1 00:00:05,940 --> 00:00:09,340 Felipe: Welcome to Marginalia. I'm Felipe, the creator of the show. 2 00:00:09,767 --> 00:00:13,180 Felipe: I'm a philosopher, neuroscientist and computational linguist. 3 00:00:13,780 --> 00:00:19,340 Felipe: Here we explore books and research, and connect ideas across philosophy, science, history and 4 00:00:19,420 --> 00:00:21,420 Felipe: the arts, AI and technology. 5 00:00:21,900 --> 00:00:25,020 Felipe: We make room for debate, disagreement and learning. 6 00:00:25,073 --> 00:00:25,900 Felipe: I'm glad you're listening. 7 00:00:26,180 --> 00:00:27,780 Essie: And I'm Essie, your co-host. 8 00:00:28,260 --> 00:00:29,700 Essie: I'm an artist and educator. 9 00:00:30,260 --> 00:00:34,900 Essie: I'm interested in how we teach these ideas, too: what someone needs to understand 10 00:00:35,100 --> 00:00:38,180 Essie: before we ask them to reconsider something they believe. 11 00:00:38,260 --> 00:00:40,180 Essie: That's going to come up quite a bit today. 12 00:00:40,530 --> 00:00:45,090 Felipe: We're returning to Dara Horn, the novelist and essayist, and her book The Final 13 00:00:45,250 --> 00:00:48,530 Felipe: Solution to the Jewish Question: A Love Story for the Living. 14 00:00:49,310 --> 00:00:52,850 Felipe: Our earlier episode introduced the book and its account of antisemitism. 15 00:00:53,534 --> 00:00:56,290 Felipe: Today we want to examine her argument more closely. 16 00:00:56,370 --> 00:01:01,170 Felipe: Why does hostility toward Jews survive so much teaching about Jewish persecution? 17 00:01:01,437 --> 00:01:02,930 Felipe: And what does she think we should do about it? 18 00:01:03,130 --> 00:01:06,490 Essie: Before we get to her answer, can we spend a moment on her earlier 19 00:01:06,570 --> 00:01:08,410 Essie: book, People Love Dead Jews? 20 00:01:09,090 --> 00:01:11,930 Essie: Because the problem she's describing didn't begin with this one. 21 00:01:12,170 --> 00:01:17,050 Felipe: Yes. In that earlier book, she asks why institutions can be so invested in 22 00:01:17,130 --> 00:01:21,690 Felipe: remembering Jews who've died, and so uncomfortable with Jews who are alive. 23 00:01:21,797 --> 00:01:25,530 Felipe: She describes a Jewish employee at the Anne Frank House in Amsterdam who wanted 24 00:01:25,610 --> 00:01:28,650 Felipe: to wear his kippah, his Jewish head covering, at work. 25 00:01:28,703 --> 00:01:32,170 Felipe: The museum initially required him to cover it with a baseball cap. 26 00:01:32,310 --> 00:01:34,390 Essie: At the Anne Frank House. 27 00:01:34,443 --> 00:01:39,030 Essie: A museum dedicated to a Jewish girl who had to hide from the Nazis. 28 00:01:39,250 --> 00:01:44,130 Felipe: Yes. The employee appealed, and the museum eventually allowed him to wear the kippah 29 00:01:44,290 --> 00:01:50,050 Felipe: openly. That reversal matters. But he had to challenge the idea that an ordinary 30 00:01:50,130 --> 00:01:53,410 Felipe: Jewish practice was something visitors shouldn't see. 31 00:01:53,650 --> 00:01:58,850 Essie: Mm. I'd expect the history the museum teaches to help its staff recognize that 32 00:01:58,930 --> 00:02:03,810 Essie: problem. It makes me wonder what was missing from their understanding of living Jews. 33 00:02:04,030 --> 00:02:06,510 Felipe: And what they thought a Jew should have to conceal. 34 00:02:07,110 --> 00:02:09,950 Felipe: The kippah is a visible symbol of Jewish identity. 35 00:02:10,430 --> 00:02:16,910 Felipe: For me, Jewish life includes practices, obligations, arguments and a shared history. 36 00:02:17,110 --> 00:02:19,950 Felipe: Those don't disappear when a symbol is hidden. 37 00:02:20,057 --> 00:02:23,630 Felipe: The person is being asked to make that part of their life less visible 38 00:02:23,670 --> 00:02:24,430 Felipe: to be accepted. 39 00:02:24,680 --> 00:02:28,600 Essie: So if we wanted to change that decision, would you start with education? 40 00:02:29,280 --> 00:02:32,440 Essie: Help the people making it understand what they're asking of the employee? 41 00:02:32,790 --> 00:02:34,230 Felipe: I'd want them to understand. 42 00:02:34,703 --> 00:02:38,710 Felipe: But the employee shouldn't need to make Judaism interesting to them before he can 43 00:02:38,790 --> 00:02:42,630 Felipe: wear his kippah. He deserves to participate as a Jew. 44 00:02:42,790 --> 00:02:47,670 Felipe: Asking him to hide a Jewish practice makes his acceptance conditional on concealing who 45 00:02:47,750 --> 00:02:48,230 Felipe: he is. 46 00:02:48,470 --> 00:02:51,830 Essie: I agree that he shouldn't have to earn permission by giving a lesson. 47 00:02:52,550 --> 00:02:57,430 Essie: I'm asking whether better understanding could stop the museum from imposing that condition in 48 00:02:57,510 --> 00:03:01,270 Essie: the first place. As an educator, I'd want to try. 49 00:03:01,650 --> 00:03:06,770 Felipe: So would I. I'm doubtful that learning about Jews will stop the hostility, though. 50 00:03:06,823 --> 00:03:10,690 Felipe: The employee needed the right to wear his kippah whether or not his employers 51 00:03:10,770 --> 00:03:15,410 Felipe: came to appreciate Judaism. We need a way to insist on fair treatment when 52 00:03:15,450 --> 00:03:17,730 Felipe: an explanation hasn't been enough. 53 00:03:17,979 --> 00:03:19,659 Essie: That's a difference we can examine. 54 00:03:20,299 --> 00:03:24,979 Essie: In The Final Solution to the Jewish Question, Horn tries to explain why the 55 00:03:25,019 --> 00:03:29,739 Essie: hostility keeps returning. She also describes an educational project. 56 00:03:30,379 --> 00:03:35,179 Essie: I'd like us to understand what she expects teaching to change before deciding whether 57 00:03:35,259 --> 00:03:36,619 Essie: we share that expectation. 58 00:03:36,969 --> 00:03:43,049 Felipe: We will. First, the concern about being able to insist on fair treatment brings 59 00:03:43,129 --> 00:03:47,769 Felipe: me to Ruth Wisse. She's a scholar of Jewish literature who was Horn's thesis 60 00:03:47,849 --> 00:03:53,929 Felipe: adviser. Horn has described Wisse's commitment to both literature and Jewish survival as important 61 00:03:54,009 --> 00:03:58,329 Felipe: to her. That gives us a reason to read Wisse alongside her, without assuming 62 00:03:58,369 --> 00:04:00,489 Felipe: Horn agrees with everything Wisse says. 63 00:04:00,729 --> 00:04:02,329 Essie: What would you start with in Wisse? 64 00:04:02,929 --> 00:04:06,249 Essie: What argument helps us understand Horn's concern about security? 65 00:04:06,489 --> 00:04:08,169 Felipe: Her book Jews and Power. 66 00:04:09,106 --> 00:04:12,889 Felipe: She asks how Jews can act on our moral commitments when we lack the 67 00:04:13,049 --> 00:04:15,049 Felipe: power to protect our own lives. 68 00:04:15,129 --> 00:04:19,209 Felipe: That's relevant to the museum employee's need to challenge a restriction, as well as 69 00:04:19,329 --> 00:04:21,209 Felipe: to much more dangerous situations. 70 00:04:21,479 --> 00:04:24,919 Essie: Could you explain how she connects morality and protection? 71 00:04:25,079 --> 00:04:27,639 Essie: Then we can ask what choices she thinks Jews should make. 72 00:04:28,019 --> 00:04:30,659 Felipe: Wisse uses the term moral solipsism. 73 00:04:31,299 --> 00:04:36,179 Felipe: It's a difficult phrase for a familiar problem: becoming so absorbed in examining our 74 00:04:36,259 --> 00:04:40,419 Felipe: own conduct that we stop examining what somebody else intends to do. 75 00:04:40,499 --> 00:04:44,179 Felipe: If someone threatens Jews, we can spend all our time asking how we should 76 00:04:44,259 --> 00:04:47,299 Felipe: improve ourselves and neglect the person making the threat. 77 00:04:47,499 --> 00:04:52,722 Essie: Is she objecting to examining our conduct, or to expecting that examination to change 78 00:04:52,802 --> 00:04:54,242 Essie: somebody else's intentions? 79 00:04:54,482 --> 00:04:58,322 Felipe: The expectation. She retains a commitment to moral idealism. 80 00:04:58,869 --> 00:05:02,802 Felipe: But we have to assess what other people want, what power they have and 81 00:05:02,882 --> 00:05:07,762 Felipe: what might constrain them. Being morally faultless wouldn't necessarily purchase our safety. 82 00:05:08,362 --> 00:05:11,922 Felipe: Her argument is that staying alive makes it possible to act on our moral 83 00:05:12,042 --> 00:05:12,802 Felipe: commitments at all. 84 00:05:12,962 --> 00:05:18,082 Essie: Mm-hm. So we still judge our own choices, but we can't make someone else's 85 00:05:18,322 --> 00:05:22,082 Essie: decision to threaten us a problem that better Jewish behavior will solve. 86 00:05:22,322 --> 00:05:23,362 Felipe: That's what I take from her. 87 00:05:23,802 --> 00:05:25,362 Felipe: And it matters to how I read Horn. 88 00:05:26,002 --> 00:05:29,442 Felipe: We can ask what Jews need to do to live freely without beginning from 89 00:05:29,482 --> 00:05:32,082 Felipe: the assumption that we somehow caused the hostility. 90 00:05:32,642 --> 00:05:36,642 Felipe: The people denying us that freedom have choices and responsibilities of their own. 91 00:05:36,882 --> 00:05:38,962 Essie: What political conclusion does Wisse draw? 92 00:05:39,602 --> 00:05:42,802 Essie: I can accept the need for protection and still want to know who she 93 00:05:42,882 --> 00:05:43,762 Essie: thinks will provide it. 94 00:05:44,042 --> 00:05:49,489 Felipe: In a 2015 interview with Moment magazine, she argues for a turn toward conservatism. 95 00:05:49,569 --> 00:05:55,889 Felipe: She criticizes Obama's liberalism and calls for greater emphasis on family, collective responsibility, national 96 00:05:56,049 --> 00:06:00,929 Felipe: commitment and Israel's future. So she does make a recommendation beyond saying Jews should 97 00:06:01,009 --> 00:06:01,969 Felipe: survive. 98 00:06:02,164 --> 00:06:07,604 Essie: Does she mean a broader conservative outlook, or a practical choice about which political 99 00:06:07,684 --> 00:06:12,324 Essie: allies will help Jews? Those could ask very different things of someone who considers 100 00:06:12,404 --> 00:06:13,524 Essie: themselves liberal. 101 00:06:13,844 --> 00:06:17,004 Felipe: In her case, there is a broader conservative commitment. 102 00:06:17,702 --> 00:06:21,884 Felipe: What doesn't follow is that every Jew who shares her concern for security has 103 00:06:22,044 --> 00:06:26,844 Felipe: adopted it. A liberal Jew might support a particular foreign policy because they believe 104 00:06:26,924 --> 00:06:30,844 Felipe: it offers protection, while disagreeing with that party about other things. 105 00:06:31,024 --> 00:06:33,104 Essie: And you'd describe that as a tradeoff? 106 00:06:33,344 --> 00:06:38,944 Felipe: Yes. We deal with overwhelmingly non-Jewish parties, whose priorities aren't ours to set. 107 00:06:39,584 --> 00:06:43,064 Felipe: We may choose the option that offers a more immediate benefit, even at a 108 00:06:43,104 --> 00:06:47,984 Felipe: cost. That doesn't mean we've found an ideology that represents everything we believe. 109 00:06:48,704 --> 00:06:52,224 Felipe: Calling the choice conservative can hide the predicament that produced it. 110 00:06:52,504 --> 00:06:54,431 Essie: I'd still want to examine the cost. 111 00:06:54,991 --> 00:06:59,671 Essie: If a party offers protection and asks for support for something we oppose, the 112 00:06:59,711 --> 00:07:02,991 Essie: need for safety doesn't settle whether that bargain is acceptable. 113 00:07:03,371 --> 00:07:07,291 Felipe: It doesn't. But we should also ask why a Jew is being put in 114 00:07:07,371 --> 00:07:12,891 Felipe: that position. If full acceptance requires giving up other convictions, how secure is the 115 00:07:13,091 --> 00:07:17,211 Felipe: acceptance? That's a connection I see with both of Horn's books. 116 00:07:17,291 --> 00:07:23,211 Felipe: In People Love Dead Jews, remembering suffering can coexist with discomfort toward living Jews. 117 00:07:23,291 --> 00:07:26,731 Felipe: The newer book asks what it takes for Jews to act as people with 118 00:07:26,931 --> 00:07:27,691 Felipe: choices of our own. 119 00:07:27,911 --> 00:07:32,631 Essie: So the question about the bargain includes what the surrounding society is willing to 120 00:07:32,871 --> 00:07:37,271 Essie: accept from Jews. It isn't enough to ask which party a Jew chooses. 121 00:07:37,550 --> 00:07:40,190 Felipe: Right. I think about this as an immigrant, too. 122 00:07:40,750 --> 00:07:44,910 Felipe: Being welcomed on condition that you leave part of yourself out is a restricted 123 00:07:45,110 --> 00:07:49,310 Felipe: welcome. Here, the part you're asked to leave out could be your liberal commitments, 124 00:07:49,470 --> 00:07:52,030 Felipe: or your commitment to Jewish collective life. 125 00:07:52,110 --> 00:07:55,710 Felipe: Why should we have to surrender either one to make ourselves politically legible? 126 00:07:56,110 --> 00:07:59,310 Essie: This is where I want to ask about neoconservatism. 127 00:07:59,390 --> 00:08:04,910 Essie: Wisse has written for Commentary, a magazine closely associated with that intellectual tradition. 128 00:08:04,990 --> 00:08:09,550 Essie: My concern is whether an argument about security is also asking us to adopt 129 00:08:09,710 --> 00:08:12,990 Essie: a broader program about national power and political authority. 130 00:08:13,240 --> 00:08:17,960 Felipe: Mm. Then we need to identify the program she's asking us to adopt. 131 00:08:18,400 --> 00:08:19,800 Felipe: The label can't do that work. 132 00:08:20,400 --> 00:08:24,560 Felipe: And with Horn, I'd reserve it for a political commitment she actually accepts. 133 00:08:24,880 --> 00:08:29,800 Felipe: Studying with Wisse, or taking Jewish security seriously, doesn't establish that commitment. 134 00:08:30,060 --> 00:08:34,940 Essie: Agreed about the adviser. What I want to examine is whether concern for Jews 135 00:08:35,020 --> 00:08:38,860 Essie: leads Horn to trust a use of power she might otherwise question. 136 00:08:38,940 --> 00:08:40,620 Essie: We'd need her own argument for that. 137 00:08:41,100 --> 00:08:42,940 Essie: Wisse's affiliation can't supply it. 138 00:08:43,220 --> 00:08:47,540 Felipe: We would. And I want us to notice the reverse problem: treating a Jew's 139 00:08:47,620 --> 00:08:50,900 Felipe: Zionism as proof that they can no longer be liberal. 140 00:08:51,060 --> 00:08:54,580 Felipe: That erases political commitments rather than examining them. 141 00:08:54,633 --> 00:08:58,540 Felipe: We're not going to settle the larger argument about anti-Zionism here; that deserves a 142 00:08:58,580 --> 00:09:03,141 Felipe: separate episode. For today, let's look at an actual judgment Horn makes. 143 00:09:03,500 --> 00:09:06,060 Essie: Her chapter on universities gives us one. 144 00:09:06,780 --> 00:09:11,740 Essie: In the newer book, she's discussing the federal government's pressure on Harvard in 2025, 145 00:09:12,260 --> 00:09:16,140 Essie: after failures she describes in its response to Jewish students' complaints. 146 00:09:16,620 --> 00:09:22,300 Essie: She objects to the government controlling what universities teach, cutting cancer research and deporting 147 00:09:22,460 --> 00:09:24,860 Essie: foreign students for noncriminal activity. 148 00:09:25,100 --> 00:09:28,380 Felipe: Those objections matter. Where do you think she stops short? 149 00:09:28,630 --> 00:09:33,030 Essie: She ends the paragraph by saying Harvard had “brought this upon itself.” 150 00:09:34,127 --> 00:09:36,470 Essie: I understand why she's angry with the university. 151 00:09:37,257 --> 00:09:41,030 Essie: But I want to know what responsibility that leaves with the government choosing the 152 00:09:41,110 --> 00:09:42,070 Essie: measures. 153 00:09:42,300 --> 00:09:46,900 Felipe: I read her as saying Harvard created the conditions for intervention by failing to 154 00:09:46,940 --> 00:09:51,340 Felipe: enforce its own rules. When I read that judgment, I keep her objections to 155 00:09:51,380 --> 00:09:52,620 Felipe: the government's methods— 156 00:09:52,520 --> 00:09:56,760 Essie: I hear those objections. It's her conclusion about Harvard I'm questioning. 157 00:09:56,960 --> 00:10:00,320 Felipe: Okay. How does that conclusion change what she has just said? 158 00:10:00,570 --> 00:10:05,610 Essie: It makes the university's failure the last explanation we hear for the government's actions. 159 00:10:06,390 --> 00:10:07,690 Essie: Take the cancer research cuts. 160 00:10:08,170 --> 00:10:12,490 Essie: If they don't protect the students, Harvard's earlier failures don't make them a better 161 00:10:12,690 --> 00:10:17,290 Essie: measure. I'd want Horn to keep the government's responsibility for that choice in view 162 00:10:17,370 --> 00:10:20,010 Essie: when she says Harvard brought the crisis on itself. 163 00:10:20,250 --> 00:10:22,490 Felipe: Mm. I see the concern. 164 00:10:23,370 --> 00:10:26,410 Felipe: I still read her explicit objections as doing that work. 165 00:10:26,890 --> 00:10:31,290 Felipe: She can blame Harvard for failing its students and reject the government's response. 166 00:10:31,450 --> 00:10:35,770 Felipe: I don't think the conclusion that Harvard bears responsibility cancels what she has just 167 00:10:35,850 --> 00:10:36,970 Felipe: said about those measures. 168 00:10:37,280 --> 00:10:42,000 Essie: It doesn't cancel it. For me, it leaves the relationship unfinished. 169 00:10:42,640 --> 00:10:47,200 Essie: If she wanted outside intervention, I'd need to know which intervention she would support 170 00:10:47,320 --> 00:10:48,960 Essie: and how it would address the complaints. 171 00:10:49,840 --> 00:10:53,680 Essie: Otherwise I understand her anger better than I understand the remedy she wants. 172 00:10:53,980 --> 00:10:56,140 Felipe: That's a fair question to ask of the passage. 173 00:10:56,680 --> 00:10:58,620 Felipe: Can we make our own answer more specific? 174 00:10:59,140 --> 00:11:03,740 Felipe: The students have reported harassment, and in Horn's account the university has failed to 175 00:11:03,820 --> 00:11:06,940 Felipe: respond. What would you require the university to do? 176 00:11:07,220 --> 00:11:10,260 Essie: Investigate those complaints and apply its conduct rules. 177 00:11:10,900 --> 00:11:14,980 Essie: Tell the affected students who is responsible for following up and what action is 178 00:11:15,100 --> 00:11:17,060 Essie: being taken to protect their participation. 179 00:11:17,780 --> 00:11:23,460 Essie: If the university refuses, I could support outside pressure directed at those failures. 180 00:11:23,540 --> 00:11:26,580 Essie: I'd want to judge the pressure by whether it makes those actions happen. 181 00:11:26,880 --> 00:11:31,600 Felipe: I would too. And if unrelated research is cut while the complaints remain unanswered, 182 00:11:32,000 --> 00:11:34,480 Felipe: calling that protection doesn't make it protection. 183 00:11:34,960 --> 00:11:39,760 Felipe: Those are criteria we're proposing; we haven't found a complete policy in Horn's paragraph. 184 00:11:40,110 --> 00:11:45,070 Essie: No. My remaining concern is about what her paragraph encourages us to examine. 185 00:11:45,790 --> 00:11:50,990 Essie: She identifies serious limits on government action, but her conclusion directs the reader back 186 00:11:51,030 --> 00:11:55,150 Essie: toward Harvard's culpability. I would want her to say more about how the two 187 00:11:55,230 --> 00:11:57,390 Essie: responsibilities are kept distinct. 188 00:11:57,690 --> 00:12:01,290 Felipe: And I think her stated limits give us reason not to read the ending 189 00:12:01,370 --> 00:12:05,983 Felipe: as excusing the government. I also don't want the government's overreach to become a 190 00:12:06,117 --> 00:12:09,770 Felipe: reason to let Harvard's own failures disappear from the discussion. 191 00:12:09,850 --> 00:12:12,810 Felipe: Both actors have to answer for what they choose. 192 00:12:13,210 --> 00:12:14,770 Essie: We can keep that difference. 193 00:12:14,877 --> 00:12:18,290 Essie: It tells us more about our readings of Horn than assigning her an agenda 194 00:12:18,370 --> 00:12:19,570 Essie: from her connection to Wisse. 195 00:12:20,500 --> 00:12:24,930 Essie: It also leaves me with a question about our own suggestions: if a university 196 00:12:25,130 --> 00:12:28,930 Essie: changes its conduct, what would convince you that the change can last? 197 00:12:29,480 --> 00:12:33,320 Felipe: I'd want to know whether the surrounding society's values were changing too. 198 00:12:33,880 --> 00:12:38,200 Felipe: A university can prohibit a practice while people still regard Jewish claims to fair 199 00:12:38,240 --> 00:12:40,520 Felipe: treatment as suspicious or excessive. 200 00:12:41,080 --> 00:12:44,680 Felipe: If those assumptions remain normal, I expect them to undermine the rule. 201 00:12:45,240 --> 00:12:50,040 Felipe: That's why I don't think changing institutional rules by itself can end antisemitism. 202 00:12:50,280 --> 00:12:51,640 Essie: Which assumptions do you mean? 203 00:12:52,280 --> 00:12:56,120 Essie: Could you explain how people learn to see a Jewish claim as suspicious before 204 00:12:56,160 --> 00:12:56,920 Essie: they've considered it? 205 00:12:57,220 --> 00:12:59,580 Felipe: This is where David Nirenberg helps me. 206 00:12:59,660 --> 00:13:05,260 Felipe: He's a historian, and his book Anti-Judaism: The Western Tradition examines how societies have 207 00:13:05,340 --> 00:13:08,860 Felipe: used ideas about Judaism to define what they oppose. 208 00:13:08,913 --> 00:13:12,700 Felipe: Horn explicitly draws on him near the beginning of The Final Solution to the 209 00:13:12,740 --> 00:13:13,900 Felipe: Jewish Question. 210 00:13:14,130 --> 00:13:18,050 Essie: What does it mean to use Judaism to define something you oppose? 211 00:13:18,130 --> 00:13:20,610 Essie: Are we talking about an argument with actual Jews? 212 00:13:20,880 --> 00:13:26,960 Felipe: Not necessarily. Nirenberg distinguishes ideas about Judaism from the lives and beliefs of actual 213 00:13:27,000 --> 00:13:30,720 Felipe: Jews. Imagine Christians disputing how to read scripture. 214 00:13:30,800 --> 00:13:34,720 Felipe: One accuses the other of being trapped in the literal law, and describes that 215 00:13:34,840 --> 00:13:39,680 Felipe: as Jewish. The accusation tells people which kind of thinking to reject, even if 216 00:13:39,800 --> 00:13:41,760 Felipe: no Jew is part of the disagreement. 217 00:13:41,980 --> 00:13:45,820 Essie: Would the people hearing that need to know anything about Jewish interpretation for the 218 00:13:45,900 --> 00:13:46,940 Essie: accusation to work? 219 00:13:47,220 --> 00:13:50,980 Felipe: No. They need to have learned that “Jewish” names the error. 220 00:13:51,060 --> 00:13:54,900 Felipe: That can make actual Jewish thought almost irrelevant to the charge. 221 00:13:54,980 --> 00:14:00,340 Felipe: In Horn's use of Nirenberg, the accusations also shift with what a society values. 222 00:14:00,393 --> 00:14:04,340 Felipe: Jews can be condemned for being too religious in one setting and for undermining 223 00:14:04,420 --> 00:14:09,220 Felipe: religion in another. The same people are made to represent opposite dangers. 224 00:14:09,520 --> 00:14:14,880 Essie: So correcting the factual description of Jews wouldn't necessarily remove the use people are 225 00:14:15,040 --> 00:14:19,360 Essie: making of the accusation. Where does Nirenberg say that habit comes from? 226 00:14:19,660 --> 00:14:22,540 Felipe: He traces it through religious and political thought. 227 00:14:23,300 --> 00:14:28,940 Felipe: Christianity and Islam define their own claims partly through their relationship to Jewish scripture 228 00:14:29,140 --> 00:14:33,420 Felipe: and their rejection of Jewish interpretations that do not accept those claims. 229 00:14:33,900 --> 00:14:38,940 Felipe: He also examines how ideas about Judaism are reused outside religion. 230 00:14:38,993 --> 00:14:42,780 Felipe: The problem isn't confined to an individual's dislike of a Jewish neighbor. 231 00:14:43,030 --> 00:14:46,710 Essie: And what do you take from that history that goes beyond Nirenberg's account? 232 00:14:47,060 --> 00:14:52,260 Felipe: I think the institutions built within these societies keep carrying those values forward. 233 00:14:52,420 --> 00:14:58,180 Felipe: Secular institutions can still expect Jews to give up something particular to become acceptable. 234 00:14:58,260 --> 00:15:03,700 Felipe: My conclusion is that antisemitism has no way to disappear while society continues to 235 00:15:03,900 --> 00:15:07,940 Felipe: define its ideals through opposition to what it calls Jewish. 236 00:15:08,100 --> 00:15:12,100 Felipe: I don't see that as a problem a better explanation of Jews can resolve. 237 00:15:12,550 --> 00:15:18,190 Essie: In his Holocaust Museum interview, Nirenberg says recognizing these habits can help people question 238 00:15:18,510 --> 00:15:21,472 Essie: them. That's the possibility I want to pursue. 239 00:15:21,525 --> 00:15:26,472 Essie: If an institution recognizes a discriminatory rule and changes it, why do you doubt 240 00:15:26,512 --> 00:15:29,152 Essie: that the underlying assumption has changed too? 241 00:15:29,410 --> 00:15:33,570 Felipe: Because changing a rule doesn't necessarily remove the assumption underneath it. 242 00:15:34,130 --> 00:15:35,890 Felipe: Think back to the museum. 243 00:15:35,943 --> 00:15:39,010 Felipe: The employee eventually won the right to wear his kippah. 244 00:15:39,090 --> 00:15:43,891 Felipe: That's a necessary change. But the initial expectation was that he should conceal an 245 00:15:43,971 --> 00:15:48,851 Felipe: ordinary Jewish practice, in an institution devoted to remembering persecution. 246 00:15:49,091 --> 00:15:51,731 Felipe: I don't see that as a small gap in its knowledge of Jews. 247 00:15:52,011 --> 00:15:56,731 Essie: Neither do I. But the employee challenged the restriction and the museum reversed it. 248 00:15:57,435 --> 00:16:01,371 Essie: Do we have to prove that every hostile assumption has vanished before we count 249 00:16:01,451 --> 00:16:03,371 Essie: the change as an improvement in his life? 250 00:16:03,691 --> 00:16:08,571 Felipe: No, but we have to distinguish that improvement from a change in society's values. 251 00:16:09,041 --> 00:16:12,891 Felipe: I'm glad he won. What worries me is that the assumption which made the 252 00:16:13,171 --> 00:16:16,731 Felipe: restriction seem reasonable remains available to the next institution. 253 00:16:17,211 --> 00:16:22,331 Felipe: If society keeps reproducing it, I expect institutional gains to be temporary unless we 254 00:16:22,411 --> 00:16:23,131 Felipe: keep defending them. 255 00:16:23,381 --> 00:16:28,581 Essie: Mm. If recurrence is near-certain, as you expect, I still want to ask whether 256 00:16:28,741 --> 00:16:30,661 Essie: learning can help make a gain last. 257 00:16:31,434 --> 00:16:35,861 Essie: People can recognize an assumption they've inherited and stop treating it as normal. 258 00:16:35,968 --> 00:16:39,621 Essie: That could change the support a rule has outside the institution as well as 259 00:16:39,701 --> 00:16:40,181 Essie: inside it. 260 00:16:40,541 --> 00:16:45,261 Felipe: I would welcome that. I just don't think a successful intervention establishes that those 261 00:16:45,341 --> 00:16:50,141 Felipe: wider values have changed. An institution may comply because it has been challenged, while 262 00:16:50,181 --> 00:16:52,221 Felipe: the society around it remains hostile. 263 00:16:52,621 --> 00:16:56,541 Felipe: We need to judge what happened and retain the power to defend the result. 264 00:16:56,648 --> 00:17:00,541 Felipe: We can't make our safety depend on optimism about the next response. 265 00:17:00,859 --> 00:17:03,419 Essie: I wouldn't make safety wait for that optimism. 266 00:17:04,124 --> 00:17:08,619 Essie: My difference with you is about how much those values can change through learning, 267 00:17:08,779 --> 00:17:11,899 Essie: and how much effort we should put into that possibility. 268 00:17:11,979 --> 00:17:16,139 Essie: Horn offers a story about Jewish life that she thinks could change what people 269 00:17:16,339 --> 00:17:21,099 Essie: recognize. Before we get to the teaching, can we examine the explanation she wants 270 00:17:21,219 --> 00:17:22,059 Essie: people to understand? 271 00:17:22,289 --> 00:17:25,409 Felipe: Yes. Which part of her explanation do you want to test? 272 00:17:25,749 --> 00:17:30,229 Essie: In the later chapters of The Final Solution to the Jewish Question, she connects 273 00:17:30,389 --> 00:17:35,429 Essie: hostility toward Jews to Jewish commitments to human equality and limits on rulers. 274 00:17:35,976 --> 00:17:41,269 Essie: In her account, a tradition that refuses unlimited human authority threatens people who want 275 00:17:41,349 --> 00:17:48,149 Essie: obedience. That is a more specific explanation than saying societies keep using anti-Jewish ideas. 276 00:17:48,399 --> 00:17:52,319 Felipe: Because it identifies something about Judaism that the attacker opposes. 277 00:17:52,919 --> 00:17:55,359 Felipe: We can ask whether the evidence shows that motive. 278 00:17:55,999 --> 00:18:00,079 Felipe: Does Horn give us an example where someone actually attacks the idea of equality? 279 00:18:00,359 --> 00:18:04,999 Essie: She does. She discusses Johann von Leers, a Nazi propagandist. 280 00:18:05,639 --> 00:18:10,359 Essie: In her account, he accused Jews of persuading the world to accept human equality 281 00:18:10,439 --> 00:18:14,439 Essie: as a lie. That is why I find her connection persuasive in that case: 282 00:18:14,959 --> 00:18:20,039 Essie: the hostility she describes is explicitly directed at the idea she says is threatening. 283 00:18:20,279 --> 00:18:23,079 Felipe: Mm. That example supports the connection. 284 00:18:23,799 --> 00:18:26,039 Felipe: My question is how far it reaches. 285 00:18:26,599 --> 00:18:31,639 Felipe: A case in which an attacker opposes equality doesn't establish that opposition to equality 286 00:18:31,719 --> 00:18:33,639 Felipe: explains every attack on Jews. 287 00:18:34,279 --> 00:18:36,679 Felipe: Can we explain other cases without that motive? 288 00:18:36,999 --> 00:18:39,799 Essie: We could test that against Horn's own account of Trent. 289 00:18:40,519 --> 00:18:44,439 Essie: She describes a bishop using a false accusation to build influence. 290 00:18:45,139 --> 00:18:46,519 Essie: Could you walk us through that case? 291 00:18:47,039 --> 00:18:50,919 Essie: I'd like to ask whether her account requires us to believe he feared Jewish 292 00:18:50,999 --> 00:18:52,279 Essie: ideas about equality. 293 00:18:52,579 --> 00:18:58,055 Felipe: Yes. In 1475, a child died in Trent, and Jews were falsely accused of 294 00:18:58,135 --> 00:18:59,975 Felipe: murdering him for a religious ritual. 295 00:19:00,615 --> 00:19:07,095 Felipe: Horn describes the bishop, Johannes Hinderbach, promoting that accusation, with confessions extracted through torture. 296 00:19:07,655 --> 00:19:11,895 Felipe: He was using an existing lie about Jews and Christian children; he didn't need 297 00:19:12,015 --> 00:19:15,015 Felipe: people to understand Jewish beliefs to turn them against Jews. 298 00:19:15,275 --> 00:19:18,635 Essie: What did promoting the accusation do for him, in her account? 299 00:19:18,985 --> 00:19:23,712 Felipe: Horn suggests that he combined a conviction that Jews obstructed his ideals with a 300 00:19:23,792 --> 00:19:26,352 Felipe: desire to strengthen his own influence. 301 00:19:26,459 --> 00:19:30,352 Felipe: He promoted records and images that made his account seem authoritative. 302 00:19:30,432 --> 00:19:34,432 Felipe: So we have a way to explain the persecution through his interests and through 303 00:19:34,512 --> 00:19:37,072 Felipe: beliefs already available to his audience. 304 00:19:37,152 --> 00:19:40,992 Felipe: We haven't had to establish that he was responding to Jewish teaching about equality. 305 00:19:41,412 --> 00:19:45,972 Essie: I see that. It limits how much the equality explanation can establish from this 306 00:19:46,252 --> 00:19:51,572 Essie: example. Horn also describes other authorities trying to stop what was happening. 307 00:19:51,679 --> 00:19:55,092 Essie: What can we learn from their resistance within that same society? 308 00:19:55,392 --> 00:19:57,592 Felipe: There were people who could be appealed to. 309 00:19:57,672 --> 00:20:01,432 Felipe: The local duke and papal authorities sought to interrupt the proceedings. 310 00:20:01,539 --> 00:20:03,512 Felipe: A papal investigator was sent. 311 00:20:03,592 --> 00:20:07,752 Felipe: Horn also describes Jewish communities appealing to authorities for help. 312 00:20:07,832 --> 00:20:11,832 Felipe: Those were attempts to protect people who were being persecuted, and the bishop worked 313 00:20:11,872 --> 00:20:13,192 Felipe: to obstruct them. 314 00:20:13,442 --> 00:20:15,282 Essie: What does the obstruction tell us? 315 00:20:15,842 --> 00:20:20,562 Essie: If some authorities rejected the accusation, why was the bishop able to keep promoting 316 00:20:20,762 --> 00:20:20,962 Essie: it? 317 00:20:21,262 --> 00:20:25,982 Felipe: In Horn's account, he kept the investigator away from the accused and from people 318 00:20:26,062 --> 00:20:27,502 Felipe: who could contradict his version. 319 00:20:28,062 --> 00:20:32,062 Felipe: He also portrayed Jewish appeals for help as improper influence. 320 00:20:32,502 --> 00:20:36,622 Felipe: An effort to challenge the lie could itself be made to look suspicious because 321 00:20:36,702 --> 00:20:37,662 Felipe: Jews were involved. 322 00:20:37,982 --> 00:20:42,542 Essie: Then the resistance matters, but we can't treat its existence as proof that the 323 00:20:42,622 --> 00:20:47,662 Essie: prejudice had disappeared. The people trying to stop the persecution still had to contend 324 00:20:47,742 --> 00:20:49,342 Essie: with that use of Jewish suspicion. 325 00:20:49,682 --> 00:20:51,362 Felipe: Which matters for our disagreement. 326 00:20:51,842 --> 00:20:55,202 Felipe: Those interventions were real. I don't want to erase them. 327 00:20:56,315 --> 00:21:00,162 Felipe: But the bishop was able to use religious assumptions about Jews to make his 328 00:21:00,242 --> 00:21:04,402 Felipe: accusation persuasive and to undermine people who challenged it. 329 00:21:04,482 --> 00:21:08,082 Felipe: Having some authorities resist didn't make those assumptions disappear. 330 00:21:08,382 --> 00:21:12,462 Essie: For me, those attempts to intervene are a reason to ask what could have 331 00:21:12,542 --> 00:21:17,262 Essie: made protection effective. We know the investigator was kept from people who could contradict 332 00:21:17,302 --> 00:21:21,982 Essie: the bishop. I'd want to understand how that access could have been secured. 333 00:21:22,035 --> 00:21:26,062 Essie: There are choices about authority to examine alongside the inherited prejudice. 334 00:21:26,442 --> 00:21:30,442 Felipe: We do. That's why I want to examine the accuser and the people able 335 00:21:30,522 --> 00:21:35,162 Felipe: to constrain him. Horn's account of Jewish equality can tell us something important about 336 00:21:35,202 --> 00:21:40,202 Felipe: Jewish values. The Trent case still needs an explanation of the bishop's campaign and 337 00:21:40,282 --> 00:21:45,322 Felipe: how it gained authority. An admirable account of Judaism can't supply all of that. 338 00:21:45,742 --> 00:21:51,662 Essie: Are you also worried that explaining hostility through Jewish virtues makes respect conditional on 339 00:21:51,742 --> 00:21:56,542 Essie: those virtues? I ask because Horn herself rejects that condition. 340 00:21:56,622 --> 00:22:01,342 Essie: She criticizes the expectation that Jews must prove their worth through their contributions. 341 00:22:01,662 --> 00:22:03,102 Felipe: I agree with her rejection. 342 00:22:03,502 --> 00:22:07,982 Felipe: My objection here is about the explanation of persecution, not a claim that she 343 00:22:08,022 --> 00:22:10,622 Felipe: thinks only admirable Jews deserve protection. 344 00:22:11,102 --> 00:22:15,422 Felipe: Jews deserve safety regardless of whether someone appreciates Jewish ethics. 345 00:22:15,635 --> 00:22:19,662 Felipe: And we shouldn't need to demonstrate what is admirable about us before examining what 346 00:22:19,702 --> 00:22:20,782 Felipe: an accuser is doing. 347 00:22:21,132 --> 00:22:25,692 Essie: Then there's a question we can carry into education: can we teach Jewish life 348 00:22:25,772 --> 00:22:29,852 Essie: in depth without making the lesson a defense of why Jews deserve to be 349 00:22:29,932 --> 00:22:34,252 Essie: here? That's something I want from teaching, and it's something Horn is trying to 350 00:22:34,332 --> 00:22:34,812 Essie: address. 351 00:22:35,362 --> 00:22:40,093 Essie: In chapter eight of The Final Solution to the Jewish Question, Horn describes founding 352 00:22:40,133 --> 00:22:45,693 Essie: The Tell Institute. Its audience includes Jews and non-Jews, in middle schools, high schools 353 00:22:45,773 --> 00:22:50,973 Essie: and Jewish community settings. She wants to teach a story of Jewish choices, law 354 00:22:51,053 --> 00:22:55,053 Essie: and disagreement that helps people recognize the accusations we've been discussing. 355 00:22:55,533 --> 00:22:58,333 Essie: She presents its effect as a hypothesis to test. 356 00:22:58,553 --> 00:23:02,633 Felipe: What would that give a student who has learned about Jewish persecution but little 357 00:23:02,713 --> 00:23:03,673 Felipe: about Jewish life? 358 00:23:03,953 --> 00:23:08,673 Essie: A way to recognize Jews as participants in a living tradition, with arguments and 359 00:23:08,753 --> 00:23:13,233 Essie: choices of our own. For instance, a student could learn how Jewish texts place 360 00:23:13,313 --> 00:23:17,313 Essie: obligations on rulers rather than treating the ruler's wishes as the law. 361 00:23:17,793 --> 00:23:20,433 Essie: Horn connects that to refusal of domination. 362 00:23:21,113 --> 00:23:24,913 Essie: My hope would be that the student becomes less willing to accept a description 363 00:23:24,993 --> 00:23:28,513 Essie: of Jews as people who simply seek power over everyone else. 364 00:23:28,813 --> 00:23:31,293 Felipe: That explains the hoped-for change in understanding. 365 00:23:31,773 --> 00:23:35,533 Felipe: Does Horn claim that a student would then reject a new accusation when people 366 00:23:35,613 --> 00:23:36,573 Felipe: around them accept it? 367 00:23:36,873 --> 00:23:41,913 Essie: She wants to test whether the teaching helps people recognize and resist those lies. 368 00:23:42,020 --> 00:23:44,073 Essie: She isn't presenting demonstrated results. 369 00:23:44,620 --> 00:23:48,153 Essie: And in the introduction to this same book, she says it isn't fair or 370 00:23:48,313 --> 00:23:51,113 Essie: realistic to ask Jews to solve antisemitism. 371 00:23:51,673 --> 00:23:56,233 Essie: Her decision to offer teaching isn't a demand that every Jew become an instructor. 372 00:23:56,613 --> 00:24:01,333 Felipe: I agree. I wouldn't criticize her for imposing an obligation she rejects. 373 00:24:01,893 --> 00:24:05,333 Felipe: I do want to ask about the scale of the educational claim. 374 00:24:05,893 --> 00:24:11,493 Felipe: Early in the book she says education can't inoculate societies built on these lies. 375 00:24:11,600 --> 00:24:16,133 Felipe: When she introduces The Tell, she hopes her teaching can alert and inoculate people 376 00:24:16,213 --> 00:24:19,413 Felipe: against them. What changes between those two claims? 377 00:24:19,663 --> 00:24:23,024 Essie: Mm. The scale might change. 378 00:24:23,544 --> 00:24:29,104 Essie: A program could help particular people recognize an accusation without undoing the society's whole 379 00:24:29,344 --> 00:24:34,624 Essie: inheritance. Since she calls it a hypothesis, I would give that possibility a serious 380 00:24:34,824 --> 00:24:38,704 Essie: test. I wouldn't treat the fact that she hasn't demonstrated a cure as a 381 00:24:38,784 --> 00:24:39,904 Essie: reason not to teach. 382 00:24:40,244 --> 00:24:43,844 Felipe: Nor would I. But I don't want us to narrow the promise on her 383 00:24:43,924 --> 00:24:45,924 Felipe: behalf without saying we're doing it. 384 00:24:46,484 --> 00:24:50,404 Felipe: Helping some students recognize a lie is a worthwhile result. 385 00:24:50,484 --> 00:24:54,164 Felipe: It would still leave the question of how the institution acts when other people 386 00:24:54,244 --> 00:24:58,084 Felipe: believe the lie, or when defending Jews becomes unpopular. 387 00:24:58,324 --> 00:25:01,604 Essie: That's where the institution's own responsibilities become important. 388 00:25:02,324 --> 00:25:04,164 Essie: How are you worried it might use the teaching? 389 00:25:04,434 --> 00:25:08,674 Felipe: My worry is what an institution expects the course to do for it. 390 00:25:08,754 --> 00:25:12,514 Felipe: It could fund some teaching and treat that as its response to a complaint, 391 00:25:12,781 --> 00:25:15,154 Felipe: without changing the conduct that led to the complaint. 392 00:25:15,414 --> 00:25:18,614 Essie: Or it could teach alongside a real response. 393 00:25:18,695 --> 00:25:21,655 Essie: Let's try a school example so we can distinguish them. 394 00:25:21,762 --> 00:25:24,375 Essie: Suppose a Jewish child is being harassed. 395 00:25:24,428 --> 00:25:28,775 Essie: The school asks a Jewish parent to give an assembly about antisemitism. 396 00:25:28,882 --> 00:25:32,055 Essie: The parent wants the other children to understand more about Jews— 397 00:25:31,975 --> 00:25:33,990 Felipe: Has it—has the school stopped the harassment? 398 00:25:34,180 --> 00:25:36,020 Essie: In this first version, no. 399 00:25:36,500 --> 00:25:38,900 Essie: The assembly is the response it's offered. 400 00:25:39,240 --> 00:25:42,600 Felipe: Then the child is still going back into the same corridor tomorrow. 401 00:25:43,160 --> 00:25:46,600 Felipe: The parent is being asked to help, while the school hasn't intervened. 402 00:25:47,200 --> 00:25:49,400 Felipe: That responsibility belongs to the school. 403 00:25:49,760 --> 00:25:51,920 Essie: It does. Let me change that fact. 404 00:25:52,987 --> 00:25:57,360 Essie: The staff intervene when the harassment happens, apply the conduct rules to the pupils 405 00:25:57,440 --> 00:26:02,240 Essie: responsible, and make sure the Jewish child can take part in school activities safely. 406 00:26:02,800 --> 00:26:06,080 Essie: Those actions have happened before anyone asks the parent to teach. 407 00:26:06,300 --> 00:26:08,460 Felipe: What happens after that first intervention? 408 00:26:08,940 --> 00:26:12,380 Felipe: The family needs to know who will follow up if the harassment resumes. 409 00:26:12,660 --> 00:26:16,500 Essie: The principal assigns a staff member to stay in contact with the family and 410 00:26:16,620 --> 00:26:18,180 Essie: check whether the harassment has stopped. 411 00:26:18,860 --> 00:26:22,180 Essie: So now we've described both immediate protection and follow-up. 412 00:26:22,808 --> 00:26:26,980 Essie: If the school then invites the parent to contribute to teaching, is the invitation 413 00:26:27,100 --> 00:26:27,780 Essie: still a problem? 414 00:26:28,160 --> 00:26:32,240 Felipe: It can be. The parent may hear it as: we've dealt with today's incident, 415 00:26:32,520 --> 00:26:36,080 Felipe: but now you need to make sure our staff and pupils understand enough to 416 00:26:36,240 --> 00:26:40,240 Felipe: prevent the next one. A parent can want to say no and still worry 417 00:26:40,320 --> 00:26:42,560 Felipe: that their child's safety will depend on accepting. 418 00:26:42,790 --> 00:26:46,070 Essie: Even when the school has taken the protective steps we've just described? 419 00:26:46,390 --> 00:26:50,790 Felipe: Yes. Those steps matter, but they don't tell the parent who is responsible for 420 00:26:50,830 --> 00:26:52,550 Felipe: the learning that comes next. 421 00:26:52,630 --> 00:26:57,350 Felipe: If the invitation is the school's only educational plan, refusing it leaves the parent 422 00:26:57,430 --> 00:26:59,910 Felipe: wondering whether anything further will happen. 423 00:26:59,990 --> 00:27:02,070 Felipe: I'm not saying refusal is wrong. 424 00:27:02,150 --> 00:27:05,350 Felipe: I'm saying the school shouldn't put that responsibility on them. 425 00:27:05,600 --> 00:27:13,361 Essie: Suppose, um, the school can find a teacher—actually, suppose it's already booked a qualified 426 00:27:13,521 --> 00:27:15,441 Essie: educator and is paying for the work— 427 00:27:15,381 --> 00:27:18,181 Felipe: Already booked, regardless of the parent's answer? 428 00:27:18,371 --> 00:27:20,611 Essie: Yes. The course will happen either way. 429 00:27:21,171 --> 00:27:25,091 Essie: The parent can contribute if they want to, but the school has taken responsibility 430 00:27:25,171 --> 00:27:30,051 Essie: for arranging the teaching. Alongside the protection and follow-up we already specified. 431 00:27:30,291 --> 00:27:33,731 Felipe: Mm. That changes the parent's position. 432 00:27:33,811 --> 00:27:37,571 Felipe: They aren't being asked to supply a class that otherwise won't exist. 433 00:27:37,731 --> 00:27:40,291 Felipe: I'd be more comfortable with an invitation on those terms. 434 00:27:41,011 --> 00:27:44,371 Felipe: It doesn't establish that the school's assumptions have changed, though. 435 00:27:44,451 --> 00:27:47,091 Felipe: We shouldn't make the paid booking prove more than it does. 436 00:27:47,391 --> 00:27:52,271 Essie: I wouldn't. I'd still want the parent to have a real choice to participate. 437 00:27:52,351 --> 00:27:56,031 Essie: They may enjoy teaching about Jewish life or have something they want the children 438 00:27:56,071 --> 00:28:02,031 Essie: to understand. We shouldn't make that choice suspect simply because institutions sometimes demand it 439 00:28:02,151 --> 00:28:03,071 Essie: unfairly. 440 00:28:03,371 --> 00:28:07,091 Felipe: Of course. The question is whether the school will do its work if the 441 00:28:07,171 --> 00:28:12,211 Felipe: parent declines. And its work has to continue after the visiting teacher leaves. 442 00:28:12,371 --> 00:28:16,371 Felipe: What led staff to offer an assembly instead of stopping the harassment? 443 00:28:16,451 --> 00:28:20,131 Felipe: What assumptions made the family responsible for supplying an answer? 444 00:28:20,371 --> 00:28:24,291 Essie: So you'd want the staff to examine their own response, not only arrange a 445 00:28:24,451 --> 00:28:25,891 Essie: lesson for pupils. 446 00:28:26,190 --> 00:28:29,390 Felipe: Yes, and to learn before the next complaint. 447 00:28:30,817 --> 00:28:36,190 Felipe: They can study Jewish history and life, seek expertise and examine ordinary practices that 448 00:28:36,270 --> 00:28:38,190 Felipe: make Jews less able to participate. 449 00:28:38,750 --> 00:28:43,630 Felipe: If they discover that a routine expectation excludes Jewish pupils, they should address it 450 00:28:43,830 --> 00:28:47,150 Felipe: without waiting for another family to exhaust itself explaining why. 451 00:28:47,420 --> 00:28:49,020 Essie: I'd call that education too. 452 00:28:49,580 --> 00:28:53,660 Essie: Staff learning to recognize a problem they had treated as normal could change what 453 00:28:53,740 --> 00:28:58,620 Essie: they do. It reaches further than the single assembly, and it could make protection 454 00:28:58,700 --> 00:28:59,500 Essie: more reliable. 455 00:28:59,750 --> 00:29:05,110 Felipe: It could. I still distinguish that institutional work from a change in the values 456 00:29:05,150 --> 00:29:09,430 Felipe: of the wider society. We need the work, and we need to ask whether 457 00:29:09,510 --> 00:29:13,270 Felipe: the expectations outside the school will keep recreating the problem. 458 00:29:13,830 --> 00:29:18,950 Felipe: The school's responsibility doesn't end with correcting one incident or paying someone to speak. 459 00:29:19,270 --> 00:29:24,310 Essie: No. But if staff carry what they learn into their other relationships, that could 460 00:29:24,350 --> 00:29:25,910 Essie: affect the wider culture as well. 461 00:29:26,630 --> 00:29:28,550 Essie: That's where I remain more hopeful than you. 462 00:29:29,190 --> 00:29:33,030 Essie: I don't think a course guarantees it; I think learning can be part of 463 00:29:33,110 --> 00:29:33,910 Essie: how it happens. 464 00:29:34,330 --> 00:29:36,650 Felipe: That's a possibility I'd want people to pursue. 465 00:29:37,170 --> 00:29:41,770 Felipe: And the responsibility for pursuing it belongs to the society reproducing the hostility. 466 00:29:42,570 --> 00:29:45,370 Felipe: There's a useful comparison with arguments about racism here. 467 00:29:46,010 --> 00:29:50,570 Felipe: The histories differ, but we can ask a shared question: do the people being 468 00:29:50,650 --> 00:29:56,250 Felipe: harmed have to provide every explanation, or must the people and institutions perpetuating the 469 00:29:56,330 --> 00:29:58,330 Felipe: harm learn and act themselves? 470 00:29:59,010 --> 00:30:03,930 Felipe: We're applying that question to antisemitism; the writers I'm about to mention aren't responding 471 00:30:03,970 --> 00:30:04,330 Felipe: to Horn. 472 00:30:04,580 --> 00:30:05,540 Essie: Who are you drawing on? 473 00:30:05,880 --> 00:30:10,600 Felipe: Ijeoma Oluo, a writer on race and racism, in So You Want to Talk 474 00:30:10,680 --> 00:30:15,240 Felipe: About Race. She describes what happens when a person points out racism and is 475 00:30:15,320 --> 00:30:18,360 Felipe: then expected to do more work for the person they've challenged. 476 00:30:18,880 --> 00:30:22,920 Felipe: If you've hurt someone, they don't owe you more emotional labor to explain what 477 00:30:23,000 --> 00:30:29,160 Felipe: you did. You can reflect, investigate, learn without requiring them to continue the conversation. 478 00:30:29,440 --> 00:30:33,040 Essie: That would mean the school can't treat the parent's refusal as the end of 479 00:30:33,120 --> 00:30:37,840 Essie: its opportunity to learn. The staff can still seek information and examine what they 480 00:30:37,960 --> 00:30:38,080 Essie: did. 481 00:30:38,380 --> 00:30:42,780 Felipe: Exactly. And Oluo's argument goes beyond having better conversations. 482 00:30:43,260 --> 00:30:48,140 Felipe: Learning should inform action in the institutions and relationships where people have influence. 483 00:30:48,987 --> 00:30:52,460 Felipe: Applied to our example, the school has to change its own practices. 484 00:30:52,940 --> 00:30:57,420 Felipe: Listening sympathetically to a parent or hiring a speaker doesn't finish that work. 485 00:30:57,780 --> 00:31:02,580 Essie: I'd add Reni Eddo-Lodge's Why I'm No Longer Talking to White People About Race. 486 00:31:03,140 --> 00:31:07,860 Essie: She's a British writer examining racism, and the book's title comes from her exhaustion 487 00:31:07,940 --> 00:31:11,700 Essie: with people who repeatedly deny the structural problem she's describing. 488 00:31:12,380 --> 00:31:15,620 Essie: The refusal is a boundary on those conversations. 489 00:31:15,673 --> 00:31:18,180 Essie: It isn't a claim that nobody can choose to teach. 490 00:31:18,420 --> 00:31:22,580 Felipe: How does she connect that boundary to responsibility outside the person being asked to 491 00:31:22,660 --> 00:31:23,140 Felipe: explain? 492 00:31:23,440 --> 00:31:27,680 Essie: She says the surrounding society has work to do in its own institutions and 493 00:31:27,840 --> 00:31:33,440 Essie: social circles. People can't wait for a person experiencing racism to make every intervention 494 00:31:33,520 --> 00:31:35,360 Essie: or for everyone to agree first. 495 00:31:36,081 --> 00:31:40,561 Essie: That's the part I would carry into our discussion: a school, a workplace or 496 00:31:40,641 --> 00:31:45,121 Essie: a group of friends has responsibilities that aren't suspended when a Jewish person is 497 00:31:45,161 --> 00:31:46,481 Essie: tired of explaining. 498 00:31:46,850 --> 00:31:49,970 Felipe: Yes. And that goes back to the Nirenberg argument. 499 00:31:50,450 --> 00:31:55,650 Felipe: If society has learned to understand its problems through ideas about Jews, Jews didn't 500 00:31:55,850 --> 00:31:59,730 Felipe: create that habit and can't be assigned the job of undoing it for everyone 501 00:31:59,810 --> 00:32:04,850 Felipe: else. Non-Jewish people have to examine the way they think and act, including the 502 00:32:04,930 --> 00:32:07,970 Felipe: claims they pass on when no Jew is there to object. 503 00:32:08,250 --> 00:32:10,730 Essie: Which still leaves room for Horn's chosen work. 504 00:32:11,370 --> 00:32:15,690 Essie: She can offer teaching, and others can take responsibility for learning from it and 505 00:32:15,770 --> 00:32:21,450 Essie: questioning it. The existence of a Jewish educator doesn't transfer the responsibility back to 506 00:32:21,530 --> 00:32:22,490 Essie: Jews as a group. 507 00:32:22,830 --> 00:32:27,310 Felipe: I agree. I want people to read her and other Jewish writers because Jewish 508 00:32:27,390 --> 00:32:32,030 Felipe: life is worth understanding. I don't want our security to depend on whether they 509 00:32:32,110 --> 00:32:37,310 Felipe: come away impressed. The school has to protect the child and examine its practices 510 00:32:37,390 --> 00:32:39,950 Felipe: even if the parent never gives that assembly. 511 00:32:40,290 --> 00:32:44,410 Essie: And I want to find out whether learning helps the staff recognize exclusions they 512 00:32:44,490 --> 00:32:48,730 Essie: previously missed and act before the next family has to complain. 513 00:32:48,811 --> 00:32:52,091 Essie: We still differ on how far that can change society. 514 00:32:52,171 --> 00:32:55,131 Essie: We don't have to settle that prediction to know the school has work to 515 00:32:55,211 --> 00:32:55,931 Essie: do now. 516 00:32:56,311 --> 00:32:59,631 Felipe: There's another part of that responsibility I want to examine. 517 00:32:59,791 --> 00:33:04,591 Felipe: If non-Jewish institutions have to learn, they can't also reserve the right to decide 518 00:33:04,711 --> 00:33:06,751 Felipe: that Jewish knowledge doesn't count. 519 00:33:06,971 --> 00:33:10,731 Felipe: We can make that problem concrete with a different case, about who gets to 520 00:33:10,811 --> 00:33:13,051 Felipe: participate in a campus project. 521 00:33:13,600 --> 00:33:18,880 Felipe: Suppose several student organizations are planning a campus campaign against discrimination. 522 00:33:18,960 --> 00:33:21,200 Felipe: A Jewish student group asks to join. 523 00:33:21,280 --> 00:33:25,200 Felipe: The organizers tell it to condemn an Israeli government policy first. 524 00:33:25,280 --> 00:33:28,240 Felipe: They haven't asked the other groups to answer for a state because of their 525 00:33:28,800 --> 00:33:33,360 Felipe: identity. The university supports the project, and a staff adviser is responsible for its 526 00:33:33,480 --> 00:33:34,560 Felipe: participation rules. 527 00:33:34,780 --> 00:33:37,675 Essie: The declaration is required because they're the Jewish group? 528 00:33:37,955 --> 00:33:40,675 Felipe: Yes. It's an antisemitic loyalty test. 529 00:33:41,235 --> 00:33:46,115 Felipe: The students are being assigned a political responsibility because they're Jewish, then asked to 530 00:33:46,195 --> 00:33:48,675 Felipe: perform a disavowal before they can participate. 531 00:33:49,235 --> 00:33:53,635 Felipe: Their Jewish identity is being treated as a reason to suspect their loyalties. 532 00:33:53,715 --> 00:33:57,955 Felipe: The organizers' description of the demand as political doesn't change what they're doing to 533 00:33:57,995 --> 00:33:58,675 Felipe: the Jewish group. 534 00:33:58,925 --> 00:34:01,565 Essie: Could you explain the history behind that loyalty test? 535 00:34:01,885 --> 00:34:06,765 Felipe: Jews have repeatedly been treated as people whose political loyalty is suspect because they're 536 00:34:06,805 --> 00:34:12,848 Felipe: Jews. The Dreyfus Affair is a nineteenth-century example: Alfred Dreyfus, a Jewish officer in 537 00:34:12,928 --> 00:34:19,248 Felipe: France, was wrongfully convicted of treason in 1894 in a case shaped by antisemitism. 538 00:34:19,355 --> 00:34:24,448 Felipe: His actual conduct was not fairly judged; Jewishness helped make him a plausible traitor 539 00:34:24,528 --> 00:34:25,408 Felipe: to his accusers. 540 00:34:25,678 --> 00:34:30,718 Essie: You're drawing a connection to that presumption of suspect loyalty, rather than equating a 541 00:34:30,798 --> 00:34:33,678 Essie: student-group condition with a criminal prosecution? 542 00:34:33,994 --> 00:34:37,194 Felipe: Yes. The situations and consequences are different. 543 00:34:37,674 --> 00:34:41,994 Felipe: The connection is the demand that Jews answer a political suspicion attached to their 544 00:34:42,474 --> 00:34:46,794 Felipe: identity. In our campus example, the group has to dissociate itself from a state 545 00:34:46,954 --> 00:34:51,754 Felipe: before it's welcomed. That history is relevant knowledge the students bring when they explain 546 00:34:51,834 --> 00:34:53,434 Felipe: why the demand is antisemitic. 547 00:34:53,714 --> 00:34:59,794 Essie: Then the adviser responsible for participation has to examine the actual demand, including who 548 00:34:59,874 --> 00:35:00,754 Essie: was asked to make it. 549 00:35:01,354 --> 00:35:06,354 Essie: The organizers can't settle the complaint simply by saying that they intended political criticism. 550 00:35:06,694 --> 00:35:11,814 Felipe: Exactly. Nor does recognizing the loyalty test require ending political criticism. 551 00:35:12,294 --> 00:35:14,854 Felipe: People can argue about Israeli policy. 552 00:35:14,961 --> 00:35:19,814 Felipe: What needs scrutiny is rhetoric that turns that argument into an obligation imposed on 553 00:35:19,854 --> 00:35:25,014 Felipe: Jews because they're Jews. The institution has to address that conduct, not make free 554 00:35:25,094 --> 00:35:28,534 Felipe: speech and Jewish participation into opposing demands. 555 00:35:28,774 --> 00:35:31,574 Essie: What would addressing it require in the case we've described? 556 00:35:31,874 --> 00:35:36,994 Felipe: The organizers should withdraw the declaration as a condition on the Jewish group's participation, 557 00:35:37,047 --> 00:35:39,314 Felipe: and the adviser should ensure they do. 558 00:35:39,514 --> 00:35:43,052 Felipe: They should also examine how the campaign came to make that demand. 559 00:35:43,132 --> 00:35:47,532 Felipe: Otherwise the students may be admitted while the suspicion that produced the condition remains 560 00:35:47,692 --> 00:35:48,492 Felipe: untouched. 561 00:35:48,732 --> 00:35:53,372 Essie: Mm. So there's an immediate correction and further work for the organizers. 562 00:35:54,172 --> 00:35:58,172 Essie: What if they find another Jewish student who thinks the condition is acceptable? 563 00:35:58,472 --> 00:36:00,632 Felipe: That doesn't erase what happened to the group. 564 00:36:01,112 --> 00:36:05,352 Felipe: Jews can disagree, but finding a Jewish person who approves isn't an answer to 565 00:36:05,392 --> 00:36:10,552 Felipe: the complaint. The organizers still need to explain why Jewish identity triggered the demand. 566 00:36:10,912 --> 00:36:14,872 Felipe: The adviser still has to enforce the participation rules they are responsible for. 567 00:36:15,172 --> 00:36:17,652 Essie: And we'd have to hear the other student's reasons, too. 568 00:36:18,357 --> 00:36:22,372 Essie: We shouldn't assume a different judgment means they don't care about Jewish life. 569 00:36:22,852 --> 00:36:26,692 Essie: But their disagreement can't be used to tell the original group that its knowledge 570 00:36:26,772 --> 00:36:27,812 Essie: no longer counts. 571 00:36:28,162 --> 00:36:33,762 Felipe: I agree. Non-Jewish society doesn't own antisemitism or get to decide its meaning without 572 00:36:33,882 --> 00:36:37,682 Felipe: us. That doesn't require a single Jewish position on every incident. 573 00:36:38,042 --> 00:36:43,762 Felipe: It requires taking Jewish experience and historical knowledge seriously, and answering the actual reasons 574 00:36:43,842 --> 00:36:48,802 Felipe: given. An institution's unfamiliarity with a loyalty test isn't evidence that the test is 575 00:36:48,882 --> 00:36:49,362 Felipe: harmless. 576 00:36:49,662 --> 00:36:53,302 Essie: Nor is disagreement a reason to postpone a decision indefinitely. 577 00:36:53,862 --> 00:36:58,102 Essie: In this case, the condition is clear, and the adviser has a responsibility to 578 00:36:58,182 --> 00:37:02,902 Essie: act on it. The students shouldn't have to produce unanimous Jewish agreement before the 579 00:37:02,942 --> 00:37:05,702 Essie: university deals with the condition on their participation. 580 00:37:06,052 --> 00:37:08,532 Felipe: That's the work I don't want handed back to Jews. 581 00:37:09,012 --> 00:37:14,052 Felipe: We've asked institutions to examine conduct, learn the history and change the practices they 582 00:37:14,452 --> 00:37:18,532 Felipe: control. We haven't asked them to wait until every Jew agrees or until someone 583 00:37:18,612 --> 00:37:20,852 Felipe: has supplied an unlimited explanation. 584 00:37:20,932 --> 00:37:23,732 Felipe: The people with authority can act on the case in front of them. 585 00:37:24,332 --> 00:37:28,492 Essie: Coming back to Horn, the museum example is still the reason I want people 586 00:37:28,572 --> 00:37:33,852 Essie: to read her. An institution can be devoted to remembering Jewish persecution and fail 587 00:37:33,932 --> 00:37:36,412 Essie: to recognize its own exclusion of a living Jew. 588 00:37:37,132 --> 00:37:40,012 Essie: People Love Dead Jews makes that failure concrete. 589 00:37:40,652 --> 00:37:45,052 Essie: The newer book asks what understanding Jewish life might change, and I want to 590 00:37:45,172 --> 00:37:46,812 Essie: test that possibility seriously. 591 00:37:47,132 --> 00:37:50,492 Felipe: What I take from both books is the insistence that we can live as 592 00:37:50,532 --> 00:37:55,372 Felipe: Jews without first proving our usefulness or becoming more acceptable to somebody else. 593 00:37:55,852 --> 00:37:59,932 Felipe: Wisse helps me explain why the power to protect that life matters. 594 00:38:00,039 --> 00:38:04,492 Felipe: We need to make decisions in the circumstances we actually face, and an ideological 595 00:38:04,732 --> 00:38:07,452 Felipe: label doesn't tell us whether those decisions are justified. 596 00:38:07,772 --> 00:38:11,692 Essie: I'm more hopeful about what learning can change in those circumstances. 597 00:38:11,745 --> 00:38:16,252 Essie: The school example helped me specify what I mean: staff understanding a problem they 598 00:38:16,332 --> 00:38:20,972 Essie: had missed, changing their practices and carrying that understanding into other parts of their 599 00:38:21,052 --> 00:38:25,132 Essie: lives. I wouldn't count attendance at a class as proof that any of that 600 00:38:25,212 --> 00:38:25,612 Essie: happened. 601 00:38:26,012 --> 00:38:31,392 Felipe: And I remain convinced that antisemitism will persist while society reproduces the values that 602 00:38:31,512 --> 00:38:37,392 Felipe: make these accusations useful. Institutional gains matter; the museum employee's freedom to wear his 603 00:38:37,432 --> 00:38:41,112 Felipe: kippah matters. But we have to be able to defend those gains when the 604 00:38:41,152 --> 00:38:46,112 Felipe: hostility returns. I won't make Jewish security depend on a promise that other people 605 00:38:46,192 --> 00:38:47,872 Felipe: have finally understood us. 606 00:38:48,192 --> 00:38:52,272 Essie: I also want to keep our question about Horn's historical explanation. 607 00:38:52,352 --> 00:38:56,592 Essie: The von Leers example supports a connection between hostility and equality. 608 00:38:56,672 --> 00:39:00,432 Essie: The Trent case needs an account of the bishop's interests, the people who resisted 609 00:39:00,512 --> 00:39:02,752 Essie: him and the obstacles they faced. 610 00:39:02,832 --> 00:39:08,192 Essie: Teaching the value of Jewish ideas doesn't by itself establish why every persecutor acted. 611 00:39:08,472 --> 00:39:09,752 Felipe: We agree on that distinction. 612 00:39:10,233 --> 00:39:13,033 Felipe: And we still read her Harvard paragraph differently. 613 00:39:13,193 --> 00:39:16,873 Felipe: I give more weight to her explicit rejection of government measures when I read 614 00:39:16,953 --> 00:39:18,553 Felipe: her criticism of the university. 615 00:39:18,853 --> 00:39:22,613 Essie: I want a clearer account of how her final judgment about Harvard keeps the 616 00:39:22,813 --> 00:39:28,373 Essie: government's responsibility in view. That's a disagreement listeners can examine in the passage itself. 617 00:39:28,426 --> 00:39:32,453 Essie: We'll include the source, along with the other books and our earlier episode introducing 618 00:39:32,533 --> 00:39:33,253 Essie: Horn's argument. 619 00:39:33,533 --> 00:39:38,253 Felipe: We'll return to Zionism, political identity and Jewish belonging in a separate episode. 620 00:39:38,573 --> 00:39:41,060 Essie: You'll find the sources in the episode notes. 621 00:39:41,140 --> 00:39:42,820 Essie: Thank you for spending this time with us. 622 00:39:43,070 --> 00:39:47,310 Felipe: And if you enjoyed the conversation, please like the video and subscribe to Marginalia 623 00:39:47,390 --> 00:39:50,190 Felipe: on YouTube. It helps other listeners find the show. 624 00:39:50,350 --> 00:39:50,910 Felipe: I'm Felipe. 625 00:39:51,130 --> 00:39:53,130 Essie: And I'm Essie. Thanks for listening.