EPISODE TRANSCRIPT
The Necessity of Exile (Shaul Magid): Essays from a Distance
Explicit
Automatically transcribed from the episode audio. Some words and names may be inaccurate.
Listen to the episodeDownload captions (VTT)
Picture this, okay? It's May 1942. You're standing in the Biltmore Hotel in Manhattan. And I mean, it's this incredibly grand opulent space, right? High ceilings, have you drapery, just totally luxurious. But the atmosphere inside is just, it's incredibly tense. Because, you know, the world outside is at war. Europe is descending into an absolute unimaginable crisis for the Jewish people. Yeah, the worst possible crisis. Exactly. And inside this hotel, This momentous meeting is taking place. David Ben -Gurion, the man who, you know, eventually becomes Israel's first prime minister, he's traveled all the way there to sit down with American Zionist leaders.
Right. They're trying to figure out a survival strategy. They are trying to hash out the absolute future of their people in the face of this existential catastrophe. But what they end up negotiating amid all that heavy geopolitical strategy is actually a linguistic bargain. Yeah, which sounds so wild when you think about it. It really does. A seemingly minor trade of words that, well, it ends up altering the entire course of modern history. It really is an incredible historical pivot point and one that honestly most people completely overlook today. Yeah. Because the American leaders essentially said to Ben -Gurion, look, we will support your goal of Jewish statehood in Palestine. We will put our political and financial weight behind it. But on one strict condition.
And it was a very specific condition. Very specific. American Jews must be officially considered as living in Gola, which translates to diaspora or natural dispersion. Right. But they must absolutely not be categorized as living in Galut, which means exile. Right. Which to a casual observer, I mean, that just sounds like pure semantics, right? Dispersion versus exile. Like, who cares? Exactly. Sounds like a dictionary debate. But it's massive. The Americans were drawing this very firm line in the sand. They were saying, look, we are Americans. We are integrated. We're safe. We are home. We are not in this deficient, tragic, temporary state of exile, just waiting around to be rescued by a new nation state. We're just geographically dispersed. Yeah. And they struck the deal. It became known as the Biltmore bargain. But that brings up the big question, right? What happens when a people who have defined themselves for literally two millennia by their longing for a home, by their exile, suddenly just declare that the exile is over? That is the exact question we are unpacking today. We are doing a deep dive into the writings of Shaul McGee, specifically his deeply provocative book, The Necessity of Exile, Essays from a Distance.
It's a heavy one. It really is. McGee is essentially arguing that making that bargain deliberately erasing the concept of exile from the Jewish consciousness, was actually this highly precarious exercise. He suggests that this erasure might actually be the very thing tearing the Middle East apart today, and that reclaiming an exilic mindset, a sense of productive distance or humility, might be strictly necessary for the future of both Judaism and the entire region. Which is just a massive claim. It is. And to really understand how he built this case, I mean, we have to look at theology, geopolitics, and some intensely personal narratives. Oh, absolutely. But before we get into the weeds, and we are going incredibly deep into the weeds today, there's a really vital framework we need to establish right at the top for you, the listener. Yes, this is crucial.
Because this source material contains highly charged political, religious, and historical viewpoints, spanning left -wing, right -wing, Zionist, and anti -Zionist spectrums, we are Absolutely not taking sides today. Not at all. Our job today is to impartially report on Shell McGee's arguments and the sources he cites. We are not endorsing these viewpoints, but simply breaking down the ideas exactly as they are presented in the text, just so you can understand them. Right. We are just guides to the material, nothing more. OK, let's unpack this. We have to start with the underlying ideological crisis that McGee believes we're living through right now. Right.
His starting point. Yeah. He opens his argument by leaning on Gershom Sholem. Now, for those who don't know, Sholem was essentially the godfather of the modern academic study of Jewish mysticism. A giant in the field. Total giant. In 1975, near the end of his life, Sholem gave an interview where he said something that feels, I mean, almost prophetic today. He called Zionism a calculated risk, specifically because it brought about the destruction of the reality of exile. And Megid uses Sholem's warning as the foundational premise of his entire project. To understand why it was such a risk, you have to really understand what exile did psychologically. Right. For nearly 2 ,000 years, the Jewish people were defined by the tension of the not yet. It was a theology of longing. Like you prayed for a return, but...
But you understood that ultimate redemption was in God's hands, in a messianic future. By claiming that exile was over through a secular political project, Zionism took a massive gamble. Because if you say, hey, we have arrived, the longing is officially over, you have to actually deliver on that absolute promise. Exactly. Maggot argues that the erasure of exile didn't just normalize the Jewish people into a standard nation state. It eventually gave birth to an ethno -national chauvinism. Oh, wow. Yeah. Because when a collective believes they have definitively arrived and that the land is exclusively theirs by this blend of historical and theological mandate, the inherent humility that exile forced upon them simply vanishes.
You transition from hoping for divine justice to enforcing state power. Precisely. Which is a perfect lens to look at the contemporary political landscape. Maggot asks a very blunt question in chapter one. Has Zionism exhausted itself? And he focuses really heavily on the crisis of liberal Zionism today, right? Yes. And the data point he uses to illustrate this crisis isn't a war or an election. It's something so mundane, yet so revealing. The 2021 Ben and Jerry's boycott.
Okay, yes. This is such a fascinating example because it perfectly encapsulates the contemporary ideological deadlock we're seeing. It really does. So, for context, in 2021, the ice cream company Ben & Jerry's announced they would stop selling their products in the West Bank settlements. Right. However, they made it very, very clear they would continue selling ice cream within Israel's pre -1967 borders, which is what is known as the Green Line. Just normal Israel proper. Exactly. Their stated intention was specifically to protest the military occupation of the Palestinian territories, not to boycott the sovereign state of Israel itself. This is a very classic liberal distinction. But the backlash within Israel, and honestly among American Jewish organizations, was just explosive. It was nearly universal across the political spectrum. Completely. Like, they didn't treat it as a targeted critique of settlement policy. They treated it as an existential attack on the Jewish state itself. And Magid points out exactly why. The Green Line, that border separating Israel proper from the occupied territories, has essentially been erased in practical, everyday Israeli life. Precisely. Because for decades, the settlements in the West Bank have been so deeply integrated into the economic, social, and infrastructural reality of Israel. I mean, we're talking highway systems, water grids, military protection. It's all connected. It's totally enmeshed. So recognizing a border felt to many Israelis like an artificial and hostile act.
Majid uses this ice cream controversy to highlight a really devastating reality for the liberal Zionist dream. Right, the dream of a neat two -state separation. Yeah. The idea that Israel is a democracy over here and the occupation is just a temporary anomaly over there, it's entirely divorced from the physical facts on the ground. So to explain how people are reacting to the death of that two -state dream, Magid brings in this framework designed by Daniel Hartman, who is a very prominent liberal Zionist thinker. Yes. Hartman breaks the contemporary Jewish engagement with Israel into four distinct categories. And I want to walk you through these because they are incredibly useful for mapping the discourse you see on the news every single day. They are super helpful. So first you have the troubled, committed. These are your classic liberal Zionists.
They deeply love Israel. They are totally committed to the idea of a Jewish state. But the permanent reality of the occupation deeply, deeply troubles them. It conflicts with their liberal democratic values. Then you have the second group, which Hartman calls the untroubled, committed. These are the settler Zionists, or the nationalist right wing. Okay. They are fully committed to the state, but they are entirely untroubled by the occupation or the lack of a Palestinian state. In their view, there is no occupation because the entire land is their rightful historical or biblical inheritance. Got it. Third, you have the troubled, uncommitted. These are liberals, often younger generations, who actually used to support Zionism, but they've watched the permanent entrenchment of the occupation. They've seen the rightward shift of the Israeli government.
And they've finally just said, you know what? I can't do this anymore. They hit a wall. My progressive values are fundamentally incompatible with ethno -nationalism. So they've walked away from the ideology entirely. They are uncommitted. And finally, the fourth group, the untroubled uncommitted. This encompasses people who are completely uninterested in Israel and just don't care at all, as well as staunch anti -Zionists who reject the foundational premise of a Jewish ethno -state from the get -go. So they aren't troubled by the current crisis of Zionism because they never bought into the ideology to begin with. Exactly. They aren't engaged with trying to save it. So Hartman's primary concern, and honestly, really the concern of mainstream American Jewish institutions, is trying to save that first group, right? The troubled, committed. Yeah, the liberals who are on the verge of abandoning ship. Right. And Magid points out something quite devastating about this dynamic. He argues that the two -state solution is essentially being kept on life support in political discourse solely to appease this exact group. Oh, totally. Because talking about a future two -state solution allows liberal Zionists to remain troubled, yet committed.
They can pretend the occupation is just a temporary glitch that will eventually be solved rather than a permanent structural feature of the state. Maggot's critique of Hartman's solution here is just fascinating. Because Hartman is honest enough to acknowledge that the two -state solution is, at least for the foreseeable future, a total fantasy. Right. But his proposed solution for keeping liberals engaged isn't to demand systemic regime change. Instead, Hartman suggests creating a new liberal Jewish story. A story. Yeah. He suggests advocating for concepts like, quote, shrinking the occupation and focusing on treating Palestinians better within the current framework.
Wait, so he's essentially trying to find a liberal vocabulary to mask an illiberal reality. That's exactly Maggot's argument. He argues this is intellectually dishonest. It's an attempt to change the narrative so the liberal feels better about themselves without actually changing the power dynamic for the people living under occupation. OK, so what Majid is saying is that shrinking the occupation is kind of like rebranding a massive leak in your living room roof as an indoor water feature. That's a great way to put it. Like it changes the story you tell your guests, but at the end of the day, you're still getting rained on. But let me play devil's advocate here for a second. Because isn't it just pragmatic to seek small improvements when the grand solution fails? Sure. Like, if the two -state solution is truly dead, isn't shrinking a military occupation demonstrably better than expanding it? Isn't Hartman just dealing with reality? From a purely utilitarian standpoint, perhaps. Less friction is better than more friction, sure, but Maggot is arguing from a structural, ideological, and moral standpoint. He's saying that if your baseline ideology, Zionism, structurally requires the domination, or at least the disenfranchisement, of another people in order to maintain a demographic majority and political hegemony, then tweaking the edges doesn't solve the moral rot. It's just a band -aid. Right. The ideology itself has become the obstacle to equality. If liberal Zionists have to constantly invent new PR stories to justify an illiberal reality, Maggot asks, why remain bound to the ideology at all? At what point does the commitment to the ideology override the commitment to human rights? That's a tough question. You know, it's so easy to look at the death of a two -state solution as just a high -level political failure, right? Something debated in think tanks or on cable news. But ideologies are actually lived by human beings on the ground. When an ideology breaks, it breaks the people holding it. And Maggety's uniquely qualified to talk about this because his own life is a literal master class in ideological whiplash. It truly is. Chapter two is this deeply autobiographical section that reads more like a novel than a political science text. He details how a person actually experiences the collapse of an ideology from the inside out. His personal pipeline is just remarkable. It really is. He grew up secular and left wing in America. His grandparents were Bundists, which is very crucial to note. OK, let's unpack Bundism for a second. Yeah, so Bundism was a massive secular socialist, fiercely anti -Zionist Jewish movement in Eastern Europe before the Holocaust. OK. They believed in Jewish cultural autonomy right where they lived, not in building a nation state in the Middle East. So he has that deep secular leftist background. But then he comes of age during the 1970s American counterculture.
Right. He's a teenager reading Haim Potok novels. He's discovering Zalman Shakhtar Shalomi, who was this huge pioneer of the Jewish renewal movement. Magid literally buys a VW bus and drives to New Mexico in search of spirituality and authenticity. And that intense search for the ultimate spiritual high, for something more authentic than middle class American bourgeois life, eventually leads him to buy a one way ticket to Israel. Oh, wow. Yeah, and he lands in the ultra -orthodox Haredi world of Mea Shiram, which is a notoriously insular neighborhood in Jerusalem. So wait, imagine this kid from the American counterculture, fresh out of a VW bus, now wearing the black coat and hat, studying the Talmud day and night. It's a huge pivot. And crucially, this specific Haredi world is fundamentally non -Zionist, and in many sects, explicitly anti -Zionist. Really? Why? Because they believe that only the Messiah can return the Jews to sovereignty. They view secular state building as a blasphemous rebellion against God.
OK, so he's living this intense insular life, but eventually he feels stifled. The Haredi world's enclavism, their intense focus on the past and rigorous legalism, it just starts to wear on him. He wants something more dynamic. Yeah. That's when he begins reading the works of Rav Cooke, who was the spiritual father of religious Zionism. Rav Cooke offered a theology that was the exact opposite of the Haredi world. It was romantic, sun -drenched, agrarian, and incredibly future -oriented. Rav Cooke's theology was completely revolutionary for someone like Maugat. Cooke taught that the secular Zionist project, you know, these non -religious pioneers draining swamps and building farms, was actually a divine messianic process unfolding in disguise. So the secular pioneers didn't know they were doing God's work, but they were. Exactly. For a spiritual seeker, this is intoxicating. It merges the physical act of working the land with cosmic redemption.
Which brings us to this really fascinating concept Magadon packs called hippie particularism, which, I mean, those two words feel like a total oxymoron. How do you go from anti -establishment, universalist, peace and love to a highly particular right wing ethno -nationalism. Like that psychological leap just seems absolutely enormous. It seems enormous on paper, but psychologically, Maggot argues, it's actually a very natural progression. The American counterculture of the 60s and 70s was defined by a search for authenticity, a desire to return to the land, a rejection of the sterile mainstream and longing for deep communal living.
Okay, yeah, I can see that. Think about listening to the Grateful Dead, or Bob Dylan, dreaming of a commune. All of that pent -up radical energy was seamlessly redirected into the religious settler movement in the West Bank. Wait, really? Yes. For these young American immigrants, moving to a rocky hilltop in Judea or Samaria felt exactly like moving to a commune. It felt progressive, rebellious, and deeply authentic. Oh wow. They believed they were the vanguard of a cosmic, redemptive shift. They were completely blind to the political reality that, to the Palestinians living in the next village over, these American hippies were operating as an armed occupying force. That is wild. The universalist ideals of the hippie movement just collapsed into a hyper -particularist ethno -nationalism. And because it was all wrapped in the language of spirituality, they didn't even notice the contradiction.
To illustrate this blindness, this incredible cognitive dissonance, Magid shares two incredibly vivid anecdotes. Imagine you are this young spiritual seeker from the American counterculture now living in Israel in the early 1980s. You and a friend who is actually a former Chabad member turned literal shepherd decide to go to the open air market in Nablus. Now, Nablus is a major bustling Palestinian city in the West Bank. Right. You walk in to buy some olives. The tension in the room is palpable because, well, you are Israelis in an occupied city. But suddenly, Magid's friend, the shepherd, just grabs a Palestinian customer and starts joyously dancing with him right there in the market. It's a surreal, almost utopian moment on the surface. But Magid reflects on it years later with profound regret. Why regret?
Because he realizes what he was actually seeing. He saw a robust, rooted, ancient Arab culture that had been there for centuries. And he realized that Zionism had essentially put a net over this world. A net? Yeah. The culture was still breathing underneath. The people were real. But Zionism was operating as if they didn't or shouldn't exist as a political entity. The dancing wasn't a bridge between equals. It was the settler asserting his freedom of movement and his romanticized view of the exotic native, completely ignoring the power dynamic. That is so heavy. And the second anecdote takes place in Gush Katif, which was the block of Jewish settlements in the Gaza Strip before they were evacuated in 2005. Right.
It's a Friday evening. The sun is setting over the Mediterranean Sea. The settlers are gathered on the beach singing L 'cha Dodi, which is this beautiful mystical poem to welcome the Sabbath. It's objectively stunning. Yeah. But Magid looks out the window past the beach and sees the Palestinian city of Khan Yunus. He sees the Palestinians riding donkey carts. He hears the Islamic call to prayer, echoing alongside their Jewish singing. And in that moment, from Aga, the romantic bubble just bursts forever. What does he realize? He realizes that the settlers around him view the Arabs not as neighbors, and not even necessarily with active hatred in that specific moment. It was actually worse. They viewed the Palestinians as part of the flora and fauna. Wow. Flora and fauna. It was pure colonial romanticism. The Palestinians were seen as quaint relics of the past, part of the biblical landscape that Zionism was destined to replace and improve upon. It was a complete erasure of their humanity, their history, and their political agency. They were just scenery. So the cracks in his ideology are clearly forming, but the absolute breaking point comes in the late 1980s during the First Intifada, which was the Palestinian uprising against the occupation. McGee is no longer just a spiritual seeker. He's a 31 -year -old father of three, serving as a combat soldier in the Israel Defense Forces deployed in the West Bank. This is where the soaring theology of Rev Cook meets the brutal, muddy reality of military enforcement. Magid writes so powerfully about the psychological toll of standing in combat here, looking into the eyes of young Palestinian children who, quite understandably, hate him. He writes about the moral degradation of watching elderly Palestinian men be humiliated at checkpoints by 19 -year -old Israeli soldiers who have been given absolute power over their lives. He experiences firsthand the reality of ribonut, which is the Hebrew word for sovereignty, but in this specific context translates to the total domination of another people to maintain control. He writes this really profound line. He says he didn't lose his Zionism in left -wing protests or university seminars.
He lost it in the IDF. Yeah. He realized that subjugating another people wasn't just an unfortunate byproduct of the state. It was structurally necessary to maintain the demographic and political ideology he had adopted. What's fascinating here is how Maugat actually manages the aftermath of this realization. Because when people lose their faith, they often swing to the absolute opposite extreme. Right. But Maged doesn't become anti -Israel in the sense of wanting the state to be destroyed. He coins a term for his new political and philosophical posture. Counter -Zionism. Counter -Zionism, okay. What does that mean? He actively separates the actual physical state of Israel from the ideology of Zionism. He says, look, I support a democratic state for all its citizens, Jews and Palestinians alike, with equal rights and shared sovereignty. Okay. But he completely abandons the proprietary, exclusive ideology of Zionism that dictates the land belongs only to the Jews.
That distinction, you know, separating the existence of the state from the ideology of Zionism, that is a huge conceptual leap. Because for most American Jews today, separating Judaism from Zionism feels like trying to unbake a cake. Absolutely. They are taught that the two are inextricably linked. So Magid uses the next section of the book to systematically dismantle the myth of what he calls the Zionist consensus. He reminds us that historically Zionism was just one menu option for Jewish identity. It's crucial historical context that has been largely forgotten today.
If you go back to the late 19th and early 20th centuries, Zionism was actually a highly controversial minority movement. Really? Oh, completely. It fiercely competed with other robust visions of Jewish future. We mentioned Bundism earlier, which advocated for Jewish socialist autonomy in Europe. It competed with Yiddishism, which saw the Yiddish language and culture as the true Jewish homeland. OK. It competed with classical reform Judaism, which argued that Judaism was solely a religion, not a nationality, and that Jews should just be loyal citizens of whatever country they lived in. And it competed with ultra orthodoxy. which saw political state building as a secular rebellion against God. So the idea that to be a good Jew means you must inherently be a Zionist is a very modern construct. Totally modern, very recent. OK. It really only solidified after the Holocaust in 1948, and it became an absolute dogma after the Six Day War in 1967.
To explore how this ideological monopoly actually plays out today, Maggie contrasts two major contemporary Jewish thinkers, Peter Beinart. and Judith Butler. Yes. Beinart is a fascinating figure. He was the golden boy of mainstream liberal Zionism for years. Eventually, he moved to the political left, publicly giving up on the two -state solution because he saw the reality on the ground. Right. He now advocates for a single equal democratic state for Jews and Palestinians. But remarkably, despite abandoning the core tenet of Jewish statehood, Beinart still insists on calling himself a Zionist.
He clings to the label. And Maggot juxtaposes Beinart with Judith Butler, the renowned philosopher who takes a much more radical and foundational approach in their book Parting Ways. What's Butler's argument? Butler argues that if Zionism is allowed to control the very definition of what it means to be Jewish, then a Jewish critique of Israel becomes logically impossible. If Zionism equals Jewishness, then criticizing the actions of the Israeli state inherently makes you anti -Jewish or anti -Semitic. Which just shuts down all debate.
Exactly. Butler proposes an entirely different framework to break this deadlock. They propose a secular, diasporic Jewishness built around the ethical principle of cohabitation. Cohabitation. Yes. The idea that Jewish identity is historically, textually, and ethically intertwined with living alongside the other, not dominating them through state power. Okay, let's pause on that. Butler's concept of cohabitation. How does that actually work ethically? Because cohabitation implies equality. But history shows that when Jews cohabitated without power, they were often marginalized or killed. Butler isn't being naive about history.
But Butler argues that the ethical core of Jewish tradition, the repeated biblical injunction to love the stranger because you were strangers in Egypt, is fundamentally incompatible with an ethnostate that requires making someone else the marginalized stranger. Right. Cohabitation means recognizing that our existence is always bound up with the existence of the other. For Butler, demanding exclusive sovereignty over a land inhabited by others is a betrayal of the deepest ethical demands of Jewish history. But the mainstream establishment fiercely resists this disentanglement, which leads right into how the gatekeepers of the modern Zionist consensus enforce their boundaries. Maggot cites figures like Gil Troy and Natan Sharansky, who co -authored an essay labeling progressive or anti -Zionist Jewish critics of Israel as un -Jews. It's a really chilling term, un -Jews. Maggot analyzes this weaponization of identity as a form of modern excommunication. Wow. Yeah. By labeling progressive Jews as un -Jews, the establishment isn't just debating their politics. They are attempting to excise them from the community entirely to delegitimize their Jewishness. That's intense.
And Maggot points out a profound historical irony here. Over a century ago, the early secular Zionist pioneers were considered heretics, dangerous radicals, and essentially un -Jews by the traditional rabbis of their time. Oh, because they were secularizing the redemption. Exactly. Now those Zionists hold all the institutional power, and they are using the exact same mechanisms of religious excommunication against their own political left. And this boundary enforcement creates some truly strange political bedfellows, which Maggot covers in a concept he calls the Grand Collaboration. This is one of his most counterintuitive yet brilliant insights.
Maggot looks at the boycott, divestment, and sanctions movement, BDS, which is a Palestinian -led, staunchly anti -Zionist movement, and he compares them to the right -wing Jewish settler movement in the West Bank. Okay, on the surface, these two groups are mortal enemies. They represent the absolute opposite ends of the political spectrum. Right. But Maggett argues they are unwittingly collaborating toward the exact same end, the complete erasure of the Green Line and the death of the two -state solution. Because neither of them believes the current situation is temporary. Exactly. Both groups agree that the occupation is a temporary, reversible paradigm is a total liberal myth. Yeah. The settlers want to formally annex the land to create one Jewish state from the river to the sea. BDS wants to highlight the permanent one -state reality to demand a single democratic state for all citizens from the river to the sea. They are both actively destroying the liberal Zionist middle ground.
They are forcing the world to acknowledge that the two -state solution is a phantom. Okay, I have to jump in here and just push back on Magid's entire framework for a second. Go for it. Because if we divorce Jewish identity from a national homeland, if we say Zionism has run its course and we should return to a diasporic mindset of cohabitation, Don't we risk losing the collective physical safety net that Zionism was built to provide in the first place? Yeah, the safety question. Right. The Holocaust wasn't just a bad chapter in history. It was an industrial genocide that happened specifically because Jews lacked sovereign power and military. How does Maget, or Butler for that matter, address the raw existential trauma that birthed Zionism?
You can't just intellectualize away the need for a sanctuary when history proves what happens without one. That is absolutely the most potent, visceral argument against Maggot's thesis. And to his credit, he doesn't shy away from it at all. Okay. Maggot fully acknowledges the trauma. He acknowledges that Zionism was a necessary counter ideology to violent, eliminationist European anti -Semitism. But his argument, drawing heavily on the political philosopher Hannah Arendt, is that answering trauma with ethno -national supremacy doesn't actually cure the trauma. It just transfers the violence to a new location. It just moves the problem. Yes. Maggot is saying that an ethnostate built on the perpetual military domination of another people is, in the long run, an unsustainable and incredibly dangerous safety net. It guarantees perpetual conflict. Right. He argues that true safety in the 21st century cannot be found behind taller walls or stronger checkpoints. It can only come through democratic equality and shared sovereignty. You cannot build a sanctuary on top of someone else's home and expect to live in peace. And that word ownership is the perfect bridge to move from political safety into theology because secular arguments only go so far in this conflict. Maggot asks a deceptively simple question.
Who actually owns the Holy Land? In secular political discourse, ownership is about treaties, wars, British mandates, and international law. Sure. But Zionism? even in its most secular socialist forms, heavily relies on a foundational theological claim, God gave this land to us. Even secular pioneers who didn't believe in God invoke the Bible as a historical deed to the land. Which is such a paradox. Total paradox. Maggot looks at how early humanistic Zionists tried to grapple with the morality of this claim, and he brings in Martin Buber, the great Jewish philosopher and theologian. Buber's take on this is beautiful, but it is in incredibly demanding of the people living there. Buber points to a specific verse, Leviticus 25, 23, where God says regarding the land of Israel, quote, for the land is mine, for you are strangers and sojourners with me.
Buber interprets this radically. He says that the very concept of Zion inherently rejects human ownership. OK. The Jewish people do not own the land. No, human owns the land. God owns the land. Therefore, Zionism should not be a project of exclusive political dominance or colonial ownership, but a project of humble caretaking. Like stewards. Yes. Dwelling in the land was supposed to be an act of imitatio dei, which means emulating God's justice, mercy, and care for all inhabitants.
Buber believed that if Jews used the biblical mandate merely as a real estate deed to dispossess the Arab populations living there, They were entirely forfeiting their spiritual right to be in the land. The land would literally vomit them out as the biblical warning state. It totally flips the script. The land isn't a prize you win. It's a moral testing ground. And Maggot Pairs Boober's high theology with Hannah Arendt's incredibly grounded political warnings from 1948 right as the state was being founded. Yes. Arendt was a brilliant political theorist who had fled the Nazis. In 1948, she looked at the partition plan and warned that creating a sovereign, exclusive Jewish state in a land deeply populated by Arabs without a framework for shared sovereignty or federation was an absolute recipe for disaster.
What did she predict? She predicted with chilling accuracy that it would lead to a Sparta -like existence. Oh, wow. Yeah. She said the Jewish state would have to exist in a permanent state of war surrounded by hostile neighbors and would be forced to rely entirely on the military and financial backing of distant superpowers just to survive. It would be a fortress, not a homeland. It's eerie how accurate she was. You look at the geopolitics today and she mapped it out over 70 years ago. Totally. But the drive for that fortress -like sovereignty is fueled by a deep generational fear of what happens if Jews remain a minority in the diaspora. And Maggot explores this fear by looking at a completely different kind of thinker, Aviva Kantor, a feminist, socialist, leftist thinker. She asked a question that seems absurd on its face. Are Jews an oppressed people today, specifically in America? It seems absurd because American Jews are... Generally speaking highly assimilated successful and integrated into the echelons of power right statistically speaking But Cantor's argument is deeply provocative.
She says yes Jews are absolutely oppressed in America, but it's an insidious oppression of toleration Oppression of toleration. Yes. She argues that Jews are granted access to power safety and conditional whiteness in America only on the strict condition that they Shed their overt particular Jewishness. They have to assimilate to a white Protestant norm to succeed Okay, I see where she's going you can be Jewish at home But in the boardroom you must be indistinguishable from the Protestant majority Therefore Cantor argues the very condition of being an exile of being a minority is inherently oppressive and psychologically damaging even when it looks economically successful Think about your own professional life for a second, you know Regardless of your background, how much of your authentic self, your culture, your accent, or your traditions, do you feel you have to hide or tone down just to fit into the acceptable corporate norm? It's a universal feeling. It really is. Kantor is saying that for Jews in the diaspora, this constant self -policing is a form of subjugation. If we connect this to the bigger picture, you can see how deeply ingrained the fear of the diaspora is. It's not just the right -wing warning that exile brings anti -Semitic violence. Here you have a leftist feminist arguing that even without violence, the subtle psychological oppression makes the diaspora fundamentally unsafe for authentic Jewish life. This leads her to conclude that immigration to Israel, aliyah, is the only way to be a fully liberated, unapologetic Jew. Exactly.
Maggot highlights Cantor specifically to show how this negation of exile, the belief that the diaspora is fundamentally broken, permeates across the entire political spectrum, from the religious right to the feminist left. It's everywhere. It's the foundational bedrock that Maggot is trying to crack open. He wants to prove that exile is not inherently a pathology that needs to be cured by statehood. Which brings us to the question, if the state exists and if the ideology of exclusive ownership is leading to endless conflict, How do we fix it from within?
How do you deconstruct a state ideology without destroying the people? Yeah, the million dollar question. This brings us to one of the most intellectually thrilling parts of the deep dive. We need to talk about Rav Shigar and his concept of religious post -Zionism. Who was Rav Shigar? Rav Shigar, who passed away in 2007, was an extraordinarily influential and highly unconventional religious Zionist thinker in Israel. He was an Orthodox rabbi. head of a yeshiva who deeply studied post -modern European philosophy. Wait, like who?
Thinkers like Michel Foucault, Jacques Derrida, Jean -François Lyotard. And he seamlessly blended their theories of deconstruction and power with profound Hasidic mysticism. That is a wild combination. It really is. Maggid dedicates a massive section of the book to showing how Chagard developed a theology for the post -Zionist era. To understand why Shigar is so radical, we have to contrast him again with Rev Cook, the pioneer of religious Zionism we discussed earlier. Rev Cook was a classic modernist. He looked at the secular Zionists building roads and farms and fighting wars, and he said, this is all part of a grand divine harmony.
The secular and the holy, the left and the right, are all ultimately merging into one beautiful, unified, redemptive picture. Cook's philosophy was about ultimate synthesis. Everything was moving toward a grand conclusion. But Rav Shigar lived through the late 20th and early 21st centuries. He looked at Israeli society and realized that this grand harmonization had entirely failed. Yeah, big time. The secular and the religious in Israel were at each other's throats. The Jews and the Palestinians were locked in endless cycles of violence. There was no harmony. Shigar realized that you cannot force a unified modernist narrative onto a deeply fractured postmodern reality. OK.
This is where he brings in Foucault's ideas about power and truth and blends them with the Hasidic master, Rebi Nachman of Bratslav, who famously taught about the spiritual necessity of existential doubt and brokenness. OK, explain the how of that. How do Foucault and Hasidism actually mix? Well, Foucault argued that grand unified narratives of truth are usually just mechanisms of power used by the dominant group to suppress minorities. Right. Standard Foucault. And Rebi Nachman. taught that the divine reality is often found in the void, in the places of shattering and contradiction.
Shigar emerges them to say, any attempt by the state of Israel to enforce one unified Zionist truth, whether religious or secular, is an act of spiritual and political violence. Truth is multifaceted and inherently shattered. We live in a broken world and we have to embrace that brokenness rather than trying to force it into a unified whole. And Shigart's philosophical realization isn't just abstract, right? It is crystallized by two massive physical traumas in Israeli society. First, the 2005 disengagement from Gaza, where the Israeli army forcibly dragged thousands of Jewish settlers out of their homes.
Yeah, highly dramatic. And then, a year later, the violent clashes at Ammona, which was an illegal settler outpost in the West Bank, where settlers literally physically fought the IDF, resulting in hundreds of injuries. For Shigar, watching the state violently attack its own citizens in Gaza and watching citizens violently attack the state in Ammona was the absolute death knell of Cooke's harmonious vision. He realized that the state is not a divine, holy instrument of absolute redemption. It's just a state. It is just a state. And like all states, it is prone to violence, bureaucracy, and the corruptions of power. So what is his solution? If the state isn't divine and harmonization is a lie, what do religious Zionists do? This is where Magid highlights Shigar's most radical proposal. Shigar says that the state of Israel must adopt an exilic ethos. It must create exile within sovereignty.
It is a deliberate, radical paradox. Shigar argues that the obsession with ending exile, the belief that we are the masters of our fate and the redemption is here, creates a very dangerous arrogance. When you believe you have achieved total redemption, you become absolute in your righteousness. An absolute righteousness breeds tyranny over minorities, whether that's the secular majority tyrannizing the ultra -orthodox or the Jewish state tyrannizing the Arabs. Shigar says the Jewish people must consciously retain the humility of exile, the sense of the not yet, even while holding sovereign power. They must accept that redemption is incomplete.
But practically speaking, I have to challenge this. How does a nuclear armed nation state with border control, tax policies, and a standing army actually act exilic? You can't just be humble when you're deploying a military or writing zoning laws. Isn't Shigar just dealing in beautiful, unworkable paradoxes? How do you legislate exile? It's a vital question. Shigar isn't saying the state should disband its military. He's talking about the epistemology of the state. how it understands its own power. Okay. Practically, it means legislating without the arrogance of divine mandate. It means if you are creating zoning laws, you do not write them under the assumption that the land belongs exclusively to you by divine right, which currently results in discriminatory housing policies against Arabs. Right. You write them with the humility of a caretaker who knows the state is temporary and flawed. It means leaving structural political room for the minority narrative. It's the difference between a state that says, we are the absolute fulfillment of history, fall in line. And a state that says, we are a safe harbor managing competing broken realities. We must tread lightly. It's like having an incomplete puzzle. Ralph Cook thought you could just press really hard to make a mismatched piece fit. forcing the end. He thought he could finish the puzzle with state power.
But Rav Shigar is saying, no, accept that the piece is missing. Stop banging on the table. The brokenness is the picture right now. That is a perfect analogy. Shigar explicitly warned that to negate exile entirely is to engage in what rabbinic literature calls forcing the end. Forcing the end. Yes. Throughout Jewish mystical tradition, trying to force the Messianic era through human violence or political machinations always results in disaster and bloodshed. By folding the concept of exile back into the sovereign state, you introduce humility, empathy for the stranger, and a tolerance for competing narratives.
You stop trying to force the puzzle pieces together. So if Rav Shigar says we need to bring exile into the state, Maggid takes the final, expansive step to close this argument. He wants to prove that exile isn't just a punishment or a tragedy. It's a historical necessity that has produced immense spiritual wealth. Yes. He does this by reading exile back into history through the lens of four distinct 20th century Jewish thinkers. Let's walk through these because they represent wildly different worldviews, yet they all arrive at the exact same conclusion about the power of the diaspora. The first thinker Maggid analyzes is Rabbi Yoel Tidelbaum. the founding rabbi of the Satmar Hasidic sect. The Satmar are fiercely ideologically anti -Zionist. Tidalbaum approached the concept of exile purely through the lens of Lurianic Kabbalah, a complex system of Jewish mysticism. Let's break that down because Lurianic Kabbalah sounds like pure jargon. Tilebaum believed that when the universe was created, there was a cosmic catastrophe known as the Shattering of the Vessels. Divine sparks of God's light were scattered and trapped inside the material world across the globe. Exactly. And according to this mystical framework, the Jews were exiled by God specifically to travel the globe, dwell among the nations, and gather these trapped sparks to purify the air of the Gentile lands. It was a literal cosmic rescue mission. Wait, gather a spark? Let's pause there because that sounds like pure magic. How does a normal person going about their day in 1950s Brooklyn or 18th century Poland actually gather a spark? Great question.
In Kabbalah, it's not a physical object you pick up. It's about performing a mundane action, like eating a meal, conducting a business transaction, or interacting with a neighbor with absolute holy intention and ethical rigor, according to Jewish law. Oh, I see. It's the idea that every piece of matter, every interaction, has trapped divine energy. By acting ethically and ritually in the diaspora, Jews free that energy. For Tidal Madam, ending exile prematurely by moving everyone to a secular political state in the Middle East ruins this entire cosmic plan. It short circuits the whole thing. Exactly. It's a rebellion against the divine mechanism of redemption. Exile isn't a punishment. It is the fundamental job of the Jewish people. So Tidal Bomb and the Tsotmar are arguing from a deeply mystical, restrictive perspective. But you don't actually have to be anti -Zionist to see the value of the diaspora.
Thinker number two is Rabbi Menachem Mendel Schneerson, the famous leader of the Chabad -Lupovich movement. Yes. He was non -Zionist. He supported the safety of Jews in Israel, but didn't view the secular state as the start of redemption. And his focus was completely different. Schneerson was a visionary regarding the diaspora. He did not view the exile, particularly the American diaspora, as a tragedy or a waiting room. He viewed the exile to America as an incomparable assent. An assent? Yeah. Because America offered unprecedented religious freedom and economic opportunity, he believed it was the ultimate fertile ground to perfect the world.
For Schneerson, The Messianic era wouldn't be born out of military state power in Israel. It would be born out of the spiritual flourishing, the charity, and the global outreach of Jews living confidently in the diaspora. America wasn't a hotel you leave when Israel is established. It was a primary stage for Jewish destiny. But you don't even have to believe in God or divine sparks to see the value of exile, do you? Because Magid also brings in secular voices. Thimmer number three is Isaac Bashevis Singer, the secular Nobel Prize winning Yiddish author. Singer's focus was linguistic, cultural, and deeply historical.
He argued that Yiddish was the literal language of exile, a language built by a wandering people lacking military vocabulary, infused with humor, irony, and longing. Beautiful. But more profoundly, Singer believed that the Jewish people only achieved their unique spiritual and intellectual greatness because they lacked political and military power. Wait, really? Yes. Because they didn't have power. Yes. He speculated that if the Jews had never been exiled, if they had stayed in the land with their own kings and armies, they would have just spent the last two millennia fighting endless territorial wars. They would have become just another forgotten, warring tribe of the ancient Near East. Wow. The marginalization of exile, the necessity of living by the book rather than the sword, is what forged their unparalleled intellectual genius. It's an incredible thought experiment, which perfectly sets up the final thinker, Rabbi Aaron Samuel Tamarez, a Lithuanian rabbi who lived through the early 20th century and became a passionate pacifist. Tamarez argued that the exilic Jew is the ideal human condition.
Why? Because being removed from state power is the only way to perfectly balance religion and ethics. Once you have a nation -state, you have to defend it. You need a military, you need borders, you need real politique. And that inevitably requires violence, compromise, and cruelty. Right. The dirty work of running a country. Exactly. Tamar is believed that exile protected the Jews from becoming violent pursuers. The diaspora, for all its dangers, was the only soil where true prophetic ethics, justice, mercy, peace, could survive untainted by the corruptions of statecraft. When you synthesize these four thinkers, from the ultra -orthodox mystic gathering Sparks, to the global vision of Chabad, to the secular Yiddish novelist, to the pacifist rabbi, they are all warning us about the exact same thing.
Yes, they are. They are asking. Are we losing the very essence of Jewish spiritual genius by trading the humility, the ethics, and the intellectual marginalization of the diaspora for the geopolitics, the border walls, and the military might of a nation -state? That is the crux of Magad's entire project. He is synthesizing these historical warnings to build his pitch for counter -Zionism in the modern day. Maugad is saying we must let go of proprietary Zionism. We must stop pretending that the state of Israel operating as an exclusive ethno -national project is the only valid safe or moral realization of Jewish history. He's arguing that we need to affirm the productivity of exile. We need to value the diaspora not as a backup plan, but as a vibrant center of Jewish life. And fundamentally, for those living inside Israel, he wants a state decoupled from exclusive ethnic ownership, a true state of all its citizens, where Jews and Palestinians can cohabitate, sharing the land without one dominating the other through military force or demographic engineering. It is a radical reimagining of the future. He's asking people to do something incredibly difficult.
To recognize that the ideology that felt so absolutely necessary to save the Jewish people in the 1940s, the ideology that birthed the Biltmore bargain, is the very ideology that is currently preventing a just, equitable, and peaceful future in the 2020s. He wants to decouple the physical safety of the people from the chauvinism of the ideology. And this is exactly why Maggid's work is so vital right now. Whether you're a student prepping for a political science seminar, whether you are deeply invested in Middle Eastern affairs, or whether you are just an intellectually curious person trying to understand the philosophical roots of a very modern, very tragic conflict, Maggid's text challenges the absolute bedrock of what we assume homeland and exile mean. It really does. He forces you to look at the stories we tell ourselves about safety, power, and identity.
He demands that we look at the catastrophic consequences of trying to force the end of history, of declaring that our narrative has won, while ignoring the people we are stepping on to claim that victory. Which leaves us with a final thought to mull over. It's a thought that extends beyond the Middle East, beyond Judaism, to any culture. If Isaac B'sheva Singer is right that the condition of exile, of being the powerless outsider, is exactly what forged a unique spiritual, ethical, and intellectual genius, What happens to the art, the literature, the ethics, and the philosophy of a people once they transition completely from being the marginalized outsider to the ultimate insider with a sovereign military? Yeah. Does comfort, majority status, and state power inevitably kill the very culture it was built to protect?
It is a profound and unsettling question about the nature of survival versus the nature of the soul. Can you save the body while losing the essence? We want to thank you for joining us on this deep dive into the source material. It's heavy, it's complex, but it is necessary. Keep questioning the narratives you are handed. And the next time you hear a political slogan or a demand for absolute territorial ownership or a claim that one group's safety requires another's subjugation, think back to that smoky room in the Biltmore Hotel in 1942. Think about the words we choose, what we are willing to bargain away, and the immense unseen and often tragic costs of declaring that our exile is finally over.