The Necessity of Exile (Shaul Magid): Essays from a Distance
LISTEN TO THIS EPISODE

Shaul Magid reconsiders exile as a resource for Jewish life rather than a condition that political sovereignty simply ends.
Across nine essays, he examines liberal Zionism, American Jewish identity, communal belonging, and the boundaries of political dissent.
Drawing on Hannah Arendt, Martin Buber, Hasidic thinkers, and Yiddish literature, he develops his idea of counter-Zionism.
He asks how Jewish self-determination can coexist with Palestinian self-determination and critiques claims of exclusive ownership of the land.
The book distinguishes antisemitism from structural oppression and explores an exilic ethic of humility and coexistence, including within Israel.
Read about the original source: The Necessity of Exile: Essays from a Distance
Part of Marginalia: books, papers, and ideas for learning and debate.