00:05:07,160 --> 00:05:09,540 statelessness over centuries, they lacked any 112 00:05:09,540 --> 00:05:13,399 political or geographic or military structure 113 00:05:13,399 --> 00:05:15,860 to defend their own civilization. They had this 114 00:05:15,860 --> 00:05:18,399 incredibly sophisticated internal society. But 115 00:05:18,399 --> 00:05:21,339 absolutely no external armor. Right. I was thinking 116 00:05:21,339 --> 00:05:23,620 about an analogy for this. It's like a team of 117 00:05:23,620 --> 00:05:26,019 brilliant software engineers, right? I like where 118 00:05:26,019 --> 00:05:28,079 this is going. And they spent generations building 119 00:05:28,079 --> 00:05:31,680 the most ethically sound, culturally rich, just 120 00:05:31,680 --> 00:05:33,459 beautifully designed operating system in the 121 00:05:33,459 --> 00:05:35,420 world. It is an absolute masterpiece of code. 122 00:05:36,040 --> 00:05:39,259 But they intentionally refuse to build a firewall. 123 00:05:40,240 --> 00:05:43,199 They don't install antivirus software. They operate 124 00:05:43,199 --> 00:05:46,759 on this deeply held, almost theological assumption 125 00:05:46,759 --> 00:05:49,800 that the sheer beauty and moral purpose of their 126 00:05:49,800 --> 00:05:52,240 code will just naturally protect it from malicious 127 00:05:52,240 --> 00:05:55,980 actors. Oh, wow. Yeah. And so when the hackers 128 00:05:55,980 --> 00:05:58,920 inevitably arrive, the system is completely destroyed. 129 00:05:59,180 --> 00:06:02,040 Not because the code was bad, but because it 130 00:06:02,040 --> 00:06:04,680 had literally no mechanism for physical defense. 131 00:06:05,680 --> 00:06:08,160 That analogy captures the essence of Wyss's critique 132 00:06:08,160 --> 00:06:11,240 perfectly. The Jewish people built this extraordinary 133 00:06:11,240 --> 00:06:14,180 moral and cultural software, but the hardware 134 00:06:14,180 --> 00:06:16,819 of a sovereign state, that military firewall, 135 00:06:17,079 --> 00:06:20,300 it was entirely absent. But, you know, the immediate 136 00:06:20,300 --> 00:06:22,459 reaction most people have when reading Wyss's 137 00:06:22,459 --> 00:06:25,779 critique of the mother in Warsaw or of European 138 00:06:25,779 --> 00:06:28,959 Jews in 1939 is to push back on the fairness 139 00:06:29,180 --> 00:06:31,959 of that judgment. Sure, because it sounds like 140 00:06:31,959 --> 00:06:35,120 victim blaming at first glance. Exactly. But 141 00:06:35,120 --> 00:06:38,620 is it fair to judge this mother or European Jews 142 00:06:38,620 --> 00:06:41,259 for not anticipating the unprecedented horrors 143 00:06:41,259 --> 00:06:44,160 of a Holocaust? I mean, the industrial scale 144 00:06:44,160 --> 00:06:46,819 of the Nazi extermination was so unprecedented 145 00:06:46,819 --> 00:06:50,180 that the jurist Raphael Lemkin literally had 146 00:06:50,180 --> 00:06:53,279 to invent the word genocide in 1944. Just to 147 00:06:53,279 --> 00:06:56,110 give the world a vocabulary for it. Right. So 148 00:06:56,110 --> 00:06:58,069 how can you judge a mother for failing to build 149 00:06:58,069 --> 00:07:01,870 a firewall against a zero day exploit that the 150 00:07:01,870 --> 00:07:04,870 human mind hadn't even conceived of yet? Well, 151 00:07:05,009 --> 00:07:07,709 and Weiss is meticulous in clarifying this exact 152 00:07:07,709 --> 00:07:10,930 point. She states unequivocally that by no fair 153 00:07:10,930 --> 00:07:13,189 historical standard can European Jews be blamed 154 00:07:13,189 --> 00:07:15,569 for failing to anticipate German intentions. 155 00:07:15,949 --> 00:07:17,689 Right. You can't blame a victim for failing to 156 00:07:17,689 --> 00:07:19,670 predict a crime that defied all known parameters 157 00:07:19,670 --> 00:07:22,560 of human history. Exactly. The focus of Jews 158 00:07:22,560 --> 00:07:24,939 in power is not about blaming the victims of 159 00:07:24,939 --> 00:07:28,019 the past. Her argument is directed squarely at 160 00:07:28,019 --> 00:07:30,720 the generations that come after the catastrophe. 161 00:07:31,060 --> 00:07:33,860 Okay, I see. The obligation of modern politics 162 00:07:33,860 --> 00:07:36,660 is to meticulously analyze the structural political 163 00:07:36,660 --> 00:07:38,860 deficiency that allowed that vulnerability to 164 00:07:38,860 --> 00:07:41,360 exist in the first place. So if the software 165 00:07:41,360 --> 00:07:43,579 gets wiped out... You don't blame the original 166 00:07:43,579 --> 00:07:45,459 engineers for not foreseeing an unimaginable 167 00:07:45,459 --> 00:07:48,899 virus. But you absolutely demand that every engineer 168 00:07:48,899 --> 00:07:50,980 who comes after them understands exactly why 169 00:07:50,980 --> 00:07:53,920 it crashed. Yes. And you demand that they build 170 00:07:53,920 --> 00:07:56,660 a firewall next time. Right. Because to ignore 171 00:07:56,660 --> 00:07:59,019 the political realities that fostered that extreme 172 00:07:59,019 --> 00:08:01,240 vulnerability would just be a catastrophic failure 173 00:08:01,240 --> 00:08:03,939 of historical memory. Which leads directly to 174 00:08:03,939 --> 00:08:06,600 a massive historical question. Right. If they 175 00:08:06,600 --> 00:08:08,439 lack the traditional defense system, like a state, 176 00:08:08,540 --> 00:08:11,680 an army, a border in 1939, when do they actually 177 00:08:11,680 --> 00:08:13,939 lose it? And how did they govern themselves in 178 00:08:13,939 --> 00:08:16,160 the meantime? Because we are conditioned to view 179 00:08:16,160 --> 00:08:19,120 history as this series of empires rising and 180 00:08:19,120 --> 00:08:22,019 falling through military conquest, right? Exactly. 181 00:08:22,500 --> 00:08:24,319 A group of people without land or an army isn't 182 00:08:24,319 --> 00:08:26,439 supposed to survive for two millennia. They're 183 00:08:26,439 --> 00:08:28,620 supposed to assimilate or scatter or just be 184 00:08:28,620 --> 00:08:31,180 destroyed. Right. But to understand the origin 185 00:08:31,180 --> 00:08:33,879 of this anomaly, Wyss takes us all the way back 186 00:08:33,879 --> 00:08:37,399 to the year 70 CE. the defining political trauma 187 00:08:37,399 --> 00:08:40,139 of the Jewish people? Yes. Judea was a province 188 00:08:40,139 --> 00:08:43,379 of the Roman Empire, and a massive Jewish revolt 189 00:08:43,379 --> 00:08:46,299 had been launched against Roman rule. So the 190 00:08:46,299 --> 00:08:48,559 Roman general Titus, who later becomes emperor, 191 00:08:48,799 --> 00:08:51,039 is sent to crush it. And he didn't just defeat 192 00:08:51,039 --> 00:08:53,720 the Jewish forces, right? I mean, the Roman army 193 00:08:53,720 --> 00:08:56,799 laid siege to Jerusalem, breached the walls, 194 00:08:57,259 --> 00:08:59,500 burned the second temple to the ground, and just 195 00:08:59,500 --> 00:09:01,860 systematically dismantled the entire city. The 196 00:09:01,860 --> 00:09:04,519 sheer totality of that destruction is staggering. 197 00:09:04,799 --> 00:09:07,519 The Roman historian Josephus, who actually witnessed 198 00:09:07,519 --> 00:09:10,299 the siege, he wrote that the city was leveled 199 00:09:10,299 --> 00:09:12,960 so completely that anyone visiting the site wouldn't 200 00:09:12,960 --> 00:09:16,000 even believe it had ever been inhabited. It's 201 00:09:16,000 --> 00:09:19,120 just wild to think about. And that loss of sovereignty, 202 00:09:19,120 --> 00:09:21,840 it essentially divided Jewish history into two 203 00:09:21,840 --> 00:09:25,009 distinct epics. You have the before. characterized 204 00:09:25,009 --> 00:09:28,169 by terrestrial sovereignty, a functioning state, 205 00:09:28,450 --> 00:09:31,549 a monarchy, an army, you know, a centralized 206 00:09:31,549 --> 00:09:34,830 geographic hub. And then you have the after. 207 00:09:35,090 --> 00:09:38,909 Right. Defined by exile, diaspora and dispersion 208 00:09:38,909 --> 00:09:41,090 across the globe. But the memory of that loss 209 00:09:41,090 --> 00:09:43,090 didn't just fade into a historical footnote. 210 00:09:43,269 --> 00:09:46,090 It was aggressively institutionalized into the 211 00:09:46,090 --> 00:09:48,070 daily fabric of the culture. Oh, absolutely. 212 00:09:48,110 --> 00:09:50,730 It was engineered into the psychology of the 213 00:09:50,730 --> 00:09:52,610 people so they wouldn't forget who they were. 214 00:09:52,879 --> 00:09:55,220 Like, every time a Jewish person recites the 215 00:09:55,220 --> 00:09:58,299 grace after meals, there's a specific plea to 216 00:09:58,299 --> 00:10:01,019 rebuild Jerusalem. And the traditional words 217 00:10:01,019 --> 00:10:03,700 used to comfort a mourner explicitly connect 218 00:10:03,700 --> 00:10:06,379 their personal grief to the collective grief 219 00:10:06,379 --> 00:10:09,240 of the destruction. They mention mourning among 220 00:10:09,240 --> 00:10:12,139 the other mourners of Zion and Jerusalem. And 221 00:10:12,139 --> 00:10:14,500 of course, the Passover Seder, which is arguably 222 00:10:14,500 --> 00:10:17,440 the most universal Jewish ritual, it culminates 223 00:10:17,440 --> 00:10:19,500 every single year with a defiant declaration, 224 00:10:19,879 --> 00:10:22,779 next year in Jerusalem. But while the memory 225 00:10:22,779 --> 00:10:25,580 of sovereignty was fiercely maintained, the physical 226 00:10:25,580 --> 00:10:28,500 reality of it was just gone. And for a very long 227 00:10:28,500 --> 00:10:30,860 time, the dominant historical narrative was that 228 00:10:30,860 --> 00:10:34,279 70 CE basically marked the death of Jewish politics. 229 00:10:34,899 --> 00:10:36,940 Right. Whistle brings up Heinrich Graz here. 230 00:10:37,179 --> 00:10:39,899 Yes. Graz was one of the most influential Jewish 231 00:10:39,899 --> 00:10:42,460 historians of the 19th century. And his thesis 232 00:10:42,460 --> 00:10:45,039 was that prior to the Roman conquest, Judaism 233 00:10:45,039 --> 00:10:48,259 functioned as a, quote, constitution for a state. 234 00:10:48,340 --> 00:10:51,580 It was a true body politic. But... After the 235 00:10:51,580 --> 00:10:54,559 exile. After the exile, Graz argued, it ceased 236 00:10:54,559 --> 00:10:57,379 to be a political entity altogether. He said 237 00:10:57,379 --> 00:10:59,980 it transitioned into a pure religion, a spiritual 238 00:10:59,980 --> 00:11:02,159 community completely divorced from the mechanics 239 00:11:02,159 --> 00:11:04,919 of statecraft. Which, you know, that view held 240 00:11:04,919 --> 00:11:07,940 sway for a long time because our modern definition 241 00:11:07,940 --> 00:11:11,659 of politics is just deeply unimaginative. We 242 00:11:11,659 --> 00:11:14,600 equate politics with land and taxation enforced 243 00:11:14,600 --> 00:11:17,850 by police and standing armies. What's fascinating 244 00:11:17,850 --> 00:11:20,590 here is how Wisse points out a massive paradigm 245 00:11:20,590 --> 00:11:22,429 shift that occurred in historical scholarship 246 00:11:22,429 --> 00:11:26,190 around the 1970s. Oh, right. Scholars started 247 00:11:26,190 --> 00:11:28,710 digging into the archives of the diaspora. Exactly. 248 00:11:29,070 --> 00:11:31,230 And they realized that Gretz was fundamentally 249 00:11:31,230 --> 00:11:34,029 wrong. The traditional definition of politics 250 00:11:34,029 --> 00:11:35,929 was just too narrow to capture what the Jews 251 00:11:35,929 --> 00:11:37,889 had actually accomplished. Here's where it gets 252 00:11:37,889 --> 00:11:40,529 really interesting, because modern political 253 00:11:40,529 --> 00:11:42,610 science rarely studies Jewish history, despite 254 00:11:42,759 --> 00:11:45,200 them running what might be the longest lasting 255 00:11:45,200 --> 00:11:48,240 political experiment in human history. That is 256 00:11:48,240 --> 00:11:51,039 Wyss's central thesis. The Jewish people didn't 257 00:11:51,039 --> 00:11:53,480 stop being a political entity when Rome burned 258 00:11:53,480 --> 00:11:56,539 their capital. Their politics just adapted. They 259 00:11:56,539 --> 00:11:59,000 remained highly organized. Highly organized. 260 00:11:59,179 --> 00:12:01,139 They maintained strict legal systems, elected 261 00:12:01,139 --> 00:12:04,299 authorities, social welfare networks, systems 262 00:12:04,299 --> 00:12:06,820 of taxation. They had all the hallmarks of a 263 00:12:06,820 --> 00:12:09,440 functioning, complex society. The crucial difference 264 00:12:09,440 --> 00:12:11,679 being that their politics had to operate entirely 265 00:12:11,679 --> 00:12:14,019 within the margins of other nations' sovereignty. 266 00:12:14,559 --> 00:12:17,559 Right. It's a continuous, self -governing civilization 267 00:12:17,559 --> 00:12:20,360 operating across multiple continents, surviving 268 00:12:20,360 --> 00:12:23,659 under the rule of Roman emperors, Islamic caliphates, 269 00:12:23,960 --> 00:12:26,480 European monarchs, Russian czars. All without 270 00:12:26,480 --> 00:12:28,460 ever possessing a centralized state apparatus 271 00:12:28,460 --> 00:12:31,519 of their own. It just blows my mind. And as Wyss 272 00:12:31,519 --> 00:12:34,460 notes, these diaspora communities actually anticipated 273 00:12:34,460 --> 00:12:37,179 features of liberal democracy centuries before 274 00:12:37,179 --> 00:12:39,399 the Enlightenment even happened. Wait, really? 275 00:12:39,700 --> 00:12:41,980 Like what? Well, they developed internal systems 276 00:12:41,980 --> 00:12:45,159 predicated on the rule of law. Individual rights, 277 00:12:45,460 --> 00:12:47,779 communal responsibilities, elected authority, 278 00:12:48,240 --> 00:12:50,960 and a commitment to universal education. For 279 00:12:50,960 --> 00:12:54,539 males. Wow. Concepts that were entirely alien 280 00:12:54,539 --> 00:12:57,159 to the feudal European or Middle Eastern societies 281 00:12:57,159 --> 00:12:59,509 that were surrounding them at the time. But if 282 00:12:59,509 --> 00:13:01,830 they didn't have a state, what do their political 283 00:13:01,830 --> 00:13:03,710 institutions actually look like on a day -to 284 00:13:03,710 --> 00:13:06,570 -day basis? I mean, how do you enforce laws and 285 00:13:06,570 --> 00:13:09,009 maintain a cohesive society while living under 286 00:13:09,009 --> 00:13:11,889 the absolute control of foreign despots? To answer 287 00:13:11,889 --> 00:13:14,129 this, Wyss illuminates the mechanics of this 288 00:13:14,129 --> 00:13:16,590 stateless power through two specific examples. 289 00:13:17,110 --> 00:13:19,750 One is a historical anecdote, and the other is 290 00:13:19,750 --> 00:13:22,269 a classic piece of folklore. Okay. Let's hear 291 00:13:22,269 --> 00:13:24,850 the anecdote first. It reads like a scene from 292 00:13:24,850 --> 00:13:27,710 a spy thriller, right? It really does. It takes 293 00:13:27,710 --> 00:13:30,720 place in Warsaw. during World War I. A German 294 00:13:30,720 --> 00:13:32,779 military intelligence officer is stationed in 295 00:13:32,779 --> 00:13:34,980 the city and he starts receiving these reports 296 00:13:34,980 --> 00:13:38,419 of suspicious coordinated activity in a specific 297 00:13:38,419 --> 00:13:41,559 courtyard. Suspicious how? Well, every evening, 298 00:13:41,700 --> 00:13:45,120 dozens of Jewish coachmen, these are rough working 299 00:13:45,120 --> 00:13:47,299 class men who drive transport wagons all day, 300 00:13:47,860 --> 00:13:50,299 are seen slipping into a building one after another. 301 00:13:50,490 --> 00:13:52,509 So through the lens of military intelligence, 302 00:13:52,649 --> 00:13:55,129 this looks like a textbook conspiracy. Exactly. 303 00:13:55,190 --> 00:13:57,750 He thinks it's a secret cabal of laborers planning 304 00:13:57,750 --> 00:14:00,049 sabotage against the occupying German forces. 305 00:14:00,450 --> 00:14:02,629 So the officer raids the building, fully expecting 306 00:14:02,629 --> 00:14:05,350 to dismantle a rebel cell. But what does he actually 307 00:14:05,350 --> 00:14:07,850 find? He bursts into the room and finds these 308 00:14:07,850 --> 00:14:10,730 exhausted blue collar men sitting at long wooden 309 00:14:10,730 --> 00:14:13,409 tables, intensely poring over ancient texts, 310 00:14:13,929 --> 00:14:16,210 aggressively debating complex points of religious 311 00:14:16,210 --> 00:14:19,309 and civil law with a scholar. That is amazing. 312 00:14:19,659 --> 00:14:21,600 The officer must have been completely disarmed. 313 00:14:21,820 --> 00:14:24,539 He was. He later notes in his reports that you 314 00:14:24,539 --> 00:14:27,480 couldn't find that level of intense voluntary 315 00:14:27,480 --> 00:14:30,899 dedication to intellectual and legal study among 316 00:14:30,899 --> 00:14:32,980 the elite students at the University of Berlin, 317 00:14:33,220 --> 00:14:35,639 let alone among, you know, day laborers. Right. 318 00:14:36,120 --> 00:14:38,320 And what that German officer inadvertently discovered 319 00:14:38,320 --> 00:14:42,399 was the actual decentralized infrastructure of 320 00:14:42,399 --> 00:14:45,250 Jewish political life. Yes. Their government 321 00:14:45,250 --> 00:14:47,330 wasn't a parliament building, it was a mobile 322 00:14:47,330 --> 00:14:50,730 constitution. The shared, rigorous study of a 323 00:14:50,730 --> 00:14:53,110 binding legal code was the mechanism that held 324 00:14:53,110 --> 00:14:55,789 the civilization together, regardless of whose 325 00:14:55,789 --> 00:14:57,730 geographic borders they happened to live within. 326 00:14:58,009 --> 00:15:00,750 That is so cool. Okay, so what about the folklore 327 00:15:00,750 --> 00:15:03,950 example? Ah, the joke about the rabbi, the duke, 328 00:15:03,970 --> 00:15:06,750 and the dog. Right. We guess folklore and humor 329 00:15:06,750 --> 00:15:08,970 are often the sharpest tools for diagnosing how 330 00:15:08,970 --> 00:15:11,450 a culture actually survives. How's the joke go? 331 00:15:11,669 --> 00:15:14,509 So a tyrannical local duke decides on a whim 332 00:15:14,509 --> 00:15:16,470 that he is going to wipe out the local Jewish 333 00:15:16,470 --> 00:15:19,269 community. The community's rabbi goes to the 334 00:15:19,269 --> 00:15:21,809 duke's estate to plead for mercy. Standard setup. 335 00:15:22,190 --> 00:15:24,950 Right. And the rabbi says, your grace, if you 336 00:15:24,950 --> 00:15:27,309 spare my people, I promise you that within one 337 00:15:27,309 --> 00:15:29,509 year I will teach your favorite hunting dog how 338 00:15:29,509 --> 00:15:31,669 to speak our language. And the duke just goes 339 00:15:31,669 --> 00:15:34,230 for it? The duke, whose arrogance is only matched 340 00:15:34,230 --> 00:15:37,570 by his amusement, agrees. But he warns, if that 341 00:15:37,570 --> 00:15:39,950 dog isn't talking in 12 months, every Jew in 342 00:15:39,950 --> 00:15:42,620 the town dies. Oh, man. So the rabbi returns 343 00:15:42,620 --> 00:15:45,120 to his congregation, and the people are absolutely 344 00:15:45,120 --> 00:15:47,120 terrified. They surround him, shouting, Rabbi, 345 00:15:47,279 --> 00:15:49,620 have you lost your mind? You can't teach a dog 346 00:15:49,620 --> 00:15:52,059 to talk. You've just guaranteed our execution. 347 00:15:52,159 --> 00:15:54,399 You've only delayed it. Now what does the rabbi 348 00:15:54,399 --> 00:15:56,960 say? The rabbi calmly looks at them and says, 349 00:15:57,440 --> 00:16:00,620 a year is a long time. A lot can happen in a 350 00:16:00,620 --> 00:16:02,940 year. Before the year is over, one of the two 351 00:16:02,940 --> 00:16:06,200 will croak, either the dog or the juke. It's 352 00:16:06,200 --> 00:16:08,519 just a brilliant piece of gallows humor. It is. 353 00:16:08,740 --> 00:16:12,080 But Wisset treats it as a masterclass in diaspora 354 00:16:12,080 --> 00:16:15,019 political strategy. It completely maps out the 355 00:16:15,019 --> 00:16:18,159 psychology of dealing with overwhelming coercive 356 00:16:18,159 --> 00:16:20,700 power when you literally have none. Because you 357 00:16:20,700 --> 00:16:23,259 can't meet the Duke on a battlefield. No. So 358 00:16:23,259 --> 00:16:26,340 you use his own ego against him. You buy time. 359 00:16:26,779 --> 00:16:29,820 You rely on the inherent biological instability 360 00:16:29,820 --> 00:16:32,960 of dictatorships. Right. The rabbi isn't praying 361 00:16:32,960 --> 00:16:36,100 for the seed to part. He's just playing the actuarial 362 00:16:36,100 --> 00:16:39,110 odds of human mortality. It's an exercise in 363 00:16:39,110 --> 00:16:42,850 extreme unsentimental pragmatism. It is the essence 364 00:16:42,850 --> 00:16:45,649 of political accommodation. But to make this 365 00:16:45,649 --> 00:16:48,470 work across centuries, this pragmatic survival 366 00:16:48,470 --> 00:16:50,590 instinct had to be formally codified into law, 367 00:16:50,809 --> 00:16:52,990 right? They had to figure out a way to legally 368 00:16:52,990 --> 00:16:56,169 square their own strict divine laws with the 369 00:16:56,169 --> 00:16:58,490 undeniable reality that they were subjects of 370 00:16:58,490 --> 00:17:01,250 whatever king or czar held the sword. Exactly. 371 00:17:01,769 --> 00:17:04,349 And this brings us to a foundational legal concept 372 00:17:04,349 --> 00:17:07,019 in Jewish history. an Aramaic principle from 373 00:17:07,019 --> 00:17:10,920 the Talmud known as Dina DeMalkuta Dina, which 374 00:17:10,920 --> 00:17:14,059 translates to, the law of the land is the law. 375 00:17:14,440 --> 00:17:17,039 Which on the surface, if you just read that translation, 376 00:17:17,160 --> 00:17:19,720 it sounds like absolute capitulation. Right. 377 00:17:19,920 --> 00:17:21,359 It sounds like the rabbis are simply saying, 378 00:17:21,619 --> 00:17:23,799 we surrender, whatever the king wants is fine. 379 00:17:24,559 --> 00:17:26,980 But Weiss explores how deeply subversive and 380 00:17:26,980 --> 00:17:29,900 brilliant this legal maneuver actually was. By 381 00:17:29,900 --> 00:17:32,099 issuing a decree within the Jewish legal framework 382 00:17:32,099 --> 00:17:35,500 that the state's law is valid, The rabbinic leaders 383 00:17:35,500 --> 00:17:38,380 were actually preserving their own internal authority. 384 00:17:38,880 --> 00:17:40,779 It's like a corporate acquisition. How do you 385 00:17:40,779 --> 00:17:43,940 mean? Imagine a small, fiercely independent tech 386 00:17:43,940 --> 00:17:47,160 startup with a unique culture, and they get hostilely 387 00:17:47,160 --> 00:17:49,599 taken over by a massive, rigid conglomerate. 388 00:17:50,680 --> 00:17:52,460 The conglomerate immediately orders the startup 389 00:17:52,460 --> 00:17:55,720 to adopt their corporate HR software and their 390 00:17:55,720 --> 00:17:58,599 specific holiday schedule. The startup has no 391 00:17:58,599 --> 00:18:01,099 leverage to fight this. Right. They have to comply. 392 00:18:01,559 --> 00:18:03,980 But... Instead of just surrendering and letting 393 00:18:03,980 --> 00:18:06,740 the team feel conquered, the startup CEO sends 394 00:18:06,740 --> 00:18:10,119 out an internal memo. The memo says, as a matter 395 00:18:10,119 --> 00:18:13,539 of our internal company policy, which I am setting 396 00:18:13,539 --> 00:18:16,720 for us, we are going to adopt these new protocols. 397 00:18:17,220 --> 00:18:20,440 Ah, I see. The end result is identical. They 398 00:18:20,440 --> 00:18:23,160 are using the conglomerate software. But the 399 00:18:23,160 --> 00:18:25,900 source of authority remains internal. It preserves 400 00:18:25,900 --> 00:18:27,619 their internal culture and chain of command. 401 00:18:27,890 --> 00:18:31,470 That is precisely how Dina de Malhuta Dina functioned. 402 00:18:31,930 --> 00:18:33,670 The Jewish leadership decreed that they were 403 00:18:33,670 --> 00:18:35,809 deferring to the secular ruler, but they were 404 00:18:35,809 --> 00:18:39,190 doing so on their own terms, under the umbrella 405 00:18:39,190 --> 00:18:42,250 of their own legal system. So they didn't internalize 406 00:18:42,250 --> 00:18:44,690 the status of a conquered, broken people? No, 407 00:18:44,690 --> 00:18:47,490 they were making a strategic, religiously sanctioned 408 00:18:47,490 --> 00:18:49,829 decision to comply in order to ensure communal 409 00:18:49,829 --> 00:18:52,950 survival. But wait, what was the limit? I mean, 410 00:18:53,150 --> 00:18:55,230 a system that says the law of the land is the 411 00:18:55,230 --> 00:18:58,109 law is incredibly dangerous if the ruler suddenly 412 00:18:58,109 --> 00:19:01,150 demands something completely unjust. You can't 413 00:19:01,150 --> 00:19:04,069 just absorb every despotic decree into your own 414 00:19:04,069 --> 00:19:06,690 legal code. Right. And the system had strict, 415 00:19:07,150 --> 00:19:09,650 heavily debated caveats. Weiss notes that the 416 00:19:09,650 --> 00:19:11,849 rabbinic consensus was that the rule only applied 417 00:19:11,849 --> 00:19:14,410 to the legitimate universal functions of a government. 418 00:19:14,630 --> 00:19:17,240 Like what? like maintaining civil order, minting 419 00:19:17,240 --> 00:19:19,819 currency, or levying standardized taxes. OK, 420 00:19:19,940 --> 00:19:23,039 so normal state stuff. Right. But if the government's 421 00:19:23,039 --> 00:19:25,380 demands were deemed fundamentally illegitimate, 422 00:19:25,779 --> 00:19:27,980 for instance, if a tax was levied only on the 423 00:19:27,980 --> 00:19:31,000 Jewish population in a punitive manner, or if 424 00:19:31,000 --> 00:19:34,319 a law demanded murder, idolatry, or sexual immorality, 425 00:19:34,799 --> 00:19:36,980 the law of the land was entirely invalid. Oh, 426 00:19:37,039 --> 00:19:39,240 wow. And in those cases, resistance, even to 427 00:19:39,240 --> 00:19:42,299 the point of death, was required. Even with those 428 00:19:42,299 --> 00:19:44,380 copy -hots in place, the stark reality of what 429 00:19:44,380 --> 00:19:47,759 Weiss terms political complementarity meant Jews 430 00:19:47,759 --> 00:19:49,759 were utterly dependent on the ruler's goodwill. 431 00:19:49,960 --> 00:19:52,720 Utterly. You are surviving by making yourself 432 00:19:52,720 --> 00:19:55,640 useful to the sovereign. It's a completely delegated 433 00:19:55,640 --> 00:19:58,539 existence. And the historical record demonstrates 434 00:19:58,539 --> 00:20:01,279 the brutal fragility of that existence, right? 435 00:20:01,420 --> 00:20:03,779 It does. I mean, Jewish communities sought the 436 00:20:03,779 --> 00:20:06,099 best possible relationship with local authorities 437 00:20:06,099 --> 00:20:09,309 out of sheer necessity. In the Middle Ages, within 438 00:20:09,309 --> 00:20:12,390 the Islamic Empire, the Gaon, the head of the 439 00:20:12,390 --> 00:20:15,170 Jewish Academy in Babylon, he wielded immense 440 00:20:15,170 --> 00:20:17,849 religious and juridical authority over the Jewish 441 00:20:17,849 --> 00:20:21,369 world. But as the historian Shlomo Goite noted, 442 00:20:21,789 --> 00:20:25,369 the Gaon's actual practical power was a mirage. 443 00:20:25,730 --> 00:20:28,349 It depended entirely on the Muslim government 444 00:20:28,349 --> 00:20:30,309 because they were the ones who controlled the 445 00:20:30,309 --> 00:20:32,970 police and the military forces necessary to actually 446 00:20:32,970 --> 00:20:35,029 enforce anything. We see the ultimate tragic 447 00:20:35,029 --> 00:20:36,990 failure of this strategy in Christian Spain, 448 00:20:37,210 --> 00:20:39,490 too. Right. The expulsion. Yeah. For centuries, 449 00:20:39,750 --> 00:20:42,789 you had the Golden Age of Spain, the convivencia, 450 00:20:43,410 --> 00:20:46,710 where Jewish communities just thrived. They were 451 00:20:46,710 --> 00:20:48,769 deeply woven into the fabric of the royal courts 452 00:20:48,769 --> 00:20:51,650 as financiers, physicians, translators, chief 453 00:20:51,650 --> 00:20:53,789 diplomats. They felt secure because they were 454 00:20:53,789 --> 00:20:56,170 indispensable to the state. Exactly. But that 455 00:20:56,170 --> 00:20:59,670 security was an illusion based entirely on utility. 456 00:21:00,470 --> 00:21:02,150 The moment the political and religious winds 457 00:21:02,150 --> 00:21:04,740 shifted at the end of the 15th century. Their 458 00:21:04,740 --> 00:21:07,019 utility couldn't offset the religious fervor 459 00:21:07,019 --> 00:21:09,319 of the Inquisition. And King Ferdinand and Queen 460 00:21:09,319 --> 00:21:12,279 Isabella, who had once been pragmatic protectors, 461 00:21:12,579 --> 00:21:14,460 they ultimately signed the Edict of Expulsion 462 00:21:14,460 --> 00:21:18,039 in 1492. A civilization that had thrived there 463 00:21:18,039 --> 00:21:20,779 for centuries was just wholesale evicted overnight. 464 00:21:21,200 --> 00:21:23,759 Which raises this massive question. How could 465 00:21:23,759 --> 00:21:27,220 a people endure centuries of this precarious, 466 00:21:27,460 --> 00:21:30,039 humiliating dependence? I mean, how do you get 467 00:21:30,039 --> 00:21:33,240 expelled from Spain or massacred in the Polish 468 00:21:33,240 --> 00:21:35,759 -Lithuanian Commonwealth centuries later without 469 00:21:35,759 --> 00:21:38,779 completely despairing or just giving up and assimilating? 470 00:21:39,299 --> 00:21:41,319 Pragmatism and legal loopholes aren't enough 471 00:21:41,319 --> 00:21:43,619 to sustain a people through that level of trauma. 472 00:21:44,140 --> 00:21:47,980 No way. They needed a theological bedrock. And 473 00:21:47,980 --> 00:21:51,400 Wisk points us toward exactly that, the Covenant 474 00:21:51,400 --> 00:21:54,680 of Sinai. According to the foundational narrative 475 00:21:54,680 --> 00:21:57,349 of the Jewish people, their ultimate treaty Their 476 00:21:57,349 --> 00:22:00,109 primary political alliance was not negotiated 477 00:22:00,109 --> 00:22:03,069 with a local duke or an emperor or a czar. It 478 00:22:03,069 --> 00:22:06,950 was negotiated with God. Yes. The treaty was 479 00:22:06,950 --> 00:22:09,130 made directly with God. So they are situating 480 00:22:09,130 --> 00:22:11,309 themselves politically within a hierarchy where 481 00:22:11,309 --> 00:22:14,130 the earthly ruler is just middle management. 482 00:22:14,549 --> 00:22:16,390 Right. The supreme power is actually running 483 00:22:16,390 --> 00:22:19,549 the board. Precisely. Wissah draws on the work 484 00:22:19,549 --> 00:22:23,170 of the historian Yitzhak Baer, writing in 1936, 485 00:22:23,349 --> 00:22:26,150 which, you know, was a profoundly dark time for 486 00:22:26,150 --> 00:22:29,250 European Jewry. Oh, for sure. Baer argued that 487 00:22:29,250 --> 00:22:31,470 the day to day fate of the Jewish people in the 488 00:22:31,470 --> 00:22:33,750 diaspora was completely comprehended through 489 00:22:33,750 --> 00:22:36,109 their firm faith in the direct influence of God 490 00:22:36,109 --> 00:22:39,269 upon history. He insisted this wasn't some naive, 491 00:22:39,269 --> 00:22:41,490 you know, timid spinning out of old dreams. It 492 00:22:41,490 --> 00:22:44,130 was a rigorous, fully functional system of religious 493 00:22:44,130 --> 00:22:47,390 concepts. So Wiesa's arguing that in their own 494 00:22:47,390 --> 00:22:50,170 minds, historically, the Jews never viewed themselves 495 00:22:50,170 --> 00:22:53,049 as truly powerless. That is the crux of their 496 00:22:53,049 --> 00:22:55,829 psychological endurance. When we look back, we 497 00:22:55,829 --> 00:22:59,210 see a marginalized, stateless people at the mercy 498 00:22:59,210 --> 00:23:02,269 of heavily armed empires, but their internal 499 00:23:02,269 --> 00:23:04,950 framework processed reality entirely differently. 500 00:23:05,549 --> 00:23:07,349 Because they believed their ultimate protector 501 00:23:07,349 --> 00:23:10,230 was omnipotent. Right. So if they suffered, it 502 00:23:10,230 --> 00:23:12,289 was never interpreted as proof that the local 503 00:23:12,289 --> 00:23:15,289 duke was more powerful than God. Instead, the 504 00:23:15,289 --> 00:23:17,470 suffering was internalized as part of a divine 505 00:23:17,470 --> 00:23:20,109 plan. Maybe it was a test of their fidelity to 506 00:23:20,109 --> 00:23:22,769 the covenant or a punishment for their own communal 507 00:23:22,769 --> 00:23:27,730 sins. So every compromise wasn't a defeat. It 508 00:23:27,730 --> 00:23:30,349 was a tactical retreat authorized by the highest 509 00:23:30,349 --> 00:23:33,170 power in the universe. Exactly. Wisse describes 510 00:23:33,170 --> 00:23:36,130 this phenomenon as the capacity for postponed 511 00:23:36,130 --> 00:23:38,890 political gratification. Postponed political 512 00:23:38,890 --> 00:23:41,740 gratification. I like that. You can endure the 513 00:23:41,740 --> 00:23:43,839 intense humiliations and physical dangers of 514 00:23:43,839 --> 00:23:46,759 the present because you possess absolute certainty 515 00:23:46,759 --> 00:23:49,279 in the ultimate divine justice of the future. 516 00:23:49,579 --> 00:23:52,099 The scales will eventually be balanced. But doesn't 517 00:23:52,099 --> 00:23:54,240 relying on divine justice eventually run out 518 00:23:54,240 --> 00:23:56,579 of steam if the physical suffering becomes too 519 00:23:56,579 --> 00:23:59,380 immense? I mean, you can only tell yourself that 520 00:23:59,380 --> 00:24:02,460 the suffering is a divine test for so long. And 521 00:24:02,460 --> 00:24:05,059 you've hit on exactly where Wyss's analysis turns 522 00:24:05,059 --> 00:24:08,779 incredibly dark. The strategy of extreme political 523 00:24:08,779 --> 00:24:12,650 accommodation combined with this internal unshakable 524 00:24:12,650 --> 00:24:15,690 sense of spiritual superiority. It didn't just 525 00:24:15,690 --> 00:24:18,190 fail to protect them in the modern era. It provoked 526 00:24:18,190 --> 00:24:21,210 a backlash. It actively provoked a paranoid, 527 00:24:21,769 --> 00:24:24,230 deadly psychological backlash from the very nations 528 00:24:24,230 --> 00:24:27,569 hosting them. This is the boomerang effect. The 529 00:24:27,569 --> 00:24:29,490 precise tools the Jewish people evolved over 530 00:24:29,490 --> 00:24:33,369 2000 years to survive were inverted and weaponized 531 00:24:33,369 --> 00:24:36,650 against them. Right. And to understand how this 532 00:24:36,650 --> 00:24:39,269 happened, we have to trace the evolution of antisemitism, 533 00:24:39,589 --> 00:24:41,809 because modern political hatred didn't just spring 534 00:24:41,809 --> 00:24:44,430 out of nowhere. It evolved from a theological 535 00:24:44,430 --> 00:24:47,470 rivalry. How so? Well, in the early centuries 536 00:24:47,470 --> 00:24:49,769 of Christian dominance in Europe, the vulnerability 537 00:24:49,769 --> 00:24:52,670 of the Jews was interpreted entirely through 538 00:24:52,670 --> 00:24:55,710 a theological lens. The Church Fathers, notably 539 00:24:55,710 --> 00:24:58,150 Augustine, developed what's known as the Witness 540 00:24:58,150 --> 00:25:01,470 Doctrine. What's that? This doctrine held that 541 00:25:01,470 --> 00:25:04,450 the Jews must not be completely eradicated because 542 00:25:04,450 --> 00:25:07,089 they needed to survive as wandering degraded 543 00:25:07,089 --> 00:25:09,650 witnesses to the truth of Christianity. Wow. 544 00:25:09,950 --> 00:25:12,309 Their physical powerlessness, their exile, their 545 00:25:12,309 --> 00:25:14,650 suffering. It was all held up by the church as 546 00:25:14,650 --> 00:25:17,509 tangible theological proof that God had abandoned 547 00:25:17,509 --> 00:25:19,650 the old covenant and transferred his favor to 548 00:25:19,650 --> 00:25:22,529 the Christians. So the degradation of the Jew 549 00:25:22,529 --> 00:25:24,890 was necessary evidence of Christianity's triumph. 550 00:25:25,329 --> 00:25:28,130 Exactly. But the Jews didn't cooperate with this 551 00:25:28,130 --> 00:25:30,750 narrative. They were supposed to act like a defeated, 552 00:25:30,849 --> 00:25:33,930 dying relic, but instead they maintained a vibrant, 553 00:25:34,390 --> 00:25:36,890 highly literate, intensely communal civilization 554 00:25:36,890 --> 00:25:39,170 right in the middle of Christian Europe. And 555 00:25:39,170 --> 00:25:41,869 Weiss points out that this sheer resilience caused 556 00:25:41,869 --> 00:25:44,670 immense intellectual and moral insecurity among 557 00:25:44,670 --> 00:25:46,950 Christian theologians and rulers. Oh, massive 558 00:25:46,950 --> 00:25:49,549 insecurity. The church possessed all the political 559 00:25:49,549 --> 00:25:53,410 and military power, yet they felt insecure because 560 00:25:53,410 --> 00:25:57,089 the Jews simply refused to disappear. As Weiss 561 00:25:57,089 --> 00:26:00,210 notes, if the dominant power truly felt capable 562 00:26:00,210 --> 00:26:02,930 of defeating the Jews on intellectual or theological 563 00:26:02,930 --> 00:26:05,769 merits, it wouldn't have had to rig public debates 564 00:26:05,769 --> 00:26:09,109 or burn the Talmud or resort to state -sanctioned 565 00:26:09,109 --> 00:26:12,190 violence. The reliance on coercive force portrayed 566 00:26:12,190 --> 00:26:14,750 a deep underlying insecurity about their own 567 00:26:14,750 --> 00:26:17,950 narrative. Right. But the true horror Weiss details 568 00:26:17,950 --> 00:26:21,549 is what happens when Europe transitions out of 569 00:26:21,549 --> 00:26:24,089 the Middle Ages. We move into the era of the 570 00:26:24,089 --> 00:26:26,470 Enlightenment and Emancipation. Right. Jews are 571 00:26:26,470 --> 00:26:28,829 finally allowed out of the ghettos. They can 572 00:26:28,829 --> 00:26:31,609 enter secular society, attend universities, establish 573 00:26:31,609 --> 00:26:35,069 businesses. And as they do, the hatred doesn't 574 00:26:35,069 --> 00:26:39,369 disappear. It mutates. It goes from theological 575 00:26:39,369 --> 00:26:42,970 bigotry into a modern political weapon. OK, and 576 00:26:42,970 --> 00:26:45,069 if we connect this to the bigger picture, this 577 00:26:45,069 --> 00:26:47,289 is the critical mechanism of modern political 578 00:26:47,289 --> 00:26:50,470 anti -Semitism. Because people often lazily attribute 579 00:26:50,470 --> 00:26:54,250 it to just xenophobia. You know, a simple dislike 580 00:26:54,250 --> 00:26:57,660 of the unlike. But in the 19th and 20th centuries, 581 00:26:58,019 --> 00:27:00,519 it was systematically weaponized for specific 582 00:27:00,519 --> 00:27:03,799 political ends. You have to remember, the Jews 583 00:27:03,799 --> 00:27:06,480 had spent two millennia honing the skills necessary 584 00:27:06,480 --> 00:27:10,940 to survive, organize, and compete without relying 585 00:27:10,940 --> 00:27:13,440 on coercive military force. Right, they had to 586 00:27:13,440 --> 00:27:15,799 be smarter, more adaptable. So when they were 587 00:27:15,799 --> 00:27:19,059 finally allowed into liberal democracies, systems 588 00:27:19,059 --> 00:27:22,119 that supposedly operate on merit, law, trade, 589 00:27:22,200 --> 00:27:25,109 and education rather than brute force, they were 590 00:27:25,109 --> 00:27:27,809 uniquely positioned to excel. Which brings us 591 00:27:27,809 --> 00:27:31,069 to Wilhelm Marr. Yes. Marr was a German agitator 592 00:27:31,069 --> 00:27:33,509 who literally coined the term anti -Semitism 593 00:27:33,509 --> 00:27:37,309 in 1879. And he wasn't arguing theology at all. 594 00:27:37,450 --> 00:27:40,289 Not at all. He wrote a wildly popular pamphlet 595 00:27:40,289 --> 00:27:44,029 called The Victory of Jewry Over Germindom. He 596 00:27:44,029 --> 00:27:46,130 looked at the Jews and saw people without an 597 00:27:46,130 --> 00:27:49,269 army, without a country, who were suddenly succeeding 598 00:27:49,269 --> 00:27:51,890 in banking, journalism, medicine, and the arts. 599 00:27:52,220 --> 00:27:54,680 But instead of recognizing that this success 600 00:27:54,680 --> 00:27:57,420 was the result of a 2 ,000 -year survival strategy 601 00:27:57,420 --> 00:28:00,640 focused on literacy and adaptability, Marner's 602 00:28:00,640 --> 00:28:03,519 contemporaries reversed cause and effect. Exactly. 603 00:28:04,220 --> 00:28:06,180 They looked at this success and argued that it 604 00:28:06,180 --> 00:28:09,099 was evidence of a vast, insidious conspiracy 605 00:28:09,099 --> 00:28:12,440 to achieve world domination. The authors of the 606 00:28:12,440 --> 00:28:15,039 infamous fabricated text, The Protocols of the 607 00:28:15,039 --> 00:28:18,299 Elders of Zion, operated on the exact same premise. 608 00:28:18,559 --> 00:28:21,619 The psychological projection here is just astounding. 609 00:28:21,829 --> 00:28:24,569 I mean, the European powers, the Germans, the 610 00:28:24,569 --> 00:28:27,130 British, the Russians, were the ones actively 611 00:28:27,130 --> 00:28:29,029 trying to conquer the globe through military 612 00:28:29,029 --> 00:28:32,230 imperialism and colonialism. Yes. Yet they projected 613 00:28:32,230 --> 00:28:35,190 that exact desire for world domination onto the 614 00:28:35,190 --> 00:28:37,410 one group of people who had explicitly renounced 615 00:28:37,410 --> 00:28:41,410 physical conquest for 2000 years. It is profound 616 00:28:41,410 --> 00:28:45,140 projection. Wyss argues that anti -Semites interpreted 617 00:28:45,140 --> 00:28:47,920 Jewish deference to power as a covert bid for 618 00:28:47,920 --> 00:28:50,839 world power. Because the Jewish community was 619 00:28:50,839 --> 00:28:53,700 decentralized and democratic, anti -Semites viewed 620 00:28:53,700 --> 00:28:57,119 it as a shadowy international cabal. So they 621 00:28:57,119 --> 00:29:00,259 claimed Jews were weaponizing liberalism to weaken 622 00:29:00,259 --> 00:29:02,460 traditional monarchies. Right, softening the 623 00:29:02,460 --> 00:29:04,279 ground so they could take over from behind the 624 00:29:04,279 --> 00:29:06,660 scenes. And there was a dark joke from the text 625 00:29:06,660 --> 00:29:08,940 that you have to share because it perfectly captures 626 00:29:08,940 --> 00:29:10,980 the cognitive dissonance of this conspiracy. 627 00:29:11,150 --> 00:29:15,089 Oh, the newspaper joke. Yes, so one Jew is walking 628 00:29:15,089 --> 00:29:16,910 through a park and sees his friend sitting on 629 00:29:16,910 --> 00:29:19,890 a bench calmly reading an anti -Semitic right 630 00:29:19,890 --> 00:29:22,769 -wing newspaper. He asks his friend, why on earth 631 00:29:22,769 --> 00:29:24,789 are you reading that garbage? And what does he 632 00:29:24,789 --> 00:29:27,349 say? The friend replies, when I read the Jewish 633 00:29:27,349 --> 00:29:30,390 press, all I read about is our disasters, pogroms, 634 00:29:30,710 --> 00:29:33,369 poverty, exile, and misery. But when I read the 635 00:29:33,369 --> 00:29:35,549 anti -Semitic press, I get the refreshing news 636 00:29:35,549 --> 00:29:37,609 that we control all the banks, we run all the 637 00:29:37,609 --> 00:29:41,059 governments, and we own the world. It's so good. 638 00:29:41,759 --> 00:29:44,140 It perfectly distills the absurdity of the conspiracy. 639 00:29:44,859 --> 00:29:47,619 But, you know, why is it that the more Jews contributed 640 00:29:47,619 --> 00:29:50,759 to a society, the more vulnerable they seem to 641 00:29:50,759 --> 00:29:54,059 become to these specific political attacks? Because 642 00:29:54,059 --> 00:29:56,839 antisemitism functions as a highly adaptable 643 00:29:56,839 --> 00:29:59,980 protean political instrument. When a modern nation 644 00:29:59,980 --> 00:30:03,180 state experiences a crisis, say, a severe economic 645 00:30:03,180 --> 00:30:06,390 depression or a humiliating defeat in war, The 646 00:30:06,390 --> 00:30:08,869 ruling political class needs simple explanations 647 00:30:08,869 --> 00:30:11,710 to feed to an angry, frightened population. You 648 00:30:11,710 --> 00:30:14,690 can't easily explain the complexities of macroeconomic 649 00:30:14,690 --> 00:30:17,910 shifts to a starving populace. No, but a demagogue 650 00:30:17,910 --> 00:30:20,210 can point to a distinct, highly visible minority 651 00:30:20,210 --> 00:30:22,750 and say, the Rothschilds are stealing your wealth, 652 00:30:22,950 --> 00:30:25,670 or Jewish intellectuals are intentionally corroding 653 00:30:25,670 --> 00:30:27,890 our traditional culture. And the Jewish lack 654 00:30:27,890 --> 00:30:30,990 of a coercive military defense made them the 655 00:30:30,990 --> 00:30:34,250 absolute perfect risk -free scapegoat. You could 656 00:30:34,250 --> 00:30:36,529 attack them physically and politically, knowing 657 00:30:36,529 --> 00:30:39,349 with absolute certainty that there was no sovereign 658 00:30:39,349 --> 00:30:41,589 state army marching over the border to retaliate 659 00:30:41,589 --> 00:30:45,240 on their behalf. Exactly. The very strategy that 660 00:30:45,240 --> 00:30:47,799 kept them alive in the Middle Ages, quiet accommodation, 661 00:30:48,240 --> 00:30:51,140 remaining inconspicuous, became a deathtrap in 662 00:30:51,140 --> 00:30:54,180 the modern era of mass politics and ethno -nationalism. 663 00:30:54,660 --> 00:30:57,380 Which leads directly to the horrific culmination 664 00:30:57,380 --> 00:31:00,539 of this scapegoating in the 20th century. And 665 00:31:00,539 --> 00:31:02,920 with that, The Jewish political strategy had 666 00:31:02,920 --> 00:31:05,920 to fundamentally change, leading to deep internal 667 00:31:05,920 --> 00:31:09,359 contradictions today. Yes. The Holocaust laid 668 00:31:09,359 --> 00:31:12,140 bare the absolute failure of the 2000 -year -old 669 00:31:12,140 --> 00:31:15,259 strategy of diaspora politics. The realization 670 00:31:15,259 --> 00:31:18,200 that accommodation was no longer viable led directly 671 00:31:18,200 --> 00:31:20,299 to the creation of the modern state of Israel. 672 00:31:21,119 --> 00:31:23,599 The Jewish people re -entered the realm of terrestrial 673 00:31:23,599 --> 00:31:26,819 sovereignty. But as Weiss points out in the final 674 00:31:26,819 --> 00:31:29,700 sections of her book, securing a geographic border 675 00:31:29,700 --> 00:31:31,980 and building an army doesn't magically erase 676 00:31:31,980 --> 00:31:34,339 the psychology that has been ingrained over two 677 00:31:34,339 --> 00:31:37,380 millennia. The transition from statelessness 678 00:31:37,380 --> 00:31:40,099 to sovereignty is fraught with immense internal 679 00:31:40,099 --> 00:31:43,599 contradiction. Right. Weiss discusses this tension 680 00:31:43,599 --> 00:31:45,980 among modern Jewish thinkers regarding power. 681 00:31:46,339 --> 00:31:48,970 For example, she brings up David Bialy. Yes, 682 00:31:49,170 --> 00:31:52,029 Bialy is a historian who wrote extensively on 683 00:31:52,029 --> 00:31:55,150 Jewish power. And Wisse notes that he viewed 684 00:31:55,150 --> 00:31:58,509 the long diaspora period as an era of relative 685 00:31:58,509 --> 00:32:01,190 stability, referring to the internal governance 686 00:32:01,190 --> 00:32:04,650 of the rabbinic courts. So he almost seemed to 687 00:32:04,650 --> 00:32:07,309 prefer the clean moral lines of that stateless 688 00:32:07,309 --> 00:32:10,250 era over the anxieties of actual self -rule. 689 00:32:10,650 --> 00:32:13,150 That's Wisse's critique, yes. She also points 690 00:32:13,150 --> 00:32:16,450 to S. Ansky, the renowned writer and ethnographer. 691 00:32:16,680 --> 00:32:20,059 Before World War I, Ansky led these massive ethnographic 692 00:32:20,059 --> 00:32:22,779 expeditions, collecting Jewish folklore. And 693 00:32:22,779 --> 00:32:25,259 he deeply romanticized this culture precisely 694 00:32:25,259 --> 00:32:27,779 because it demonstrated an aversion to physical 695 00:32:27,779 --> 00:32:30,839 heroism. He favored spiritual struggle, right? 696 00:32:31,079 --> 00:32:33,779 Exactly. He celebrated the fact that Jewish folk 697 00:32:33,779 --> 00:32:36,299 tales rejected the nightly battles or military 698 00:32:36,299 --> 00:32:38,660 glory that dominate other European folklore. 699 00:32:38,920 --> 00:32:41,240 But Wisse gives a really strong pushback here. 700 00:32:41,740 --> 00:32:44,339 She argues that Judaism never actually glorified 701 00:32:44,339 --> 00:32:46,519 powerlessness. I mean, she points directly to 702 00:32:46,519 --> 00:32:49,019 the Psalms, which are full of visceral appeals 703 00:32:49,019 --> 00:32:52,119 to a mighty, avenging God to destroy enemies. 704 00:32:52,619 --> 00:32:54,220 Right. The tradition didn't worship weakness. 705 00:32:54,559 --> 00:32:56,619 It simply outsourced the execution of physical 706 00:32:56,619 --> 00:32:59,900 power to the Almighty. Wisse is essentially diagnosing 707 00:32:59,900 --> 00:33:03,339 a diaspora hangover. A diaspora hangover. Yeah. 708 00:33:03,839 --> 00:33:06,819 For 2000 years, Jewish morality was inextricably 709 00:33:06,819 --> 00:33:10,160 linked to not possessing coercive power. If you 710 00:33:10,160 --> 00:33:11,960 don't have an army, you don't have to make the 711 00:33:11,960 --> 00:33:14,339 morally agonizing decisions that come with deploying 712 00:33:14,339 --> 00:33:17,079 one. You can maintain a pristine, theoretical 713 00:33:17,079 --> 00:33:19,259 moral high ground. But with the state of Israel, 714 00:33:19,440 --> 00:33:21,839 that dynamic has shifted. And to understand the 715 00:33:21,839 --> 00:33:24,259 danger of clinging to that diaspora mindset, 716 00:33:24,700 --> 00:33:27,420 Wees brings in Jean -Francois Ravel's How Democracies 717 00:33:27,420 --> 00:33:30,730 Perish. Yes. Ravel warned that modern democratic 718 00:33:30,730 --> 00:33:32,990 societies are uniquely vulnerable because they 719 00:33:32,990 --> 00:33:36,009 are often beset by internal guilt. They turn 720 00:33:36,009 --> 00:33:38,430 inward, constantly questioning their own legitimacy 721 00:33:38,430 --> 00:33:40,990 and try to accommodate or appease existential 722 00:33:40,990 --> 00:33:43,230 threats rather than forcefully repelling them. 723 00:33:43,549 --> 00:33:45,250 Because they're terrified of compromising their 724 00:33:45,250 --> 00:33:48,490 own moral purity. Exactly. And we supplies this 725 00:33:48,490 --> 00:33:50,799 directly to the Jewish condition. She argues 726 00:33:50,799 --> 00:33:53,240 that if modern Jews no longer rely on God to 727 00:33:53,240 --> 00:33:55,720 physically intervene, they must provide that 728 00:33:55,720 --> 00:33:57,940 missing dimension of physical power themselves, 729 00:33:57,960 --> 00:34:01,640 or it is quite literally a suicide pact. It reminds 730 00:34:01,640 --> 00:34:02,960 me of the quote on the back cover of the book 731 00:34:02,960 --> 00:34:06,180 from Cynthia Ozick. She asks if political independence 732 00:34:06,180 --> 00:34:08,679 has truly altered the venerable Jewish psychology 733 00:34:08,679 --> 00:34:11,480 of appeasement. It's a terrifying implication. 734 00:34:11,780 --> 00:34:14,659 Right. It's wise saying that the exact survival 735 00:34:14,659 --> 00:34:16,699 skills that kept the Jewish people alive for 736 00:34:16,699 --> 00:34:19,300 2000 years, the instinct to accommodate, to buy 737 00:34:19,300 --> 00:34:22,420 time, are the exact same traits that threaten 738 00:34:22,420 --> 00:34:24,659 them today if they don't adapt. She is confirming 739 00:34:24,659 --> 00:34:27,780 exactly that. The politics of accommodation worked 740 00:34:27,780 --> 00:34:30,920 only when there was no other choice. Today, with 741 00:34:30,920 --> 00:34:33,119 the state of Israel, the dynamic has fundamentally 742 00:34:33,119 --> 00:34:36,320 shifted. Israel's ability to withstand assailants 743 00:34:36,320 --> 00:34:38,840 now affects the security of other democratic 744 00:34:38,840 --> 00:34:41,360 nations, making the Jewish political condition 745 00:34:41,360 --> 00:34:44,360 a bellwether for the survival of global democracy 746 00:34:44,360 --> 00:34:47,260 itself. Stepping back, this has been such a profound 747 00:34:47,260 --> 00:34:49,860 journey. We've seen how a people redefined politics 748 00:34:49,860 --> 00:34:52,820 to survive without a state, how their reliance 749 00:34:52,820 --> 00:34:55,000 on a higher power gave them the stamina to endure, 750 00:34:55,320 --> 00:34:58,719 and how their very success bred paranoid conspiracy 751 00:34:58,719 --> 00:35:01,679 theories. And how the transition back to sovereign 752 00:35:01,679 --> 00:35:05,440 power challenges a 2000 year old mindset. Right. 753 00:35:05,599 --> 00:35:08,119 Which leaves us with a final thought for you, 754 00:35:08,219 --> 00:35:12,280 the listener to ponder. Wist suggests that democracies 755 00:35:12,280 --> 00:35:15,860 today suffer from the same guilt producing accusations 756 00:35:15,860 --> 00:35:19,099 and hesitation to use power that historically 757 00:35:19,099 --> 00:35:22,139 plagued stateless Jews. So as you look at the 758 00:35:22,139 --> 00:35:25,190 world today, ask yourself, in our quest to be 759 00:35:25,190 --> 00:35:28,130 the moral mensch in the courtyard, are modern 760 00:35:28,130 --> 00:35:30,130 democracies ignoring the wolves at the gate? 761 00:35:30,829 --> 00:35:33,170 Can a society be so committed to its own moral 762 00:35:33,170 --> 00:35:35,989 purity that it forgets it actually has to survive 763 00:35:35,989 --> 00:35:38,539 to practice it? Thank you so much for joining 764 00:35:38,539 --> 00:35:41,480 us on this deep dive. Keep asking the hard questions, 765 00:35:41,780 --> 00:35:44,199 keep seeking out multiple perspectives, and we'll 766 00:35:44,199 --> 00:35:44,860 see you next time.